I Ran Valuation Analysis On The Most Popular Stocks
I Ran Valuation Analysis On The Most Popular Stocks
Podcast51 min 40 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

MasterCard (MA) is presented as a high-conviction portfolio centerpiece, with analysis projecting a potential 24% compounded annual return driven by strong organic growth and efficient capital use. For value-oriented investors, Adobe (ADBE) and Salesforce (CRM) are highlighted as deeply undervalued opportunities where negative market sentiment has created a significant margin of safety. Uber (UBER) is considered another dislocated asset, offering a potential 26-27% annual return for those comfortable with long-term disruption risk. Conversely, analysis suggests avoiding Tesla (TSLA), as its valuation appears detached from fundamentals, with models showing negative returns even under aggressive growth assumptions. Similarly, Palantir (PLTR) is flagged as a stock to avoid due to an extreme valuation that requires unrealistic growth to generate positive returns.

Detailed Analysis

MasterCard (MA)

  • The host describes MasterCard as a potential "centerpiece" for a portfolio, highlighting its combination of a reasonable valuation, stability, a strong competitive moat, and long-term survivability.
  • The company is praised for its strong organic growth, with top-line revenue growing at 15-16%.
  • It is noted as being capital efficient, with stock-based compensation being a "tiny fraction" of its free cash flow, meaning it does not heavily dilute shareholders.
  • This combination of factors leads to an incredibly fast free cash flow per share growth rate, exceeding 30%.
  • A Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) analysis assuming 20% annual growth and a 3% free cash flow yield (a 33.3x multiple) projects a 24% compounded annual return.
  • The host believes the primary risk is a simultaneous slowdown in growth and a decrease in its valuation multiple. However, even in a bearish scenario with 13% growth, the projected return is still a positive 10%.
  • Category: Dislocated (A high-quality company trading at an attractive valuation).

Takeaways

  • The analysis presents a bullish case for MasterCard, viewing it as an attractive long-term investment.
  • Investors should consider its strong fundamentals, including high organic growth and shareholder-friendly capital allocation.
  • The valuation is seen as reasonable, offering a good entry point into a high-quality business with significant upside potential if growth continues.

Meta (META)

  • Described as an "incredible company" that recently experienced a small dip in its stock price.
  • A key concern highlighted is the high level of stock-based compensation, which makes up a "staggering" 42% of the company's free cash flow. The host dislikes this practice of issuing stock to employees and then using cash flow to buy it back.
  • Despite this, a DCF analysis assuming 18% free cash flow per share growth and a 3% free cash flow yield suggests a 15% annual return.
  • The host believes Meta could easily exceed these growth numbers if it reduces employee expenses or capital expenditures (CapEx).
  • Category: Dislocated (A high-quality company trading at a valuation below its intrinsic worth).

Takeaways

  • The sentiment is bullish, positioning Meta as a decent buy, especially after a price dip.
  • While the high stock-based compensation is a significant negative, the company's growth potential and current valuation are seen as attractive.
  • The investment thesis relies on Meta's ability to continue growing its cash flow, with the potential for even faster growth if management focuses on cost controls.

Adobe (ADBE)

  • The stock has sold off significantly, down 22% year-to-date while the market is up, creating a potential opportunity.
  • A point of concern is that revenue growth is decelerating from ~15% down to ~10%.
  • However, other fundamentals remain strong, with free cash flow per share growing at 14% over the past two years.
  • The valuation is considered very low, trading at a 14 forward PE ratio and a 6.7% free cash flow yield.
  • The primary risks are long-term disruption from increased competition, specifically from Canva on the low end and from generative AI tools.
  • A DCF analysis with moderate assumptions (12% growth, 5% free cash flow yield) still results in a 19% projected annual return.
  • Category: Dramatically Undervalued / Trash Bin (Priced with so much bad sentiment that it creates an opportunity).

Takeaways

  • The analysis is very bullish due to the stock's low valuation.
  • The host believes an investor does not need to assume high growth for the investment to work out; the company just needs to "hang in there."
  • This is an opportunity for investors who believe the market has overreacted to the long-term threats of competition and AI, and that Adobe's business is more resilient than its current stock price suggests.

Amazon (AMZN)

  • The company is described as difficult to evaluate based on its current free cash flow, which has recently plummeted.
  • An earnings-based analysis is presented as an alternative. Assuming 20% earnings per share growth and a 28 PE ratio, the projected return is about 17%.
  • Category: Dislocated.

Takeaways

  • The sentiment is bullish, suggesting the company is undervalued.
  • The investment thesis looks past the current free cash flow issues and focuses on the potential for a strong turnaround and continued earnings growth.

Duolingo (DUOL)

  • Considered a "big battleground stock" due to uncertainty about the impact of AI on its language-learning business model.
  • The company's current numbers show it is "thriving and growing," with free cash flow per share up 49% year-over-year.
  • The host personally views Duolingo as the "Spotify of education" and believes that AI-powered live translation will not eliminate the human desire to learn new languages.
  • A DCF analysis with conservative growth assumptions (15% growth) still yields a 20% projected annual return.
  • Category: Fair Value.

Takeaways

  • The sentiment is neutral to slightly bullish. The valuation is considered fair at current prices.
  • An investment in Duolingo is a bet that the company can continue its strong growth and that its business model will not be fundamentally disrupted by new AI tools.

NVIDIA (NVDA)

  • The company has experienced "astronomically fast growth," but this growth is now decelerating. Free cash flow per share growth has slowed from 111% (over two years) to 38% (in the past year).
  • Future growth is considered "very, very unknown," with potential competition from rivals like Google's TPUs mentioned as a risk.
  • A DCF analysis assuming a slowdown to an 18% growth rate and a premium 2.5% free cash flow yield results in a 10% annual return.
  • Category: Premium Valued.

Takeaways

  • The analysis is neutral, suggesting the stock is fully priced and not a bargain.
  • While positive returns are still possible, they depend on the company maintaining very healthy growth rates for the next five years, which is uncertain. The easy money has likely already been made.

Salesforce (CRM)

  • The stock's valuation has "plummeted" as investors have priced in significant disruption and slowing growth.
  • The host believes the stock is pricing in an excessive amount of "doom and gloom."
  • Even with bearish assumptions in a DCF model (10% free cash flow per share growth), the projected return is still in the double digits. Using slightly more optimistic (but still conservative) assumptions of 13% growth, the projected return is 15%.
  • Category: Trash Bin.

Takeaways

  • The analysis is very bullish on the valuation.
  • Salesforce is presented as a classic value opportunity where market sentiment has become overly negative, creating a large margin of safety. The investment thesis is that the company will perform better than the market's low expectations.

Google (GOOGL)

  • The host notes the stock has moved up from being deeply undervalued ("trash bin") to being more fairly priced.
  • The bull case remains strong, with multiple growth stories still playing out:
    • Cloud growth is still massive and accelerating.
    • The Waymo robo-taxi business is still in its early stages.
    • YouTube continues to be a dominant "monster" asset.
    • Gemini represents a major push in AI-powered search.
  • A DCF analysis assuming 14% earnings per share growth and a 31 PE ratio projects a 14% annual return.
  • Category: Fair Value (or between Fair Value and Dislocated).

Takeaways

  • The sentiment is bullish on the business but neutral on the valuation.
  • Google is seen as a great company with a strong moat that continues to grow. While it's no longer a deep value stock, it is considered a fair price for a high-quality business with multiple ongoing growth drivers.

Microsoft (MSFT)

  • The stock is not considered a "deal today" but is still a "worthy hold" for existing investors.
  • A DCF analysis assuming 16% earnings per share growth and a premium PE ratio in the low 30s projects a 13% annual return.
  • Category: Premium Valued.

Takeaways

  • The sentiment is neutral. Microsoft is a great company, but its high quality is fully reflected in its current stock price.
  • It is positioned more as a stable holding for a portfolio rather than a compelling new buy for value-oriented investors.

Uber (UBER)

  • While disruption risk from autonomous vehicles (Waymo, Tesla) exists, the market seems less concerned, partly because Uber is partnering with these companies.
  • Fundamentals are strong, with free cash flow per share growing at 45%, although this rate is decelerating.
  • Using "very conservative assumptions" in a DCF model (25% growth, 4.2% free cash flow yield to account for risk), the projected return is a very strong 26-27%.
  • Category: Dislocated.

Takeaways

  • The analysis is bullish, viewing Uber as an undervalued company with significant upside.
  • The investment offers the potential for high returns, but investors must be willing to accept the long-term risk of disruption in the ride-sharing industry.

Netflix (NFLX)

  • The host is personally very bullish on Netflix, calling it one of the "most valuable assets."
  • The analysis is complicated by the ongoing M&A situation involving Warner Brothers Discovery (WBD). The host believes a successful acquisition of HBO's content library would be incredibly valuable due to the "operating leverage of content."
  • He notes that Paramount (PARA) is making a competing hostile takeover bid for WBD, creating uncertainty.
  • Despite this, the host's DCF analysis, which assumes >20% free cash flow per share growth, projects annual returns of 19-20%.
  • This is a "contrarian viewpoint," as many analysts view the stock as overvalued based on its high PE ratio.
  • Category: Dislocated.

Takeaways

  • The host presents a strong bullish and contrarian case for Netflix.
  • The investment thesis is based on the power of Netflix's global content machine and its ability to generate massive cash flow, which the market may be underestimating.
  • The potential acquisition of WBD/HBO is a significant catalyst, but the host remains bullish on the stock even if the deal does not happen.

Tesla (TSLA)

  • The analysis is extremely bearish on the company's valuation.
  • The host points out that Tesla's $1.4 trillion market cap is supported by less free cash flow than Netflix, which has a much smaller market cap.
  • Fundamental concerns include stagnating vehicle deliveries, flat revenue for multiple years, declining earnings per share, and falling behind Waymo in the robo-taxi race.
  • The DCF analysis shows that even with an aggressive 40% annual growth assumption for five years, the projected return is negative. To get even a 4% return, you would need to assume 50% annual growth.
  • Category: Cult Status.

Takeaways

  • This is a strong sell or avoid recommendation based on valuation.
  • The host argues that the stock price is completely detached from business fundamentals and is based on a "dream" or "vision."
  • An investment in Tesla at current prices is considered incredibly risky and requires believing in growth assumptions that are seen as unrealistic.

Palantir (PLTR)

  • Like Tesla, the analysis is very bearish on the valuation, calling it "so extreme that there's literally no precedence."
  • The company trades at an incredible 100x price-to-sales ratio.
  • While the business is performing well (positioned as the "official AI company," with 47% YoY growth), the valuation demands perfection.
  • To achieve just a 10.5% annual return, an investor must assume the company grows its free cash flow by 50% every year for five years and maintains a premium 50x free cash flow multiple.
  • Category: Cult Status.

Takeaways

  • This is another strong avoid recommendation based on an extreme valuation.
  • The stock is only for investors seeking "the most extreme high-flying stocks" who are comfortable with the immense risk that comes with a price that has factored in years of perfect execution.

ASML (ASML)

  • The company's competitive moat is described as "the size of the Atlantic," based on unique and difficult-to-replicate physics and science.
  • The valuation is no longer considered "super cheap" but has moved into a more realistic range, with a 31 forward PE and a 2.5% free cash flow yield.
  • A bullish DCF analysis (20% growth) projects a 20% annual return, while more moderate assumptions still yield a solid 15% return.
  • Category: Fair Value.

Takeaways

  • The sentiment is neutral to slightly bullish.
  • ASML is an exceptional company with an unparalleled competitive advantage. While it's not a bargain, its current valuation is seen as fair, offering the potential for strong returns driven by its continued growth in the critical semiconductor industry.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
00:00 Overview 03:00 Mastercard 08:00 Meta 10:24 Adobe 14:20 Amazon 15:02 Duolingo 17:03 Nvidia 18:25 Salesforce 19:25 Google 21:05 Microsoft 21:25 Uber 22:50 Netflix 26:00 Tesla 28:10 Palantir 29:50 ASML 31:30 Paramount Hostile Bid 40:50 Fail Of The Week: Waymo vs Kitkat
About The Joseph Carlson Show
The Joseph Carlson Show

The Joseph Carlson Show

The world of investing is no longer boring. We explore timeless wealth creation principles, current news and drama, as well as commentary and reaction from members of the community.