Why Bitcoin Has Fallen Behind Gold & What Could Come Next
Why Bitcoin Has Fallen Behind Gold & What Could Come Next
112 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast51 min 6 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider a significant allocation to Gold, as global central banks are shifting away from U.S. treasuries, with a potential price target of $10,000 within two years. For a diversified precious metals strategy, a suggested portfolio is 85% Gold, 10% Silver, and a 5% split between Platinum and Palladium. Be cautious with Bitcoin (BTC), which is viewed as a high-risk speculation rather than a reliable store of value due to its volatility and limited institutional adoption. Look for opportunities in Emerging Markets, as many are in stronger fiscal positions than developed nations like the UK and Japan. Finally, ensure your portfolio is well-balanced by including real assets like property and private cash-flow generating businesses for long-term stability.

Detailed Analysis

Gold

  • Guest Vinny Lingham is extremely bullish on gold, viewing it as the neutral reserve asset of the world.
  • He believes the rest of the world is losing faith in the U.S. economy's ability to manage its spending, citing a massive federal deficit.
  • Central banks globally are shifting their reserves away from U.S. treasuries and into gold. Gold has reportedly surpassed treasuries to become the #1 reserve asset for central banks.
  • Lingham believes this trend will continue and has a price target of $10,000 for gold within two years.
  • The gold market is described as very liquid, with a $33 trillion market size.
  • Guest Eric Fine from VanEck reinforces this bullish sentiment, citing "fiscal dominance" as a key driver. This is the idea that governments with too much debt cannot afford for their central banks to raise interest rates, leading to currency devaluation.
  • VanEck's research provides a theoretical price for gold if it were to back the global money supply:
    • $34,000 per ounce if backing the M0 money supply.
    • $189,000 per ounce if backing the M2 money supply.
  • The sanctioning of Russia's central bank reserves was described as a "major event" that has accelerated other central banks' move into gold as a neutral, seizure-resistant asset.

Takeaways

  • The sentiment from the podcast is overwhelmingly bullish on gold as a long-term investment and a hedge against currency debasement and geopolitical instability.
  • Investors may consider allocating a portion of their portfolio to gold as a defensive play against the declining value of fiat currencies, particularly the US dollar.
  • The discussion suggests that gold's role is shifting from a simple commodity to a primary global reserve asset, which could support significantly higher prices in the future.
  • While the price targets mentioned ($10,000, $34,000, etc.) are speculative, they are based on the macro trend of de-dollarization and central bank policy.

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • Vinny Lingham, an early Bitcoin adopter, is now "very, very light on Bitcoin" and has a more cautious to bearish outlook.
  • He argues that Bitcoin has failed to live up to its promise as "digital gold" for several reasons:
    • Insufficient Liquidity: With a market cap around $2 trillion, it is considered too small to function as a global reserve asset. Lingham notes you cannot hedge a large, multi-hundred-billion-dollar position in Bitcoin without taking on "ridiculous" counterparty risk.
    • High Volatility: Bitcoin remains too volatile to be a trusted store of value for large institutions like central banks, who prefer the relative stability of gold.
    • Lack of Institutional Adoption: Central banks are generally not permitted to buy Bitcoin. In a crisis, they buy gold, which drives gold's price up, not Bitcoin's.
    • Stalled Growth: Lingham notes that Bitcoin's growth has "stalled," pointing out that nine years after first hitting $20,000, it is still under $100,000, contrary to the expectations of early believers.
  • A research note from Bitwise is mentioned, which argues that gold and Bitcoin play complementary roles: gold as "defense" in downturns and Bitcoin as "offense" in recoveries. The note concluded that owning both outperformed holding just one.
  • Risk Factor: The quantum computing threat to Bitcoin's security is mentioned as a serious risk that is being "glossed over" by the community.

Takeaways

  • While Bitcoin was once seen as "digital gold," the podcast suggests it has not yet achieved the scale, stability, or institutional trust to compete with physical gold as a primary reserve asset.
  • Investors should be aware of the liquidity and volatility risks associated with Bitcoin, especially for large-scale investments.
  • A balanced approach may be to hold both gold and Bitcoin, using gold for stability and wealth preservation, and Bitcoin for speculative growth potential, as suggested by the Bitwise research.
  • The sentiment is that crypto is more for speculation ("Gamby") with smaller amounts of money, whereas gold is for investing and hedging.

Silver

  • Vinny Lingham believes silver is "definitely overheated right now" after its recent price spike.
  • However, he does not rule out the possibility of it going higher, even to $100.
  • He views silver as much more volatile than gold.
  • In a sample precious metals portfolio, he suggests a much smaller allocation to silver compared to gold.

Takeaways

  • Investors should view silver as a higher-risk, higher-reward precious metal compared to gold.
  • Given the sentiment that it is "overheated," caution is advised. It may be more suitable for traders or investors with a higher risk tolerance looking for beta (higher volatility and potential returns) within a precious metals allocation.

Precious Metals Portfolio

  • For an investor looking to allocate capital to precious metals, Vinny Lingham provided a sample balanced portfolio allocation:
    • 85% Gold
    • 10% Silver
    • 2.5% Platinum
    • 2.5% Palladium
  • The rationale is to have gold as the core stabilizer, with smaller allocations to other metals to capture potential outperformance (beta).

Takeaways

  • This provides a clear, actionable framework for investors looking to build a diversified precious metals portfolio.
  • Gold should form the vast majority of a precious metals holding, acting as the anchor, while other metals can be used for tactical, higher-risk bets.

Zash (XASH)

  • Zash is a new company announced by Vinny Lingham, creating the world's first gold-backed stablecoin with a rewards program.
  • How it works: The stablecoin is backed by physical gold. The gold reserves are hedged to protect against price drops. If the price of gold appreciates, the gains ($2.5 billion in a hypothetical example) are distributed to users as rewards based on their activity.
  • Rationale: The project is built on the belief that gold, not U.S. treasuries or Bitcoin, will be the future global reserve asset. Gold's massive market size allows for the hedging required to back a large-scale stablecoin, which is not possible with Bitcoin.
  • The stablecoin will be chain-agnostic, launching on chains like Ethereum and Solana.

Takeaways

  • Zash presents a novel way for users to hold a stable asset while gaining upside exposure to the price of gold without taking on downside risk.
  • This could be an interesting product for those who are bullish on gold but want the utility and transferability of a crypto stablecoin.
  • It represents an emerging investment theme that bridges traditional assets (gold) with decentralized finance (DeFi).

General Investment Themes & Other Assets

  • Diversified Portfolio: Vinny Lingham emphasized that he has personally moved away from a heavy crypto allocation and is now more focused on:
    • Property / Real Estate
    • Private company equity
    • Cash-flow generating businesses (e.g., restaurants)
  • The core idea is to have a well-balanced portfolio with a "little bit of everything" to perform well over the long term regardless of market conditions.
  • Emerging Markets (EM) vs. Developed Markets (DM):
    • Eric Fine from VanEck notes that many emerging market countries (like South Africa) are in a much stronger fiscal position than developed markets (like the UK and Japan).
    • EM countries were forced to adopt fiscal discipline after past crises, while DMs have continued to "paper over" problems with debt.
    • This could lead to a "reset" where EM assets and currencies outperform those of over-leveraged developed nations.
  • Public Stocks: Mentioned as a form of "investing" rather than speculating. Companies like Apple (AAPL) and Google (GOOGL) are cited as examples of long-term investments. Lingham notes he holds very few public stocks, preferring the illiquidity of private investments.

Takeaways

  • Investors should consider diversifying beyond just financial assets like stocks and crypto into real assets like property and private businesses that generate cash flow.
  • There may be significant opportunities in emerging markets, which are viewed as more fiscally responsible and fundamentally sound than many developed nations.
  • The distinction between investing (long-term, fundamental-driven) and speculating (short-term, price-driven) is a key theme. Investors should be clear about which activity they are engaging in, especially with volatile assets like crypto.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Thank you to our sponsor, Figure! As tensions between the Trump administration and the Federal Reserve rise, gold and silver have surged to record highs. Bitcoin, meanwhile, has struggled to keep pace, raising uncomfortable questions about its “digital gold” narrative. In this back-to-back Unchained episode, Vinny Lingham, cofounder of Xash, and Eric Fine, portfolio manager at VanEck, offer two distinct but complementary perspectives on what’s happening beneath the surface of global markets. Vinny explains why gold’s liquidity, trust, and central-bank adoption still dwarf Bitcoin’s, and why that gap led him to design a gold-backed, reward-bearing stablecoin, USDX. Eric walks through VanEck’s provocative analysis showing gold could reach $39,000 or even $184,000 if the dollar were to lose its reserve-currency dominance and gold had to back the money supply. He also dives into why some developed markets may be more fragile than investors assume. Guests: Vinny Lingham, Co-founder, and President of Xash Eric Fine, Portfolio Manager, Active Emerging Markets Debt at VanEck Links: Why Gold and Bitcoin Work Best Together Why Bitcoin Is Tanking Despite Gold Reaching High After High How Venezuela Shows Why Bitcoin, Crypto and Stablecoins Help Everyday People Bitcoin Rallies to $93,000 After U.S. Attack on Venezuela Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.