Why Bitcoin Has Fallen Behind Gold & What Could Come Next
Why Bitcoin Has Fallen Behind Gold & What Could Come Next
113 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast52 min 6 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider a significant allocation to gold, which is viewed as a primary hedge against currency debasement with a potential price target of $10,000 within two years. For a precious metals portfolio, a suggested allocation is 85% gold, 10% silver, and the remainder in platinum and palladium. In contrast, view Bitcoin (BTC) as a high-risk speculation rather than a safe-haven asset and limit your exposure accordingly. Look for investment opportunities in fiscally sound emerging markets, which may outperform developed nations with high debt. Be cautious of long-term exposure to the Japanese Yen (JPY) and UK Sterling (GBP) due to their potential for significant devaluation.

Detailed Analysis

Gold

  • Guest Vinny Lingham is extremely bullish on gold, viewing it as the world's true neutral reserve asset, surpassing U.S. treasuries in importance for central banks.
  • He believes the trend of central banks buying gold will continue as faith in the U.S. economy's ability to manage its debt declines.
  • Price Target: Lingham predicts gold could reach $10,000 per ounce within two years.
  • Scarcity: He highlights gold's scarcity, noting all the gold in the world could fit on less than 10% of the largest oil tanker.
  • Liquidity: Gold is a very liquid, $33 trillion market, making it suitable for large-scale institutional investment, unlike Bitcoin.
  • Guest Eric Fine from VanEck presented a model showing gold's potential price if it were to back global money supplies:
    • $34,000 per ounce if backing the global M0 money supply.
    • $189,000 per ounce if backing the global M2 money supply.
  • The primary driver for this re-evaluation is "fiscal dominance," where governments have so much debt that their central banks cannot raise interest rates without risking bankruptcy, leading to currency depreciation.
  • The sanctioning of Russia's central bank reserves was a major event that accelerated central banks' shift to holding gold as a reserve asset they control.

Takeaways

  • Gold is presented as a crucial asset for hedging against currency debasement, geopolitical instability, and a potential loss of faith in the U.S. dollar.
  • Consider an allocation to gold as a defensive, long-term store of value. Lingham suggests a precious metals portfolio could be 85% gold.
  • The analysis from both guests suggests significant long-term upside potential for gold, driven by fundamental shifts in the global financial system.

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • Vinny Lingham, an early Bitcoin adopter, is now "very, very light on Bitcoin" and has shifted his focus.
  • He argues Bitcoin has failed to live up to its promise as either "peer-to-peer electronic cash" or "digital gold."
  • Key Criticisms:
    • Insufficient Market Size: With a market cap around $2 trillion, Bitcoin is too small and illiquid to function as a global reserve asset or to back a major stablecoin. Lingham notes you cannot hedge $200 billion of Bitcoin without extreme counterparty risk.
    • High Volatility: Bitcoin remains too volatile to be a trusted store of value for institutions like central banks, who prefer the relative stability of gold.
    • Stalled Growth & Adoption: Lingham states that Bitcoin's growth has "stalled" and it has not been a top-performing asset over the last 4-5 years compared to gold. Central banks are not permitted to buy Bitcoin.
    • Speculation vs. Investment: He categorizes crypto investing as "speculation" or "gambling," suitable for small amounts of money but "dangerous" for large sums.
  • Quantum Computing Risk: Lingham agrees with other analysts that the threat of quantum computing to Bitcoin's security is being "glossed over" and not treated with enough urgency.
  • Complementary Role: A study by Bitwise is mentioned, which found that gold and Bitcoin can play complementary roles. Gold acts as "defense" in market downturns, while Bitcoin acts as "offense" in recoveries.

Takeaways

  • The sentiment on Bitcoin is cautious to bearish. It is viewed as a high-risk, speculative asset rather than a safe haven.
  • Investors should be aware of the risks, including its volatility, relatively small market size for institutional use, and potential future technological threats (like quantum computing).
  • A potential strategy is to hold both Bitcoin and gold, using Bitcoin for potential high growth ("offense") and gold for stability and wealth preservation ("defense").

Silver, Platinum, and Palladium

  • Silver: Lingham believes silver is "definitely overheated right now" but acknowledges it could go higher.
  • He views silver as much more volatile than gold.
  • Platinum & Palladium: Mentioned briefly as other precious metals to include for diversification.

Takeaways

  • For investors building a precious metals portfolio, Lingham suggests a potential allocation of:
    • 85% Gold (as the core stabilizer)
    • 10% Silver
    • 2.5% Platinum
    • 2.5% Palladium
  • These other metals can add "extra beta" (higher potential returns and risk) to a portfolio anchored by gold.

Zash (XASH)

  • Zash is Vinny Lingham's new company, launching the "world's first gold-backed stablecoin that rewards your activity."
  • How it works:
    • The stablecoin is backed by physical gold reserves.
    • The gold position is hedged against downside risk. If gold's price falls, hedges (like put options) would protect the reserves.
    • If the price of gold goes up, the profits are distributed to the stablecoin users as rewards based on their activity.
  • Rationale: The project is built on the belief that gold, not U.S. Treasuries or Bitcoin, will be the ultimate reserve asset. It aims to allow users to participate in the upside of the backing asset, unlike traditional stablecoins like USDC or Tether (USDT).
  • The stablecoin will be chain-agnostic, planning to launch on chains like Ethereum and Solana.

Takeaways

  • Zash is a new, speculative project to watch for those interested in the stablecoin space and who are bullish on gold.
  • It presents a novel model that attempts to combine the stability of a dollar-pegged asset with potential upside from gold appreciation. As a new venture, it carries inherent risks.

Other Investment Themes

  • Emerging Markets (EM):
    • VanEck's Eric Fine argues that many emerging market countries are in a stronger fiscal position than developed markets like the U.S., U.K., and Japan.
    • EMs were forced to adopt fiscal discipline and orthodox economic policies after past crises (e.g., the 1997 Asian Financial Crisis), while developed markets have continued to increase leverage.
    • Takeaway: Consider looking at investments in fiscally sound emerging markets, as their currencies and bonds may outperform those of debt-laden developed nations in the long run.
  • Private Equity & Real Assets:
    • Lingham has personally moved his portfolio away from public stocks and crypto and is "heavier on property" and private, cash-flow generating businesses like restaurants.
    • He prefers the illiquidity of private investments because it prevents emotional selling and encourages a long-term perspective.
    • Takeaway: For investors seeking yield and a long-term strategy, investing in real assets and private businesses that generate consistent cash flow can be an alternative to volatile public markets.
  • Japanese Yen (JPY) & UK Sterling (GBP):
    • Eric Fine's analysis highlights Japan and the U.K. as having highly leveraged central banks, making their currencies potentially vulnerable to a significant reset or devaluation relative to other currencies and gold.
    • Takeaway: Investors should be cautious about long-term, unhedged exposure to the Yen and Sterling, given the underlying fiscal pressures in those economies.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Thank you to our sponsor, Figure! As tensions between the Trump administration and the Federal Reserve rise, gold and silver have surged to record highs. Bitcoin, meanwhile, has struggled to keep pace, raising uncomfortable questions about its “digital gold” narrative. In this back-to-back Unchained episode, Vinny Lingham, cofounder of Xash, and Eric Fine, portfolio manager at VanEck, offer two distinct but complementary perspectives on what’s happening beneath the surface of global markets. Vinny explains why gold’s liquidity, trust, and central-bank adoption still dwarf Bitcoin’s, and why that gap led him to design a gold-backed, reward-bearing stablecoin, USDX. Eric walks through VanEck’s provocative analysis showing gold could reach $39,000 or even $184,000 if the dollar were to lose its reserve-currency dominance and gold had to back the money supply. He also dives into why some developed markets may be more fragile than investors assume. Hosts: Laura Shin Guests: Vinny Lingham, Co-founder, and President of Xash Eric Fine, Portfolio Manager, Active Emerging Markets Debt at VanEck Links: Why Gold and Bitcoin Work Best Together Why Bitcoin Is Tanking Despite Gold Reaching High After High How Venezuela Shows Why Bitcoin, Crypto and Stablecoins Help Everyday People Bitcoin Rallies to $93,000 After U.S. Attack on Venezuela Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.