Uneasy Money: Hyperliquid's Dilemma After 10/10: Protect Itself or Its Users? - Ep. 954
Uneasy Money: Hyperliquid's Dilemma After 10/10: Protect Itself or Its Users? - Ep. 954
169 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast1 hr 10 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider buying Ethena (ENA) as prominent venture fund Multicoin Capital is actively accumulating the token on the open market, signaling strong institutional conviction. For early-stage opportunities, Aztec's upcoming token sale at a $350 million valuation presents a more attractive risk/reward profile compared to other recent offerings. In contrast, Monad's ICO at a $2.5 billion valuation may offer more limited upside potential for investors. A key investment theme is the weakness in decentralized exchanges like Hyperliquid, which has prioritized its own survival over protecting users during volatility. This creates a significant opportunity for competitors like Drift Protocol that are building more user-friendly platforms with better liquidation mechanisms.

Detailed Analysis

Initial Coin Offerings (ICOs)

  • The podcast hosts declare that the "ICO meta is back," signaling a renewed interest in public token sales as a fundraising mechanism.
  • They contrast the current ICOs with those from the 2017-2018 era, noting that valuations are significantly higher now.
    • Monad is launching at a $2.5 billion valuation.
    • Aztec is launching at a $350 million Fully Diluted Valuation (FDV).
    • In the past, major ICOs like Brave (BAT) or Status (SNT) raised around $50-100 million at much lower FDVs (e.g., $60 million for Synthetix/Haven).
  • The involvement of major players like Coinbase in hosting ICOs is seen as a positive development, providing a sense of safety and legitimacy for retail participants.
  • A key psychological difference between ICOs and airdrops was discussed. Buying into an ICO gives an investor a cost basis, making them feel like they've made an investment they want to hold. An airdrop can feel like "free money" that recipients are incentivized to sell immediately.

Takeaways

  • Opportunity: The return of ICOs presents an opportunity for retail investors to get into projects early, a dynamic that has been less common in recent years.
  • Valuation is Key: Be critical of high valuations. A project like Monad at $2.5 billion may have less room for explosive growth (e.g., 5-10x returns) compared to a project with a lower valuation like Aztec at $350 million. The potential for "life-changing returns" is often found in lower-valuation sales.
  • Platform Matters: Participating in ICOs on established, regulated platforms like Coinbase may offer a layer of protection compared to launching on independent or less-proven platforms.

Monad

  • Monad is conducting a high-profile ICO on Coinbase's new launch platform.
  • The valuation is considered high at $2.5 billion, especially given the current market sentiment.
  • The sale has not sold out instantly, which the hosts speculate could be due to the high price or the specific design of the sale mechanism which may not incentivize FOMO (Fear Of Missing Out).

Takeaways

  • High Barrier to Entry: The $2.5 billion valuation suggests that much of the early-stage upside may already be priced in. Investors should carefully consider if the project's potential justifies this high entry point.
  • Limited Short-Term Upside: Unlike historical ICOs that could easily do a "4, 5, 6, 7x," a project starting at this valuation may offer more modest returns, behaving more like a traditional IPO.

Aztec

  • Aztec is conducting its own ICO, described as a "node sale."
  • Its starting FDV is $350 million, which the hosts describe as feeling "cheap" in the current market, especially when compared to Monad.

Takeaways

  • Higher Potential Upside: The relatively low $350 million valuation could present a more attractive risk/reward opportunity for investors seeking significant returns, as there is more room for the project's valuation to grow.
  • Due Diligence Required: Since Aztec is running its own sale (not on a major platform like Coinbase), potential investors should perform extra due diligence on the project and the mechanics of the sale.

Ethena (ENA)

  • Ethena is a project that created USDE, a yield-bearing stablecoin, by tokenizing the "basis trade" (a strategy involving holding a spot asset while shorting its perpetual future to capture the funding rate).
  • The project has seen incredible growth, reaching $6 to $10 billion in supply.
  • Prominent crypto venture fund Multicoin Capital has been actively buying ENA on the open market, a strong bullish signal from a major institutional player. One of the hosts is also a self-proclaimed "big ENA bull."
  • The project's survival and performance during the "10/10" market crisis (a major liquidation event) is seen as a positive sign of its resilience. One host noted they invested a significant amount after it survived this test.

Takeaways

  • Institutional Confidence: Multicoin Capital's public accumulation of ENA lends significant credibility to the project. When a major fund buys a liquid token on the market, it signals strong conviction.
  • High-Risk, High-Reward: Ethena represents a new, complex financial primitive. While it has shown resilience, investors must be aware of the inherent "black swan" risks:
    • Counterparty Risk: The exchanges where Ethena runs its strategy could face issues.
    • Funding Rate Risk: The yield is dependent on positive funding rates. In a prolonged bear market, these rates could turn negative, threatening the model.
    • De-Peg Risk: In a crisis, a rush to exit could cause the USDE stablecoin to lose its peg as the protocol unwinds its complex positions. This is a "duration risk" where assets can't be liquidated fast enough to meet redemption demand.

Investment Theme: Decentralized Exchanges (Perps DEXs)

  • The discussion centered on Hyperliquid, a leading decentralized perpetuals exchange.
  • A major issue was highlighted: Hyperliquid's design prioritizes the protocol's survival over protecting its users.
    • During the "10/10" crisis, this led to an "auto-deleveraging" event and liquidation cascades where users were closed out of their positions at extreme, inaccurate prices (e.g., the price of ATOM briefly went to $0).
  • This user-unfriendly approach has caused prominent traders (like "the white whale") to leave the platform, creating FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, and Doubt).
  • The hosts believe this creates a clear opportunity for competing exchanges that offer better user protection. Drift Protocol was mentioned as an example.

Takeaways

  • Competitive Opportunity: Hyperliquid's focus on protocol safety at the expense of user experience creates a gap in the market. Investors should watch for competing DEXs that innovate on user protection.
  • Look for "Soft Liquidations": A key feature to look for in competitors is a "soft liquidation" mechanism. Drift Protocol was cited for its approach:
    • Using more stable Oracle Prices instead of volatile Mark Prices for liquidations.
    • Implementing circuit breakers to halt liquidations during extreme price divergence.
    • Performing partial liquidations over time, rather than wiping out a whole position instantly.
  • Trading Risk: For those trading on Hyperliquid, be aware that you are at risk of being liquidated at unfair prices during extreme market volatility. The platform has explicitly chosen a design that does not protect you from this.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
In this episode of Uneasy Money, hosts Kain Warwick, Luca Netz and Taylor Monohan explore how the recent ICO boom compares with the 2017 era.  They share stories of some of the big names from the past, including Kain's struggles after raising 30,000 ETH at the cycle top. Plus Luca shares what it takes for founders to thrive in crypto. They also unpack the “FUD” surrounding Hyperliquid following the infamous Oct. 10 crypto crash. Moreover, they discussed what Multicoin's investment in Ethena revealed about Kyle Samani, and potential black swan risks facing the project. Hosts: Luca Netz, CEO of Pudgy Penguins Kain Warwick, Founder of Infinex and Synthetix Taylor Monahan, Security at MetaMask Links: Unchained: Monad ICO on Coinbase Fizzles 12 Hours After Launch Uneasy Money: ICOs Are Back and Why Airdrops Are Instantly Dumped The Chopping Block: Tokenomics Reset — ICOs Rise, UNI Turns On Fees, MEV Goes to Court Hyperliquid Founder Denies Claims That DEX Prioritizes Revenue Over Traders The Chopping Block: Inside the $19B+ Perp Crash, ADL Explained, Binance’s USDe/Staked-Token Depeg, and the Hyperliquid Whale Debate Ethena Labs Expands to Support Two New Products Timestamps: 🚀00:00 Introduction  🎞 1:12 How the new ICO meta compares to the old days ❕️13:48 Why Luca would still airdrop PENGU despite the ICO craze 📽 16:19 New v. Old ICO meta cont'd 😬 26:00 Kain talks about raising 30,000 ETH at the 2017 top 💡27:49 Luca explains what it takes for founders to thrive in crypto 🤕 31:01 Hyperliquid “FUD” and why some of its celebrity whale traders are leaving ➰️45:18 The tension that Hyperliquid faces: protecting the protocol over users 🤔 47:32 Will a new perp DEX champion emerge? 📈 54:03 Multicoin goes long Ethena 🥊54:27 Kain's beef with Multicoin  🎞 59:52 Luca's history with Multicoin  ⚠️ 1:01:43 The real black swan scenario for Ethena Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.