The Chopping Block: Perp Wars & Stablecoin Battles: Hyperliquid, Aster, Tether - Ep. 911
The Chopping Block: Perp Wars & Stablecoin Battles: Hyperliquid, Aster, Tether - Ep. 911
225 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast1 hr 2 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

The PerpDex Wars between decentralized exchanges represent a major investment theme with high growth potential. Hyperliquid is presented as the current leader, demonstrating strong organic growth and durable user activity, making it a higher-conviction play in this space. Be cautious of competitor Aster, as its massive trading volume is likely driven by temporary airdrop farming and wash trading rather than genuine use. When evaluating these platforms, focus on open interest over trading volume to distinguish real activity from artificial hype. Despite Hyperliquid's current strength, this sector is highly competitive, so monitor for new challengers backed by major players like Binance.

Detailed Analysis

PerpDex Wars (Hyperliquid vs. Aster)

• A major theme of the discussion was the "PerpDex Wars," a fierce competition for dominance among decentralized perpetual exchanges, primarily between Hyperliquid and a new, rapidly growing competitor, Aster. • Aster (formerly APX Finance) is backed by EasyLabs (formerly Binance Labs) and has seen a massive surge in trading volume, at one point hitting $30 billion in a single day compared to Hyperliquid's $10 billion. - This volume is viewed with skepticism. Aster's open interest (the total value of active trading positions) is significantly lower than Hyperliquid's ($1.25 billion vs. $10 billion), which strongly suggests that the high volume is driven by wash trading and points farming in anticipation of a token airdrop. - Aster's points program is seen as flawed because it incentivizes takers (who remove liquidity) more than makers (who provide it), a strategy that historically leads to non-sticky, inorganic volume. - Despite these flaws, the speakers warn against underestimating Aster. They highlight that teams with Binance backing are known for their rapid execution and ability to iterate, meaning they could fix their mistakes and copy what works from competitors. • Hyperliquid (HYPE) was considered the clear winner of the PerpDex space until Aster's recent surge. - It has demonstrated more organic growth, with high open interest suggesting real user activity and durable liquidity. - The project is praised for its "masterclass" incentive program, which successfully built a strong, defensible market position (a "durable moat"). - Disclosure: The podcast host's firm, Dragonfly, is an investor in Hyperliquid. • The broader market for perpetual exchanges is described as extremely competitive, where market leaders can be dethroned quickly. The speakers believe these "wars" will likely never end, with new competitors constantly emerging.

Takeaways

• The decentralized perpetuals market is a high-growth, highly competitive sector. While Hyperliquid has proven its model with strong, organic user engagement, the entrance of heavily-backed competitors like Aster shows that no position is safe. • Investors should be cautious when evaluating projects based on trading volume alone. Metrics like open interest are crucial for distinguishing real activity from incentive-driven wash trading. • The success of Aster's token, which reached a $20 billion fully diluted valuation despite questionable metrics, shows that the market can be driven by hype and the influence of major players like CZ (of Binance). This presents both high-risk opportunities and potential pitfalls. • The long-term winner in this space will likely be the platform that can build the most durable liquidity and innovate on product, not just offer short-term incentives.


Tether (USDT)

• The world's largest stablecoin, Tether, is reportedly seeking to sell a ~3% stake in a private placement at a staggering $500 billion valuation. • The company's financials are incredibly strong: - It claims a $5 billion profit in Q2 alone. - It operates with 99% gross margins. - It has $172 billion in circulating stablecoins (USDT). • There was a strong debate among the speakers about whether this valuation is justified. - The Bull Case: Tether is an "untouchable" cash-flow machine with a powerful moat in emerging markets and crypto trading. Its business is far more efficient and profitable than its main competitor, Circle (USDC). The speakers argue that Tether's ability to avoid revenue-sharing deals and its dominance in high-margin markets justifies a massive premium. One speaker suggested it could evolve into a Berkshire Hathaway-like private investment company, using its massive float to invest in other assets. - The Bearish Case: A $500 billion valuation is a "terrible deal." On a comparative basis with Circle, Tether is asking for a valuation that is roughly 6 times more expensive relative to its stablecoin supply. The speaker argues that Tether is timing this sale perfectly at the peak of its profitability, as its income is highly dependent on interest rates, which are expected to fall. A fair value might be closer to $200 billion.

Takeaways

Tether is a private company, so this investment opportunity is not available to the general public. However, the discussion provides a fascinating look into one of the most profitable and controversial companies in crypto. • The $500 billion valuation is likely an ambitious opening bid to attract attention from the small number of global investors who can write billion-dollar checks. The final deal, if it happens, may be at a lower valuation. • Tether's business model is highly sensitive to interest rates. As the Federal Reserve cuts rates, Tether's profits from its reserves will decrease, which is a key risk factor for its valuation. • The company is unlikely to go public (IPO) due to its desire to remain private and avoid strict US regulatory oversight, making any private investment highly illiquid.


Circle (USDC)

Circle, the issuer of the USDC stablecoin, was frequently used as a point of comparison for Tether's valuation. • The sentiment towards Circle as a business was largely negative. - It was described as a "terrible business" and "inefficient" compared to Tether. - Its Q2 adjusted EBITDA was only $126 million, a tiny fraction of Tether's reported profit, despite managing a large $74 billion supply of USDC. - The speakers believe Circle is in a weaker competitive position, forced to strike revenue-sharing deals with exchanges and partners that erode its profit margins.

Takeaways

• The stablecoin market is not a "winner-take-all" market. Different stablecoins dominate different niches. USDC is the dominant stablecoin in DeFi, while USDT dominates in emerging markets and on centralized exchanges. • Despite its strong presence in DeFi, Circle's business appears to be significantly less profitable than Tether's. This highlights that market share in stablecoins does not automatically translate to high profitability, as the underlying business models and target markets can be very different. • For investors looking at the stablecoin space, this suggests that the "picks and shovels" businesses that enable stablecoin usage (like RAIN, discussed next) may offer interesting opportunities beyond just the issuers themselves.


RAIN (Private Company)

RAIN is a B2B stablecoin payments platform that acts as the "connective tissue" between the traditional financial system (like Visa/Mastercard) and the new world of stablecoins. • The company provides infrastructure for other businesses (fintechs, exchanges, etc.) to offer products like stablecoin-powered debit/credit cards. This allows users to spend their stablecoin balances at any merchant that accepts traditional card payments. • Disclosure: The podcast host's firm, Dragonfly, is an investor in RAIN. The company recently raised $58 million. • The platform is seeing explosive growth, with every customer cohort growing week-over-week. This is driven by real-world use cases: - Payroll and Earned Wage Access: Workers can get paid in stablecoins 24/7 and spend the money instantly. - Small Business Payments: Businesses in countries like Argentina and Brazil are using RAIN-powered cards to import goods from China more cheaply than using traditional bank wires. - DeFi-Powered Credit: Users can borrow against their crypto holdings in a DeFi protocol and spend the funds instantly using a card, without ever selling their underlying assets.

Takeaways

RAIN represents a "picks and shovels" investment opportunity in the stablecoin ecosystem. Instead of betting on a single stablecoin, it profits from the overall growth and adoption of all stablecoins for payments. • The company's success demonstrates the powerful, non-speculative demand for stablecoins, particularly for cross-border commerce, savings in high-inflation countries, and creating more efficient financial products. • The key innovation is bridging the gap between crypto and traditional finance. By allowing stablecoins to be spent on existing card networks, it overcomes the major hurdle of merchant adoption, making stablecoins useful for everyday life. • The growth metrics suggest a strong product-market fit and a significant, untapped market for businesses looking to build on top of stablecoin rails. This is a key area to watch for the future of finance.

Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Welcome to The Chopping Block – where crypto insiders Haseeb Qureshi, Tom Schmidt, Tarun Chitra, and Robert Leshner chop it up about the latest in crypto. This week, we’re joined by Farooq Malik, co-founder and CEO of Rain, as two parallel wars erupt across crypto: the Perp DEX war between Hyperliquid and the CZ-backed Aster, and the deepening battle for stablecoin dominance. As Aster rockets to $30B in daily volume, we debate whether it’s real adoption or points-fueled froth — and what it means for Hyperliquid’s lead. Then we dive into Tether’s shocking $500B valuation play, Circle’s shrinking moat, and how Rain is building real-world rails for stablecoin payments. If crypto has two new battlegrounds — trading venues and money itself — this is where the future is getting drawn. Show highlights 🔹 DEX Wars: Aster vs. Hyperliquid – Aster hits $30B daily volume; is it real demand or a points-fueled surge? Hyperliquid’s dominance faces its first real threat. 🔹 CZ’s Return to Form – Aster’s Binance links, aggressive fee model, and possible “James Wynn” conspiracy theory raise the stakes in the perp DEX arena. 🔹 Wash Trading & Open Interest Gaps – Aster’s $2B TVL contrasts with $1.25B open interest vs. Hyperliquid’s $10B, sparking questions about organic traction. 🔹 Incentive Wars – Aster rewards takers 2x over makers; Hyperliquid and Blur praised for long-game design that built sticky liquidity instead of short-term volume. 🔹 The Execution Advantage – Haseeb: “Asia executes better than it innovates”; Aster may stumble now but could out-iterate and outscale its rivals. 🔹 Stablecoin Shockwave: Tether’s $500B Valuation Leak – Tether quietly seeks $15–20B in private funding, aiming for a $500B valuation—matching OpenAI and SpaceX. 🔹 Circle vs. Tether – Circle trades at 0.5x supply, Tether seeks 3x; the panel debates margins, moat, and whether USDC can survive the “reverse momentum.” 🔹 Rain’s Real-World Stablecoin Rails – Farooq Malik shares how Rain powers payroll, P2P, cards, and merchant payments on stablecoins—without touching fiat. 🔹 New Use Cases: Stablecoins in the Wild – On-chain credit cards, just-in-time lending, cross-border Facebook ad funding, and more—all enabled by 24/7 money. 🔹 Global Adoption: LatAm, MENA, Asia – Rain’s data shows stablecoin usage exploding outside the U.S., especially in regions with FX controls and unstable banks. Hosts ⭐️Haseeb Qureshi, Managing Partner at Dragonfly ⭐️Robert Leshner, CEO & Co-founder of Superstate ⭐️Tom Schmidt, General Partner at Dragonfly  Guest ⭐️Farooq Malik, Co-Founder & CEO of Rain ⁠Disclosures⁠ Timestamps 00:00 Intro 01:02 Aster vs. Hyperliquid 14:25 Regulatory Capture: L2s, Sequencers, CFTC 26:08 Tether’s $500B Valuation: Bubble or Bargain? 31:36 Tether vs. Circle: Stablecoin Economics 42:56 Rain: Stablecoin Payments Infra 47:16 Stablecoin Use Cases; Cards, Payroll, P2P 54:04 Global Stablecoin Growth Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.