DAT Stocks Are on Sale. Are They a Buy? Plus, Why Crypto Is Dead - Ep.945
DAT Stocks Are on Sale. Are They a Buy? Plus, Why Crypto Is Dead - Ep.945
140 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast54 min 10 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider investing in Digital Asset Treasuries (DATs), which are companies holding crypto that currently trade at a significant discount to their underlying asset value. Many of these stocks, such as Nakamoto (NACA) and ETHZilla, are trading at a Multiple of Net Asset Value (MNAV) around 0.5, offering a way to buy their crypto holdings for roughly half the market price. This strategy is a long-term value play, betting that this discount will close over time, providing returns on top of any appreciation in Bitcoin or Ethereum. For those bullish on Ethereum, ETHZilla is a notable option as it can generate additional yield by staking its holdings. Be cautious and research individual names, avoiding companies like Ether Machine which face massive future share dilution that will erase its apparent discount.

Detailed Analysis

Digital Asset Treasuries (DATs)

  • Digital Asset Treasuries (DATs) are publicly traded companies that hold significant amounts of cryptocurrency, like Bitcoin and Ethereum, on their balance sheets, following a strategy popularized by MicroStrategy (MSTR).
  • Many of these stocks are currently trading at a significant discount to the value of the crypto they hold. This is measured by the MNAV (Multiple of Net Asset Value), which is similar to a price-to-book ratio.
    • An MNAV below 1 means the company's market capitalization is less than the value of its crypto assets, indicating a discount.
    • During the bull market, many DATs traded at a premium (MNAV > 1). Now, with negative sentiment, they have flipped to a discount.
  • The podcast discusses whether these discounted DATs represent a good buying opportunity. The consensus from experts interviewed is that the long-term, stable MNAV for these companies should be around 1.
  • Several specific DATs were mentioned with their current MNAVs:
    • 21 Capital and Tether: Trading at an MNAV of 0.5.
    • Nakamoto (KindlyMD - TICKER: NACA): Trading at an MNAV of 0.53.
      • Risk Factor: The company received a delisting warning from NASDAQ for its stock trading below $1 for 30 consecutive days. However, the analyst noted this is not a major concern as it can be resolved with a reverse stock split.
    • Similar scientific: Trading at an MNAV of 0.57.
      • Potential Catalyst: Strive (Vivek Ramaswamy's group) is looking to acquire the company at a "very large premium" to its current share price. However, the deal was arranged in September before the recent market crash and may not close.
    • ProCap Financial (Anthony Pompliano's group): Trading at an MNAV of 0.7.
    • ETHZilla: An Ethereum-focused DAT trading at an MNAV of 0.56. It was the first DAT to sell some of its crypto holdings to finance a share buyback program.
    • Ether Machine: Shows a misleadingly low MNAV of 0.13.
      • Risk Factor: The company's business combination has not yet closed, and a massive dilution of shares is expected to occur. This will significantly increase the market cap and the MNAV. Investors should anticipate a "sell wall" once the deal closes and shares become liquid.

Takeaways

  • Potential Opportunity: Buying DATs at a significant discount (MNAV well below 1) could be a way to get exposure to crypto with potential for "extra gains" if the MNAV reverts to its expected equilibrium of 1 and the underlying crypto prices recover. This is described as a "value play."
  • Long-Term Strategy: This is not a short-term trade. The speakers emphasize that investors should be patient and have a high-conviction, strategic view. There is no clear catalyst or timeline for the discounts to close.
  • Do Your Homework: Each DAT has unique circumstances. Investors should research the specifics of each company, including:
    • The potential for future share dilution from "PIPE" (private investment in public equity) deals.
    • The status of any mergers or acquisitions.
    • The effectiveness of share buyback programs, which are often too small to make a meaningful impact.
  • Not the Same as GBTC: The historical discount of the Grayscale Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) is not a good comparison. GBTC had a clear path to closing its discount by converting to an ETF. DATs do not have a similar built-in arbitrage mechanism.

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • The price of Bitcoin was mentioned as being down approximately 30% from its recent highs. The podcast references a price drop from $126,000 down to testing $80,000.
  • Bitcoin is the primary asset held by many DATs.
  • It is described as not being a "productive asset" in the same way as Ethereum, because it cannot be natively staked to generate yield. This makes it more difficult for Bitcoin-focused DATs to generate additional returns to justify a premium valuation.

Takeaways

  • High-Beta Play: DATs that hold Bitcoin are described as "high beta plays" on the price of BTC. This means their stock prices tend to move more dramatically (both up and down) than the price of Bitcoin itself.
  • Indirect Exposure: Investing in a discounted Bitcoin-holding DAT can be an alternative way to bet on the long-term appreciation of Bitcoin.

Ethereum (ETH)

  • The price of Ether has dropped even more than Bitcoin from recent highs.
  • It is described as a "productive asset" because it can be staked to generate a passive yield, estimated to be between 2.7% and 3%.
  • This staking yield provides a way for Ethereum-focused DATs (like ETHZilla and Ether Machine) to generate additional returns on their holdings.

Takeaways

  • Potential for Premium: Because ETH is a productive asset, DATs that properly manage their ETH holdings (through staking, restaking, etc.) might be able to trade at a slight premium (MNAV > 1) over the long term.
  • Company-Specific Strategies: Investors looking at Ethereum-focused DATs should examine how the company is utilizing its assets to generate yield and whether that strategy is sustainable.

General Crypto Market Outlook

  • The podcast discusses the theme "Crypto is Dead," arguing that while the technology will persist, the culture and strategies of the "crypto native" world are changing.
  • The industry is maturing and shifting away from speculative, incentive-driven models (like airdrop farming and points programs) that have a "short shelf life."
  • The future of crypto adoption lies in building user-friendly applications for a mainstream audience, often by hiding the complex blockchain technology in the background (a "DeFi mullet" strategy).
  • Companies that are successfully bridging the gap to mainstream users were highlighted:
    • Robinhood (HOOD): Praised for its diversified product suite and for making crypto accessible to its large user base.
    • Coinbase (COIN): Mentioned for its "everything app" strategy.
    • Stripe: A non-crypto company making interesting moves to integrate crypto/stablecoins.
    • Polymarket: Noted for gaining mainstream media attention, a sign of longevity.

Takeaways

  • Focus on Utility: The most successful future projects will likely focus on the real-world problems they solve rather than marketing themselves as "crypto" or "web3," which can be seen as "baggage."
  • Evaluate Business Models: When evaluating new projects, look beyond short-term incentive schemes. Focus on projects with sustainable, long-term business models and a clear strategy for attracting mainstream users.
  • User Experience is Key: Projects that simplify the user experience (e.g., Moonshot's Apple Pay onboarding) are positioned to win by removing barriers to entry for new users.
  • The Four-Year Cycle: The traditional four-year crypto market cycle may be breaking down as the industry matures and more businesses generate revenue independent of market speculation. However, it may persist in the short term as a self-fulfilling prophecy.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
In this combined episode of Unchained, Steven Ehrlich first breaks down why crypto treasury stocks (DATs) have swung from massive premiums to deep discounts, why comparisons to GBTC can be misleading, and why buying these stocks isn’t a clean arbitrage trade but a long-term, high-conviction bet. You can read Steve’s full report here and you can subscribe for 95% OFF before the end of year! 😱 Then, Figment Capital’s Dougie DeLuca zooms out to the broader shift underway. As fintechs and institutions embrace blockchain infrastructure, he argues that “crypto as we know it” may be fading—and that crypto natives risk being left behind unless they adapt to real users, sustainable products, and mainstream distribution. Need liquidity without selling your crypto? Take out a Figure Crypto-Backed Loan, allowing you to borrow against your BTC, ETH, or SOL with 12-month terms and no prepayment penalties. They have the lowest rates in the industry at 8.91%, allowing you to access instant cash or buy more Bitcoin without triggering a tax event.  Thank you to our sponsor, Figure! Unlock your crypto’s potential today at Figure!  Guests: Dougie DeLuca, Investor and Researcher at Figment Capital Steven Ehrlich, Executive Editor at Unchained Links: Unchained: Coinbase Launches Stock Trading and Prediction Markets Inside Robinhood’s Big Super App Plan: ‘There’s Still a Lot of Work to Be Done’ Dougie's “Crypto is Dead” article Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.