Bits + Bips: Why Gold Still Dominates — And What Bitcoin Must Prove
Bits + Bips: Why Gold Still Dominates — And What Bitcoin Must Prove
105 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast48 min 57 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Given current market uncertainty, consider gold as a primary safe haven asset, which is outperforming riskier assets. Investors can gain exposure and hedge against volatility through ETFs like GLD. Treat Bitcoin (BTC) as a high-risk growth investment, similar to a tech stock, as it currently trades in line with the NASDAQ 100. Be aware that Bitcoin is not acting as "digital gold" and will likely sell off during broad risk-off market events. Finally, monitor rising bond yields in Japan, as this could negatively impact liquidity for all risk assets, including crypto.

Detailed Analysis

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • The speaker, Steve Sosnick, argues that Bitcoin has firmly become a risk asset, not the safe haven or "digital gold" it is often purported to be. Its performance is highly correlated with periods of monetary accommodation.
  • Bitcoin's performance is diverging significantly from gold, which is reaching new all-time highs amidst geopolitical uncertainty. The speaker finds this divergence "quite telling."
  • The launch of spot Bitcoin ETFs, such as IBIT, has been incredibly successful, bringing in mainstream investors ("normies"). This has reinforced Bitcoin's correlation with risk assets like the NASDAQ 100, as these investors treat it like any other stock in their retirement accounts.
  • These new investors are not comfortable with the asset's high volatility, such as a 30% drawdown, and tend to sell when risk sentiment turns negative.
  • Unlike a company like NVIDIA which has underlying earnings and revenues, Bitcoin is not a productive asset. This makes valuation difficult and "buying the dip" a riskier strategy, as there's no fundamental floor to the price.
  • The speaker notes that on breaking news of postponed tariffs, Bitcoin rallied towards 90K, which he sees as a "line in the sand between true risk on, risk off," further cementing its status as a risk-on asset.
  • For Bitcoin to ever be considered a safe haven like gold, it needs to mature and develop a more stable, "currency-like volatility."

Takeaways

  • Investors should treat Bitcoin as a high-volatility growth asset, similar to a tech stock, rather than a portfolio hedge or a replacement for gold.
  • Be prepared for significant price swings. Its correlation to the broader stock market means it will likely fall during market-wide risk-off events.
  • While it may not be a safe haven for global investors yet, it could still be a valuable asset for individuals in countries with unstable currencies (e.g., Argentina, Turkey) due to its ease of transfer and non-sovereign nature.

Gold (GLD)

  • Gold is currently fulfilling its traditional role as a safe haven asset, with its price setting new all-time highs while risk assets like Bitcoin are struggling.
  • Investors are actively buying gold as a hedge against geopolitical uncertainty and market volatility.
  • Gold has a "thousand-year head start" on Bitcoin and is perceived as a much more stable, "stodgier" store of value. Its volatility is significantly lower than Bitcoin's and is more comparable to a major currency.
  • The speaker notes that while Bitcoin and gold had similar performance over a two-year period, gold has pulled ahead significantly in the recent risk-off environment.
  • With the advent of ETFs, it is now just as easy for a portfolio manager to sell a Bitcoin ETF like IBIT and buy a gold ETF like GLD, making it easy to rotate between the two based on performance and risk appetite.

Takeaways

  • Gold has re-asserted its dominance as the premier safe-haven asset in the current environment.
  • Investors looking to reduce portfolio risk or hedge against inflation and geopolitical turmoil may find gold to be a more reliable option than Bitcoin at this time.
  • The emergence of tokenized gold on blockchains is a future trend to watch, as it could combine the benefits of gold with the transferability of crypto, potentially siphoning some demand from Bitcoin.

Stablecoins

  • The discussion suggests that stablecoins may be capturing some of the demand that might have otherwise gone to Bitcoin from people seeking safety.
  • For someone in a country with a volatile local currency (e.g., living in Buenos Aires or Istanbul), holding a stablecoin pegged to the U.S. dollar offers the benefits of crypto's ease of movement without the extreme price volatility of Bitcoin.
  • The key trade-off is decentralization. While Bitcoin is decentralized, stablecoins are managed by a central entity, and their value depends on being fully backed by real-world assets like T-bills.

Takeaways

  • Stablecoins present a compelling use case for capital preservation and cross-border payments, acting as a "safe" crypto-asset.
  • Investors considering stablecoins must perform due diligence on the issuer and the quality of the reserves backing the coin, as this introduces counterparty risk not present in decentralized assets like Bitcoin.

Broader Market & Investment Themes

  • Risk Assets vs. Safe Havens: The primary theme is the clear distinction in performance between risk assets (Bitcoin, NASDAQ 100) and safe havens (Gold) during the recent geopolitical turmoil. Risk assets sold off, while gold rallied.
  • Japanese Carry Trade: Rising yields on Japanese government bonds are a key factor to watch. This could unwind the "carry trade" (borrowing in cheap Japanese Yen to invest in higher-yielding assets), which would reduce liquidity for risk assets globally, including crypto.
  • Digital Asset Treasury Companies: The speaker expressed caution about investing in publicly traded companies that simply hold digital assets, noting that investors often end up "paying $2 for a dollar's worth of coins."
  • Silver: Mentioned as a highly speculative risk asset, with the speaker calling it the "original and current crypto favorite in its own way." It is not viewed as a pure safe haven like gold.

Takeaways

  • Pay close attention to the market's risk-on/risk-off sentiment. The discussion makes it clear that Bitcoin currently trades with risk-on sentiment, while gold benefits from risk-off moves.
  • Monitor global bond yields, particularly in Japan. A significant change could impact global market liquidity and affect all risk assets.
  • Be cautious when investing in stocks of companies whose sole business is holding cryptocurrencies, as their share price may trade at a significant and volatile premium to the value of the assets they hold.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Gold is hitting new highs. Bitcoin is struggling to keep up. And once again, the “digital gold” narrative is being put to the test.On today’s episode of Bits + Bips: The Interview, host Steve Ehrlich sits down with Steve Sosnick, Chief Strategist at Interactive Brokers, to break down why bitcoin still trades like a risk asset, why gold keeps winning in moments of market stress, and what crypto must prove to close the credibility gap. From rising bond yields to geopolitics and Fed independence, this conversation cuts through the noise to explain what’s really driving markets right now. Hosts: Steven Ehrlich, Executive Editor at Unchained Guests: Steve Sosnick, Chief Strategist at Interactive Brokers Links: Should You Buy Gold or Bitcoin? Here’s How to Think About It Bitcoin Rebounds After Trump’s Truth Social Post Eases Tariff Fears Crypto Slides on Tariff Fears as Gold Breaks Above $4,850 Why Gold Rose and Bitcoin Tumbled on Japan Bond Turmoil Supreme Court casts doubt on Trump’s power to fire Fed official without proper review Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.