Bits + Bips: The Case for Why DATs Are Superior to Crypto ETFs - Ep. 897
Bits + Bips: The Case for Why DATs Are Superior to Crypto ETFs - Ep. 897
247 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast54 min 56 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider investing in the Solana-focused Digital Asset Treasury UPEXI to gain leveraged exposure to SOL, which benefits from an 8%+ staking yield and the ability to purchase tokens at a discount. Buying spot Ethereum (ETH) is a direct way to profit from the constant buying pressure created by the growing number of Ethereum-focused DATs. For assets like Solana and Ethereum, these DATs are presented as a superior investment to spot ETFs because they can capture and benefit from staking yields. Investors should watch for the approval of altcoin futures in the U.S., as this is viewed as the single most important catalyst for the next major altcoin rally. Be aware of potential short-term weakness for Bitcoin (BTC), as September is historically a poor-performing month for the asset.

Detailed Analysis

Digital Asset Treasuries (DATs)

  • What are they? DATs are publicly traded companies that hold a specific digital asset (like Bitcoin or Solana) on their balance sheet. The podcast guests compare them to banks, as they raise money from capital markets and invest it into an asset (crypto) to earn a return.
  • The "Summer of DATs": The speakers believe 2024 is for DATs what 2021 was for DeFi, marking their arrival as a core innovation in crypto.
  • The Key Investment Thesis: The primary value driver for DATs is their ability to issue new shares of their own stock at a price above their net asset value (NAV). This is described as being "tantamount to selling a dollar for two or buying Bitcoin half off."
    • Example: A DAT holding $100 of Solana might trade on the stock market for a $200 valuation (a 2x multiple). It can then issue $100 of new stock to buy another $100 of Solana. This process is highly accretive, meaning it increases the value per share for existing shareholders.
    • MicroStrategy (MSTR) is the prime example, having created an estimated $26 billion in value for its shareholders through this strategy.
  • DATs vs. ETFs: For crypto assets that can be staked to earn a yield (like Ethereum and Solana), DATs are presented as a superior product to the current spot ETFs.
    • ETFs currently cannot pass the staking yield on to investors due to regulatory and structural constraints.
    • DATs can and do stake the assets they hold, generating a yield that benefits the company and its shareholders.
  • Risks Mentioned:
    • "DAT exhaustion": There is a concern that there are too many DATs coming to market, creating a bubble. The market may only support a few leaders per asset (a "Coke and a Pepsi").
    • Attention Game: Success is highly dependent on momentum and capturing investor attention. A DAT needs a strong storyteller or "KOL" (Key Opinion Leader), like Michael Saylor for MSTR or Tom Lee for Bitmine.
    • Momentum Dependent: The value-creation model only works as long as the DAT trades at a premium to its asset value. If that momentum breaks and the stock trades below its NAV, the model fails.

Takeaways

  • DATs offer a unique, potentially high-reward way to invest in crypto assets, especially those that offer staking yields like Solana (SOL) and Ethereum (ETH).
  • The core benefit is the value creation from issuing stock at a premium, which can significantly outperform just holding the underlying crypto asset.
  • When evaluating a DAT, consider its multiple to NAV (MNAV). A high multiple allows for more value creation, but a low multiple might represent a better value purchase if you believe the multiple will increase.
  • Be aware that this is a momentum-driven space. The speakers suggest there will be a shakeout, with only a few winners in each category. Pay attention to which DATs are capturing the most attention and trading volume.

Solana (SOL)

  • UPEXI is a publicly traded DAT focused exclusively on Solana, holding approximately $400 million worth.
  • Bullish Case for Solana DATs:
    • High Staking Yield: Solana offers a high staking yield (mentioned as 8%+), which a DAT like UPEXI can capture to make its treasury a productive, income-generating asset.
    • Locked Token Discounts: DATs can purchase "locked" SOL tokens at a significant discount (mentioned as 15%), providing an immediate built-in gain for shareholders. This is an advantage not available to typical retail investors or ETFs.
    • Growth Potential: With a market cap that is only 4% of Bitcoin's, Solana is seen as having significantly more potential upside. The speaker notes that it's much more likely for SOL to 5x than for Bitcoin to do so.
  • Tokenization Hub: Galaxy Digital's recent move to issue its corporate shares directly on the Solana blockchain (in partnership with SuperState) reinforces Solana's positioning as a potential "decentralized NASDAQ" for financial assets.

Takeaways

  • Investing in a Solana-focused DAT like UPEXI could be a way to get leveraged exposure to SOL's potential growth while also benefiting from value-creation mechanisms like staking and discounted token purchases.
  • The speakers suggest that due to these additional value mechanisms and higher growth potential, a Solana DAT could warrant a higher trading multiple than a Bitcoin DAT like MSTR.
  • The development of Solana as a platform for tokenized securities (like the Galaxy issuance) is a major long-term catalyst to watch.

Ethereum (ETH)

  • Strong Momentum: The speakers note that Ethereum has strong momentum, with its price chart looking very positive despite general market pessimism.
  • DATs as a Price Driver: The rise of Ethereum DATs, heavily promoted by figures like Tom Lee of Bitmine, is cited as a primary reason for ETH's price moving from $2,700 to $4,700. These DATs create a "forced bid" or constant buying pressure for ETH.
  • Aave (AAVE), a leading DeFi protocol on Ethereum, is mentioned as "doing fantastic," supporting the thesis that a boom in DeFi follows a boom in the underlying platform.

Takeaways

  • The discussion suggests that buying spot ETH is a simple way to benefit from the constant buying pressure created by the growing number of Ethereum DATs. The thesis is: "buy what people are forced to buy."
  • For investors who can't or don't want to hold spot crypto, an Ethereum DAT is presented as a better option than an ETH ETF because the DAT can generate and benefit from staking yield.
  • The health of top DeFi applications on Ethereum, like Aave, can be seen as a bullish indicator for the entire ecosystem.

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • Negative Seasonality: The podcast highlights that September is historically a weak month for Bitcoin's price performance.
  • The 4-Year Cycle: The traditional 4-year cycle theory suggests Bitcoin could top in November, though some are questioning if the cycle is broken.
  • MicroStrategy (MSTR) Impact: A decision by MSTR's Michael Saylor to change (and then change back) the rules governing when the company buys Bitcoin was seen as a negative that "spoiled the market" by undermining the crypto ethos of immutability.
  • MSTR as a Benchmark: Despite this, MSTR's trading multiple (around 1.6x NAV) is viewed as a potential "floor" for the multiples of other DATs, especially those with higher growth potential or yield.

Takeaways

  • Investors should be aware of the potential for short-term weakness or "chop" for Bitcoin in September due to historical trends.
  • MicroStrategy (MSTR) remains the primary DAT for investors seeking exposure to Bitcoin in a traditional stock format.
  • While Bitcoin has less explosive growth potential than smaller assets like Solana, it remains the bedrock of the crypto market, and its leading DAT (MSTR) serves as the benchmark for the entire DAT category.

Altcoin Market (General Theme)

  • Bullish Long-Term Outlook: The speakers are very bullish on altcoins for the medium to long term, citing significant regulatory de-risking as a major catalyst.
  • The Single Most Important Catalyst to Watch: The listing of altcoin futures in the U.S. is identified as a massive potential unlock for the market.
    • It would cement these altcoins as commodities in the eyes of regulators.
    • It would unlock "basis trading" by institutions, which creates buying pressure for the spot token.
    • It would pave the way for spot ETFs for those altcoins, as futures markets are used for surveillance.

Takeaways

  • The current high Bitcoin dominance (around 58%) suggests there is significant room for a market rotation into altcoins.
  • Investors should pay close attention to any news regarding the approval of listed futures contracts for altcoins beyond BTC, ETH, and SOL. This is seen as the "missing link" that could trigger the next major wave of institutional investment and price appreciation in the altcoin market.

US Equities

  • American Eagle (AEO): Mentioned as a successful non-consensus trade. The stock was reportedly up 24% after its earnings report, demonstrating strength in beaten-down retail names.
  • Better Mortgage (BETR): Part of a "mortgage refi" investment theme that the speaker believes will continue to perform well.

Takeaways

  • The podcast suggests a bullish macro backdrop for consumer-focused stocks, with potential opportunities in retailers like AEO that have been overlooked due to tariff concerns.
  • Rate-sensitive names tied to the mortgage industry, like BETR, are also highlighted as a theme with continued upside potential.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
DATs aren’t done. They may just be getting started.  In this episode, CoinFund’s Chris Perkins and Upexi’s Brian Rudick join Ram Ahluwalia and Steven Ehrlich to dissect why some DATs could outcompete ETFs for certain investors, the bullish accretion math behind premiums, and what makes a winning vehicle. We also dig into whether this is altcoin season or a head fake, why Galaxy’s tokenized-share move matters, and the one market unlock Perkins says could change everything. Use this episode to pressure-test your assumptions: are DATs “just banks,” or the best product-market-fit crypto has found for TradFi capital? Thank you to our sponsor ⁠Xapo Bank⁠! Xapo offers Bitcoin-backed loans of up to $1 million, so eligible members can access liquidity without selling their BTC.  Hosts: Ram Ahluwalia, CFA, CEO and Founder of Lumida Steve Ehrlich, Executive Editor at Unchained Guests: Christopher Perkins, Managing Partner and President of CoinFund Brian Rudick, Chief Strategy Officer at Upexi Links: DATs: How Crypto Treasury Companies Are Turning to DeFi and TradFi to Juice Yields How Michael Saylor Plans to Ensure Strategy Keeps Its Bitcoin Forever These 4 Crypto Treasury Companies Are Primed for a Price Crash Crypto Treasury Companies Are All the Rage. Could They Cause an Industry Collapse? Tokenization: Federal Reserve to hold conference discussing crypto stablecoins, tokenization, and AI GLXY tokenized stock Ondo Finance launched over 100 tokenized U.S. stocks and ETFs on Ethereum CZ-owned Trust Wallet launches tokenized stocks and ETFs Timestamps: 🎬 0:00 Intro ⏱  3:00 Are markets set for another September swoon? 📈 6:03 Why the bull case for DATs isn’t over 🏦 12:41 Why Brian says “DATs are banks” 💡 18:20 Are DATs better products than ETFs for investors? 🧮 21:00 How the math behind premiums shows DATs create value 🪙 28:01 Whether this is the time for altcoins to shine 🌍 35:10 Where macro is heading and what investors should watch 🚨 37:48 Why Galaxy’s tokenized-share move on Solana is such a big deal 🔑 49:25 What the key market unlock is for altcoins Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.