Arthur Hayes and Adam Schlegel on Why Private Equity Is Crypto's Next Big Wave - Ep. 933
Arthur Hayes and Adam Schlegel on Why Private Equity Is Crypto's Next Big Wave - Ep. 933
193 days agoUnchainedLaura Shin
Podcast1 hr 9 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider an investment in Ethena (ENA) as a strategic play on falling interest rates, as its revenue is expected to grow with increased crypto speculation. In contrast, Circle's business model is viewed as bearish, with profits projected to plummet alongside interest rates, making it a less favorable investment in the current macro environment. This analysis suggests that Ethena may overtake Circle in market supply and represents a superior investment for the expected economic climate. Be cautious with perpetual DEXes like Hyperliquid, as they face a "war of attrition" against large exchanges offering zero-fee alternatives. Ultimately, investment focus should remain on stablecoins with massive distribution networks like Tether (USDT), Circle (USDC), and Ethena (ENA), which are expected to dominate the market.

Detailed Analysis

Maelstrom Private Equity Fund

  • Maelstrom, Arthur Hayes's family office, is launching a private equity fund seeking to raise at least $250 million to buy controlling stakes in 5-6 crypto companies.
  • The fund's strategy is to acquire established, cash-flowing crypto infrastructure companies that are often overlooked by traditional Western investors.
  • Target Profile:
    • Companies with $50 to $100 million+ in revenue and 30-50%+ EBITDA margins.
    • The fund is looking for control deals, aiming to acquire 51% or more of the company.
    • The minimum revenue for a target is around $25 million.
    • Many of these targets are located in Asia and Latin America, which are perceived as "scary" by some Western funds, creating a valuation discount.
  • The Goal:
    • Buy these profitable but "unpolished" companies, professionalize their operations, and grow them 3-5x over 2-4 years.
    • Sell these improved companies at a higher multiple to larger private equity firms (like KKR), strategic acquirers (like Coinbase, Robinhood, Charles Schwab), or take them public.
    • The fund explicitly will not invest in tokens, focusing on equity in centralized finance (CeFi) businesses that support the crypto ecosystem.
  • Fund Structure:
    • It is structured as a $250 million anchor fund with a "hub and spoke" model.
    • For larger deals, they will raise Special Purpose Vehicles (SPVs) on a deal-by-deal basis.
    • The minimum investment for Limited Partners (LPs) is $5 million.

Takeaways

  • This fund represents a new phase in crypto investing, moving beyond venture capital (early-stage tokens) and into traditional private equity (buyouts of mature companies).
  • The core investment thesis is that there are highly profitable crypto-native businesses being undervalued because of their geographic location or lack of corporate polish.
  • Maelstrom believes they can create value by acting as an intermediary, preparing these companies for acquisition by larger, more traditional financial players who are interested in crypto but hesitant to buy "unrefined" assets directly.
  • This strategy is designed to appeal to large institutional investors (pension funds, endowments) who want crypto exposure but prefer the familiar structure of private equity over volatile token investments.

Coinbase (COIN)

  • Coinbase is seen as a natural acquirer for the types of companies Maelstrom's fund will be developing.
  • The recent acquisition of Echo is viewed as a strategic move by Coinbase to build out its capital markets capabilities and compete with Binance's successful new-issue market (Launchpad).
  • Arthur Hayes notes that Coinbase is using its "funny money stock" (highly valued stock) to make these acquisitions, which is a smart corporate strategy.
  • Coinbase, along with players like Robinhood and Stripe, has the distribution necessary to potentially launch a successful stablecoin, but faces the challenge of changing user behavior away from established players like Tether.

Takeaways

  • Coinbase is actively expanding from a simple exchange into a full-fledged capital markets platform, using acquisitions to fill gaps in its ecosystem.
  • Investors should watch how effectively Coinbase integrates acquisitions like Echo to see if it can generate new revenue streams comparable to Binance's Launchpad.
  • The high valuation of COIN stock is a powerful tool for the company, allowing it to acquire other businesses without spending as much cash.

Hyperliquid (No Ticker)

  • Hyperliquid is highlighted as the first perpetuals DEX (decentralized exchange) that "ticked all the boxes" by successfully sharing revenue with its community, something previous DEXes like dYdX failed to do effectively.
  • Its success is attributed to a superior business model where security costs are outsourced to the underlying blockchain (paid via gas fees), making it more capital-efficient than a centralized exchange (CEX) like Binance or BitMEX.
  • Major Risk: Centralized exchanges are now fighting back by launching their own zero-fee perpetuals DEXes. This is a strategy to "neuter a competitor" by compressing their revenue.
  • The future of Hyperliquid and similar DEXes depends on whether they can survive a prolonged period of low-to-no fee competition from large, well-funded CEXes.

Takeaways

  • Hyperliquid represents a significant innovation in the DEX space, proving that a revenue-sharing model can attract massive volume and create a loyal user base.
  • The investment risk for platforms like Hyperliquid is extremely high right now. They are entering a "war of attrition" against giants like Binance and other CEXes who can afford to offer free trading to crush competition.
  • Arthur Hayes predicts that in 5-10 years, most trading will occur on decentralized perpetual exchanges, but the immediate future is a battle for survival.

Stablecoins (Investment Theme)

  • The single most important factor for a stablecoin's success is distribution. A technologically superior stablecoin with no users is worthless.
  • Tether (USDT) is the dominant player because of its massive, global distribution network. Arthur Hayes notes, "I know if I have Tether if I go to fucking Bariloche, Argentina, I can pay my ski guide." This real-world utility creates an incredibly sticky network effect.
  • Most new stablecoin projects are dismissed as a "zero" unless they are backed by an entity with a billion users, like a Walmart or Facebook.
  • The market is likely to remain dominated by a few key players: Tether (USDT), Circle (USDC), and Ethena (ENA), which are expected to control 95% of the market.

Takeaways

  • Investors should be extremely skeptical of new stablecoin projects. Without a clear and massive distribution strategy, they are unlikely to succeed against entrenched incumbents.
  • The "better technology" argument is not enough to win in the stablecoin space; it's a business and network-building game.

Circle (USDC)

  • Circle's business model is highly sensitive to interest rates. It earns revenue from the yield on the Treasury bills it holds to back USDC.
  • Arthur Hayes expressed a bearish view on Circle, especially in a falling interest rate environment. As rates come down, Circle's revenue will "plummet."
  • He predicts that Ethena (ENA) will overtake Circle in market supply.
  • The high valuation of Circle's recent IPO is seen as a product of public market mania for crypto exposure, not necessarily a reflection of its fundamental business strength in a changing macro environment.

Takeaways

  • An investment in Circle is effectively a bet on interest rates remaining high. If you believe the Federal Reserve and other central banks will continue cutting rates, Circle's profitability is at significant risk.
  • Circle faces a fundamental business model challenge compared to a synthetic dollar provider like Ethena, whose revenue model is not directly tied to T-bill yields.

Ethena (ENA)

  • Ethena's revenue model is fundamentally different from Circle's. It generates yield from the "basis trade" in crypto markets (the difference between spot and futures prices), which is driven by speculator demand for leverage.
  • Arthur Hayes is very bullish on Ethena in a falling interest rate environment. His logic is:
    1. Lower rates lead to cheaper money and more speculation in crypto.
    2. More speculation increases demand for leverage, widening the basis.
    3. Ethena captures a percentage of this widening basis, so its revenue goes up as crypto becomes more bullish.
  • Ethena is positioned to do well when rates come down and crypto goes up, whereas Circle's revenue would fall in the same scenario.

Takeaways

  • Ethena is presented as a strong strategic play for investors who are bullish on crypto and expect interest rates to fall.
  • It offers a way to get exposure to crypto market activity and volatility, with a business model that thrives on speculation, unlike traditional stablecoins that rely on TradFi yields.
  • The podcast positions Ethena as a superior investment to Circle for the current and expected macroeconomic climate.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Crypto has spent years obsessing over tokens, airdrops, and speculation. But what about the unsexy businesses actually making money? Arthur Hayes and Adam Schlegel join Laura Shin to talk about Maelstrom's $250M private equity fund targeting crypto's most profitable, yet overlooked, companies, $50M revenue businesses with 50% margins that VCs can't touch and exchanges won't pay cash for. But while everyone frames this as just another fund, Hayes and Schlegel argue it's actually the missing piece in crypto's maturation: a cash buyer for founders who've done their time and want out without four-year earnouts.  Plus: Why Asian crypto companies with monster margins get ignored by Western capital. Thank you to our sponsors! Binance Guests: Arthur Hayes, Co-Founder of BitMEX & CIO at Maelstrom Adam Schlegel, Head of Private Equity at Maelstrom Links: Previous appearances on Unchained: The Chopping Block: Arthur Hayes & Tom Lee; Hyperliquid vs Aster, DATs & ETH Arthur Hayes and Hanson Birringer on Hyperliquid’s Success (And What Could Stop It) Bloomberg: Arthur Hayes’ Family Office Seeks $250M for Buyout Fund Coindesk: Arthur Hayes’ Maelstrom Seeks $250M Private Equity Fund to Acquire Crypto Firms: Bloomberg Akshat’s tweet announcing the fund Timestamps: 🎬 0:00 Intro 📰 1:08 Maelstrom’s $250M private equity fund to buy crypto firms 👤 1:42 Adam’s background and path from Morgan Stanley to Haveli to Maelstrom 💼 3:51 Why Maelstrom believes the next crypto boom is in private equity 📈 4:42 Arthur on how crypto investing evolved from beta → VC → PE 🌏 10:05 Geographic focus: Asia and LatAm’s overlooked crypto firms 🧭 11:49 How Maelstrom evaluates targets and performs due diligence 🛠️ 17:02 Inside Maelstrom’s $250M anchor fund and LP co-invest model 👀 26:01 The types of companies Maelstrom is targeting ⚙️ 30:16 Fund structure and Arthur’s role in Maelstrom PE 📊 36:05 “The four-year cycle is dead”: Arthur on today’s crypto market 💰 39:18 Investor requirements and $5M minimum commitment 🏦 42:09 Coinbase’s Echo acquisition and what it means for exchanges ⚔️ 47:59 The perps war, how DEXs are forcing CEXs toward zero-fee trading 💥 52:18 Binance, ADL liquidations, and leverage risk 🔮 56:27 Prediction markets: Polymarket vs Kalshi vs Limitless 💵 59:06 Stablecoins and rates, why Tether and Circle could lose to Ethena 📈 1:04:15 Who wins the next phase of crypto’s evolution 🔚 1:08:14 Closing thoughts Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About Unchained
Unchained

Unchained

By Laura Shin

Crypto assets and blockchain technology are about to transform every trust-based interaction of our lives, from financial services to identity to the Internet of Things. In this podcast, host Laura Shin, an independent journalist covering all things crypto, talks with industry pioneers about how crypto assets and blockchains will change the way we earn, spend and invest our money. Tune in to find out how Web 3.0, the decentralized web, will revolutionize our world. Disclosure: I'm a nocoiner.