The Bank Stock Rout: Separating Facts From Fiction | The Weekly Wrap
The Bank Stock Rout: Separating Facts From Fiction | The Weekly Wrap
Podcast19 min 51 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

A massive M&A wave is beginning, creating a prime opportunity to invest in top investment banks like Goldman Sachs (GS) and Morgan Stanley (MS). For a more focused play on this trend, consider specialized boutique firms such as Evercore (EVR) and PJT Partners (PJT). To capitalize on expected consolidation among smaller banks, the SPDR S&P Regional Banking ETF (KRE) offers broad exposure to potential acquisition targets. Outside of banking, the recent dip in auto insurance leader Progressive (PGR) may present a buying opportunity for this long-term compounder. While early credit concerns are emerging, they are viewed as minor and do not yet derail the bullish case for the financial sector.

Detailed Analysis

Investment Banking & M&A Theme

• The speaker, Steve Eisman, believes we are at the beginning of a massive M&A (Mergers & Acquisitions) wave, similar to the 1990s. • This is supported by strong M&A fees, trading, and underwriting results reported by the large banks. • To capitalize on this trend, Eisman suggests looking at large-cap investment banks or smaller, specialized "boutique" firms.

Takeaways

Bullish Sentiment: There is a strong bullish case for companies that benefit from increased M&A activity. • How to Play It: - Large-Cap: Consider Goldman Sachs (GS) or Morgan Stanley (MS). - Boutiques: For a more focused play, look at investment banking boutiques like Evercore (EVR) and PJT Partners (PJT).


Goldman Sachs (GS)

• Goldman is highlighted as a prime way to invest in the M&A boom, as it is the #1 ranked M&A advisor globally. • The stock trades at a premium valuation (2.3 times tangible book value) compared to peers like Wells Fargo and Bank of America, which trade around 1.8 to 1.9 times. • This premium is justified because Goldman's earnings are highly sensitive to capital markets activity (M&A and trading), which is currently very strong. • It has a Return on Tangible Common Equity (ROTCE) of around 15%, similar to Wells Fargo and Bank of America, but gets a higher valuation due to its M&A leadership.

Takeaways

Bullish Sentiment: Eisman is positive on Goldman due to the strong M&A cycle. • Valuation Context: Investors are willing to pay a premium for Goldman because it is seen as the best way to capitalize on the current strength in investment banking. This is a "cycle" play, meaning it's attractive while the M&A market is hot.


Morgan Stanley (MS)

• Mentioned alongside Goldman Sachs as a well-run, capital markets-driven bank that investors favor during strong cycles. • It has one of the highest returns in the banking group, with a Return on Tangible Common Equity (ROTCE) of over 20%. • This high profitability results in a high valuation of around 3 times tangible book value.

Takeaways

Bullish Sentiment: A high-quality bank that performs well when investment banking is strong. • Premium Stock: Like Goldman, it's a premium-priced stock that reflects its high profitability and strong position in the market.


Citigroup (C)

• Citi was the best-performing large bank this year, up 43%. • The bank's Return on Tangible Common Equity (ROTCE) is finally improving after many years, reaching 8%. While this is the lowest in the large-cap group, the improvement is a positive sign. • Due to this improvement, the stock is now trading at 1 times tangible book value for the first time since before the 2008 financial crisis. • Historical Context: Despite the strong recent performance and the stock price hitting $100, it remains far below its pre-financial crisis high of $557.

Takeaways

Turnaround Story: Citi is presented as a turnaround story under its CEO, Jane Fraser. The improving profitability is being rewarded by the market. • Valuation: While still valued lower than its peers, the fact that it's no longer trading at a discount to its tangible book value is a significant milestone.


JPMorgan Chase (JPM)

• Reported strong earnings, helped by its investment banking and trading divisions. • The bank has a very high Return on Tangible Common Equity (ROTCE) of over 20%, leading to a premium valuation of around 3 times tangible book value. • Credit Concerns: Jamie Dimon noted some "early signs of excess in corporate lending," specifically in auto-related companies. - J.P. Morgan took a $170 million loss on the Tricolor fraud bankruptcy, which is considered a tiny amount for a bank of its size. - Commercial non-accruing loans (loans the bank doesn't expect to collect) were up 33% year-over-year, indicating some deterioration.

Takeaways

Mixed Signal: While the bank is performing very well and is highly profitable, investors should note the early signs of credit issues on the commercial side. • Perspective: Eisman emphasizes that these credit issues are minor ("at the margin") and not yet a cause for major alarm or an indicator of a looming recession.


Regional Banks (KRE ETF)

• Eisman believes regional and community banks need to merge to survive. They are struggling with high regulatory and technology costs, which larger banks can handle more easily. • He states that the current administration is likely to be supportive of mergers among these smaller banks. • Investment Thesis: The primary reason to own regional banks is the potential for them to be acquired in this M&A wave. • How to Play It: Eisman suggests buying the KRE index, which is an ETF that tracks a basket of regional banks. This diversifies risk instead of picking individual banks.

Takeaways

Bullish on M&A: The investment case for regional banks is not based on their fundamental business strength but on the likelihood of a buyout. • Actionable Idea: Consider the SPDR S&P Regional Banking ETF (KRE) to gain broad exposure to this theme. • Risk Factor: A major risk is poor management. Eisman notes that many regional bank CEOs may resist selling their company, which is the best outcome for shareholders. - First Horizon (FHN) is used as a prime example. Its CEO suggested the bank might be an acquirer rather than a seller, causing the stock to drop 9% in one day and erasing most of its yearly gains.


Zions Bancorporation (ZION) & Western Alliance (WAL)

• These two regional banks disclosed problems with loans made to the same fraudulent borrower (the "Cantor Group"). • Zions took a $60 million charge-off. • Western Alliance is dealing with a bad loan valued at almost $100 million. • Market Reaction: The news caused Zions stock to fall 13% and Western Alliance to fall 11%, and it dragged down the entire banking sector for the day.

Takeaways

Isolated Issue: Eisman stresses that these problems appear to be isolated to these two banks and this specific borrower. Other regional banks did not report similar issues. • Market Sensitivity: This event shows how hypersensitive the market is to any news about credit problems. Investors are on high alert for signs of economic weakness.


Progressive (PGR)

• Eisman describes Progressive as a "champion" in the mature auto insurance industry. • Its business model is to be more efficient than competitors and pass those savings to customers through better pricing, allowing it to consistently gain market share. He compares it to Walmart (WMT), Costco (COST), and T-Mobile (TMUS) in their respective industries. • The stock recently fell 6% after reporting earnings. While the numbers were fine, premium growth of 9.9% slightly missed estimates, sparking fears of rising competition.

Takeaways

Long-Term Hold: Eisman has owned the stock for years and continues to believe it's a good long-term investment. • Expect Volatility: Investors should be aware that the stock can be sensitive to news about competition. Periods of intense competition can cause the stock to react negatively, as seen this week. This may present buying opportunities for long-term believers in the company's business model.

Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
On this episode of The Weekly Wrap, Steve Eisman breaks down the bank stock rout and explores whether it signals deeper issues in the financial sector. He also discusses Trump's tariffs battle with China and provides an update on last week's mailbag question regarding AI in the workforce.     Watch my Financial Literacy Masterclass video here: https://youtu.be/u8chA7LC8lU    Subscribe 👉🏻https://www.youtube.com/@RealEismanPlaybook?sub_confirmation=1    Connect with Steve Eisman and access all things The Eisman Playbook: 🌐 https://linktr.ee/realeismanplaybook → Follow on socials, watch episodes, and get the latest updates — all in one place.    Disclaimer: The financial opinions expressed are for information purposes only. The opinions expressed by the hosts and participants are not an attempt to influence specific trading behavior, investments, or strategies. Past performance does not necessarily predict future outcomes. No specific results or profits are assured when relying on this content. Before making any investment or trade, evaluate its suitability for your circumstances and consider consulting your own financial or investment advisor. The financial products discussed in ‘The Eisman Playbook' carry a high level of risk and may not be appropriate for many investors. If you have uncertainties, it's advisable to seek professional advice. Remember that trading involves a risk to your capital, so only invest money you can afford to lose. Derivatives are unsuitable for all investors and involve the risk of losing more than the amount originally deposited and any profit you might have made. This communication is not a recommendation or offer to buy, sell, or retain any specific investment or service.    Copyright ©2025 Steve Eisman
About The Real Eisman Playbook
The Real Eisman Playbook

The Real Eisman Playbook

By Steve Eisman

The Real Eisman Playbook is your front-row seat to the insights, strategies, and perspectives of legendary investor Steve Eisman. Best known for predicting the 2008 financial crisis, Steve brings his sharp analysis and no-nonsense approach to dissecting the markets, global economy, and investment trends shaping the future. Whether you’re a seasoned investor or just curious about how the financial world really works, The Eisman Playbook delivers the knowledge you need to stay ahead. Tune in for expert commentary, candid conversations, and actionable takeaways from one of Wall Street’s most influential minds. Follow Us on Social Media!