Michael Burry’s Bearish Bet Knocked Palantir 10% — Is It Overvalued? | Prof G Markets
Michael Burry’s Bearish Bet Knocked Palantir 10% — Is It Overvalued? | Prof G Markets
YouTube26 min 43 sec
Watch on YouTube
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Legendary investor Michael Burry has placed a significant bet against Palantir (PLTR), citing its massive valuation of nearly 300 times earnings as a key risk. This bearish view exists despite the company's spectacular growth, making PLTR a high-risk, high-volatility stock driven by a battle between fundamentals and narrative. Burry's trade reflects a broader concern that the AI sector is in a bubble, with PLTR being one of the most susceptible stocks if sentiment turns negative. Separately, fears of a business exodus from New York City due to political changes appear to be overstated. Major corporations like JPMorgan (JPM) are doubling down with massive new investments, signaling long-term confidence in the city's economic environment.

Detailed Analysis

Palantir (PLTR)

  • The stock fell more than 10% after news that legendary investor Michael Burry (of "The Big Short" fame) made a large bet against it.
    • His firm, Scion Asset Management, bought put options (a bet the price will fall) on approximately 5 million shares, a position worth almost $1 billion.
  • This news overshadowed a "spectacular" earnings report where Palantir beat all Wall Street expectations.
    • Overall sales grew 63%.
    • U.S. commercial software sales grew 121%.
    • U.S. government software sales grew 52%.
    • The company reported a very profitable 50% operating margin.
  • The primary concern for bears like Michael Burry is the stock's massive valuation.
    • It trades at almost 300 times earnings and 125 times sales.
    • Guest analyst Gil Luria from DA Davidson stated these numbers are "detached from the fundamentals" and hard to justify with traditional valuation methods.
  • The bullish case is compared to Tesla (TSLA) in its early days, where individual investors' belief in the company's mission and long-term growth proved correct despite Wall Street's skepticism about its high valuation.
    • The stock is disproportionately driven by individual investors who believe in the company's long-term potential.
    • Palantir's CEO, Alex Karp, appears highly motivated by the short-sellers, using it as "bulletin board material" to drive the company to perform better.

Takeaways

  • High Risk, High Volatility: Palantir is presented as a classic "story stock" where the investment thesis is a battle between a compelling growth narrative and an extremely high valuation. Investors should expect continued volatility.
  • Bearish View: If you believe that fundamentals and valuation ultimately matter, the stock appears significantly overvalued. Michael Burry's short position suggests he believes the "AI bubble" will pop, and Palantir, with its high valuation, is a prime candidate for a major correction.
  • Bullish View: If you believe Palantir is a generational company that can continue its phenomenal growth for many years, the current valuation may be justifiable, similar to how early Tesla investors were rewarded. The company's actual business performance is exceptionally strong.
  • Patience is Key for Shorts: The guest analyst warns that shorting the stock is risky. The business is performing very well, and the positive narrative could continue for years, causing losses for short-sellers. As the saying goes, "the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent."

AI Sector

  • Michael Burry's bet against Palantir is part of a broader thesis that Artificial Intelligence (AI) is a bubble.
  • The podcast notes that concerns about an AI bubble are widespread, and market sentiment swings back and forth between excitement and fear.
  • Palantir is highlighted as having the highest valuation within the AI space, making it the most "susceptible" to negative news and shifts in sentiment.

Takeaways

  • Be Aware of Sector-Wide Risk: Investors in AI-related stocks should be conscious of the "bubble" narrative. A negative catalyst, like a prominent investor's bearish call, can impact the entire sector, but it will likely affect the highest-valuation stocks the most.
  • Focus on Fundamentals: While hype can drive prices, the discussion suggests that in the long run, differentiation will be key. Palantir's strong growth and profitability metrics are what bulls point to as evidence it's more than just hype. Investors should scrutinize the actual business performance of their AI investments.

Pinterest (PINS) & Snap (SNAP)

  • Pinterest (PINS): The stock had its second-worst day ever, falling 21% after its earnings report.
    • The decline was attributed to the impact of tariffs, which caused retailers to reduce their advertising spending on the platform.
  • Snap (SNAP): Shares soared 25% after the company announced a $400 million perplexity deal in its earnings report.

Takeaways

  • Ad-Based Businesses are Sensitive to Economic Headwinds: Pinterest's sharp decline is a clear example of how macroeconomic factors like tariffs can directly impact ad spending, hurting social media and e-commerce platforms.
  • Company-Specific Catalysts Matter: In contrast to Pinterest, Snap's major stock move was driven by a specific corporate action (a large deal), showing that individual company news can sometimes override broader market trends.

New York City Investment Environment

  • There was significant fear among Wall Street and business leaders that the election of a democratic socialist mayor, Zohran Mamdani, would trigger a "gigantic exodus" of businesses and wealthy individuals from New York City.
    • Concerns centered on higher taxes, policing, quality of life, and the mayor's perceived anti-billionaire stance.
  • However, post-election, the sentiment has shifted to "resignation" and a willingness to work with the new administration.
    • Prominent figures like Bill Ackman, who had warned of an exodus, have since publicly offered their support to the new mayor.
    • The guest analyst is "pretty skeptical" that a mass exodus will actually happen.
  • A key piece of evidence against the exodus theory is JPMorgan's (JPM) massive investment in a new, state-of-the-art headquarters in Midtown Manhattan. This is seen as a "giant bet on Midtown Manhattan" and a monument to capitalism in the city.

Takeaways

  • Political Risk May Be Overstated: The threats of a business exodus from NYC appear to have been "empty threats" used for political leverage. Investors who may have been worried about the impact on NYC-based companies or real estate should note that major players are doubling down on their commitment to the city.
  • Follow the Money, Not the Rhetoric: JPMorgan's new office tower is a tangible, multi-billion dollar signal that one of the world's largest financial institutions sees a strong future for NYC, despite the political rhetoric. The fact that NYC remains a global hub for talent is a powerful force that keeps businesses anchored there.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Video Description
Ed Elson is joined by Gil Luria, Head of Technology Research at D.A. Davidson, to break down how Palantir reacted to news of Michael Burry’s massive bet against the company. Then, Liz Hoffman, business and finance editor at Semafor, joins the show to break down how Wall Street is responding to the NYC mayoral election results. Timestamps 00:00 - Today's Number 00:22 - Market Vitals 01:11 - Palantir Earnings (ft. Gil Luria) 11:12 - Ad Break 12:25 - Wall Street Reacts to Mamdani Win (ft. Liz Hoffman) 26:27 - Credits --- Subscribe to the Prof G Markets newsletter: https://links.profgmedia.com/markets-newsletter Order "Notes On Being A Man" now! https://amzn.to/4nl4VKo Subscribe to No Mercy / No Malice: https://links.profgmedia.com/nmnm-yt-sub-desc Follow Scott on Instagram: https://instagram.com/profgalloway Follow Ed on Instagram and X: https://instagram.com/ed_elson_/ https://twitter.com/edels0n Note: We may earn revenue from some of the links we provide.
About The Prof G Pod – Scott Galloway
The Prof G Pod – Scott Galloway

The Prof G Pod – Scott Galloway

By @theprofgpod

NYU Professor, best-selling author, business leader and serial entrepreneur Scott Galloway cuts through the biggest stories in ...