What if Uncertainty Isn’t Such a Bad Thing?
What if Uncertainty Isn’t Such a Bad Thing?
Podcast55 min 17 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Investors should maintain a high conviction in Shopify (SHOP) as a "picks and shovels" play, as it captures 10% of U.S. e-commerce and leverages AI to lower the barrier for new entrepreneurs. Look for growth opportunities in Salesforce (CRM) by identifying management teams, like those at Slack, who are willing to pivot away from mediocre products to pursue high-potential internal innovations. Diversify into the Data Privacy sector through services like Incogni, which are becoming essential utilities as AI increases the scale of personal data exploitation. Avoid companies with rigid five-year plans or a lack of "ghost ships" (abandoned projects), as an inability to cut losses often signals a lack of innovation. Finally, favor companies that prioritize "diversity of thought" and internal dissent over efficient consensus, as these firms are better equipped to navigate the current era of record-high global uncertainty.

Detailed Analysis

The podcast episode "What if Uncertainty Isn’t Such a Bad Thing?" features author Simone Stolzhoff discussing the psychological and professional impacts of uncertainty. While the conversation is primarily philosophical and behavioral, it provides significant insights into corporate strategy, leadership risks, and the history of major tech pivots.


Slack (WORK - formerly, now CRM)

The transcript highlights the origin story of Slack as a masterclass in navigating business uncertainty and the "pivot" strategy.

  • The "Tiny Speck" Pivot: Originally a gaming startup called Tiny Speck, the company had raised $17 million and had tens of thousands of players.
  • Strategic Decision: Founder Stewart Butterfield recognized the game wasn't long-term viable despite its current success. He shut it down to focus on an internal communication tool the team had built for themselves.
  • Outcome: This tool became Slack, which grew into one of the fastest-growing enterprise companies in history and was eventually sold to Salesforce (CRM) for approximately $27.7 billion.

Takeaways

  • Value of "Unknowing": Investors should look for founders who are willing to abandon a mediocre "success" to pursue a high-potential "uncertainty."
  • Internal Tools as Assets: Sometimes a company’s most valuable asset isn't their flagship product, but the internal infrastructure they built to create it.

Shopify (SHOP)

Shopify is highlighted as a primary tool for entrepreneurs to mitigate the risks of starting a new business.

  • Market Position: Shopify powers 10% of all e-commerce in the U.S. and supports millions of businesses globally.
  • AI Integration: The platform is aggressively integrating AI tools to help small business owners with product descriptions, headlines, and photography, lowering the barrier to entry for new ventures.

Takeaways

  • Platform Resilience: As a "picks and shovels" play for the creator economy, Shopify benefits from the very uncertainty that drives individuals to start side hustles or new businesses.

Investment Themes & Sectors

The "Expertise Trap" in Corporate Leadership

The discussion identifies a specific risk factor for established companies: Intolerance of Uncertainty.

  • The Risk: Highly seasoned experts (e.g., ER doctors, senior economists) often suffer from "overconfidence effect" and "confirmation bias."
  • Corporate Failures: Kodak and Blockbuster are cited as canonical examples of companies with rigid strategic plans that prevented them from adapting to new information.
  • The "Department of Doubt": The New York Federal Reserve created an "Applied Critical Thinking Unit" to act as internal devil's advocates. However, the unit was eventually shut down because it was viewed as a "cost center" and a "drag on efficiency."

AI and the "Certainty Fallacy"

  • The Trend: There is a rising expectation that answers should be instantaneous due to mobile phones and AI.
  • The Risk: AI (ChatBots) can project "false certainty," lying confidently even when incorrect. This creates a risk for businesses that over-rely on AI for high-stakes decision-making (e.g., career moves, legal advice, or market timing).

Actionable Investment Insights

  • Identify "Divergent Thinking" in Management: Research suggests that teams with "diversity of thought" make better decisions, even though the process is "less comfortable" and involves more friction. Investors should favor companies that encourage internal dissent over those that prioritize "efficient" but potentially blind consensus.
  • Beware of "Paralysis by Analysis": In the current era, five-year plans are often outdated overnight. The most successful modern companies follow the "Next Right Action" philosophy—taking small, iterative steps rather than adhering to rigid, long-term projections.
  • The "Ghost Ship" Metric: When evaluating a company's history, look at their "ghost ships"—the projects they abandoned to focus on their current winners. A company with no abandoned projects may be suffering from a lack of innovation or an inability to cut losses.
  • Sector Focus - Personal Privacy: Mention of Incogni highlights a growing investment theme in Data Privacy and Protection. As AI empowers scammers with personal data, services that automate the removal of personal info from data brokers are becoming essential consumer utilities.

Risk Factors Mentioned

  • Global Uncertainty Index: The five highest measurements of global uncertainty since the 1980s have all occurred within the last five years.
  • The "Shock" Study: Research shows people are more stressed by a 50% chance of a painful event than a 100% certainty of one. This suggests markets may react more violently to ambiguity than to confirmed bad news.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
You can run from uncertainty, but you can’t hide. The thing to do, says Simone Stolzoff, to develop comfort with ambiguity and build tolerance for the unknown. His new book is How to Not Know: The Value of Uncertainty in a World that Demands Answers. Granola ➡️ If meetings are eating up your day, Granola is a no-brainer. You can try it totally free for three months. Just head to granola.ai/idea Incogni ➡️ Protect your personal information online and get an exclusive 60% off an annual plan at incogni.com/nbi Quince ➡️ Refresh your spring wardrobe and get free shipping and 365-day returns at quince.com/nbi Shopify ➡️ Launch your business for just $1/month. Start selling today at shopify.com/nbi
About The Next Big Idea
The Next Big Idea

The Next Big Idea

By Next Big Idea Club

The Next Big Idea is a weekly series of in-depth interviews with the world’s leading thinkers. Join hosts Rufus Griscom and Caleb Bissinger — along with our curators, Malcolm Gladwell, Adam Grant, Susan Cain, and Daniel Pink — for conversations that might just change the way you see the world. New episodes every Thursday.