Can One Person Change History? Jared Diamond Has the Data.
Can One Person Change History? Jared Diamond Has the Data.
Podcast1 hr 6 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

The insights offer no direct buy or sell recommendations, price targets, or timeframes, so they don’t support a specific actionable trade. When evaluating Procter & Gamble (PG) or other companies, weigh durable business strengths, industry conditions, and economic factors alongside leadership. For perfume and teen apparel businesses, assess how reliably management can anticipate fast-changing customer preferences; for railroads, shipyards, and regulated utilities, focus more on operating conditions, infrastructure, and regulation.

Detailed Analysis

Procter & Gamble (PG)

  • Jared Diamond cited Procter & Gamble as a consistently successful soap company across multiple generations of leaders, illustrating that a company’s underlying strengths can matter as much as its CEO.
  • He described company profits as being influenced by four factors: the year (economic conditions), the company, the industry, and the CEO.

Takeaways

  • The discussion supports looking beyond a company’s current leadership when assessing its prospects: durable business strengths and industry conditions also matter.
  • Procter & Gamble was an example in the conversation, not a specific stock recommendation.

Leadership-Sensitive Businesses: Perfume and Teen Apparel

  • Diamond said CEOs may have greater influence in businesses where consumer preferences shift quickly.
  • He gave perfume and teen apparel as examples: anticipating what customers will want can strongly affect sales and profits.
  • He described a friend in the teen T-shirt business as having made billions by predicting changing preferences, which can shift every couple of weeks. No company was named.

Takeaways

  • In fast-changing consumer businesses, assess whether a company can consistently spot and respond to trends; the discussion suggests leadership and execution can have an outsized effect.
  • The same rapidly changing preferences that create opportunities also make demand harder to predict.

Lower-Discretion Businesses: Railroads, Shipyards, and Regulated Utilities

  • Diamond contrasted those consumer businesses with railroads, shipyards, and water and power utilities.
  • He argued that CEO decisions may have less influence in businesses where infrastructure is already established or government regulation limits choices.

Takeaways

  • For these kinds of businesses, the conversation suggests focusing less on claims about CEO impact and more on the company’s operating conditions, infrastructure, and regulatory constraints.
  • Diamond’s examples were general observations, not recommendations about particular companies or securities.

CEO Influence on Company Profits

  • Diamond said CEOs account for roughly 25% to 30% of the variation in company profits on average, while emphasizing that their influence varies by industry.
  • He also described a Danish study in which a CEO’s spouse or child dying was associated with lower company profits for a period afterward. The discussion presented this as a natural experiment, not as a direct basis for evaluating a specific stock.

Takeaways

  • CEO quality can matter, but the discussion cautions against treating it as the only driver of performance; economic conditions, the company itself, and the industry also matter.
  • The episode gave no stock price targets, timelines, or direct buy or sell recommendations.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
In his Pulitzer Prize–winning book Guns, Germs, and Steel, Jared Diamond showed that the rise of civilizations had more to do with geography, climate, crops, and livestock than with the “great men” history books tend to credit. Now, in Profits, Prophets, Coaches, and Kings, he turns things around and asks whether, after all, one person can change the course of history. 🎥 The Next Big Idea is on YouTube! You can find our episodes ⁠here⁠. 📱 Follow Rufus on ⁠LinkedIn⁠, subscribe to our ⁠Substack⁠, or send us an email at ⁠podcast@nextbigideaclub.com⁠. 🤝 Support us by supporting our sponsors: Granola — If meetings are eating up your day, Granola is a no-brainer. You can try it totally free for three months — just head to granola.ai/idea Hostinger — Describe the website you want and Hostinger’s AI agent builds it in minutes, with plans starting at $3/month. Go to hostinger.com/nbi and use code NBI for 10% off NYU Stern — The leaders who stand out today are those who can turn data into better business outcomes with AI expertise. NYU Stern's one-year, part-time MS in Business Analytics and AI is built for working professionals who want to do exactly that. Apply today to join the class beginning May 2027 at stern.nyu.edu/msbai Sequencing — Go to sequencing.com and use promo code IDEA for 10% off Storyblocks — Storyblocks’ best deal of the year is here for Black Friday: 20% off any annual plan, for a limited time. You get unlimited downloads from a 100% human-made library of footage, music, sound effects and templates, all pre-licensed for monetized content. Claim it at storyblocks.com/nbi Talkiatry — A 100% online psychiatry practice that's in-network with major insurers. Complete a short assessment and get matched with a psychiatrist in minutes at talkiatry.com/idea
About The Next Big Idea
The Next Big Idea

The Next Big Idea

By Next Big Idea Club

The Next Big Idea is a weekly series of in-depth interviews with the world’s leading thinkers. Join hosts Rufus Griscom and Caleb Bissinger — along with our curators, Malcolm Gladwell, Adam Grant, Susan Cain, and Daniel Pink — for conversations that might just change the way you see the world. New episodes every Thursday.