Andrew Ross Sorkin: What the Crash of 1929 Says About Today
Andrew Ross Sorkin: What the Crash of 1929 Says About Today
Podcast1 hr 8 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

While the AI sector shows signs of a speculative bubble, established tech giants like Google and Apple appear more reasonably valued for investors seeking exposure to the theme. Be extremely cautious with private market investments offered to retail investors, as they lack transparency and carry significant risks reminiscent of the SPAC bust. The underlying blockchain technology presents a more durable long-term opportunity than speculative cryptocurrencies, with promising applications in tokenization and stablecoins. Investors should be aware of the extreme leverage available in Bitcoin (BTC), which creates significant volatility and risk. Ultimately, focus on productive assets that generate real cash flow rather than purely speculative plays.

Detailed Analysis

Artificial Intelligence (AI) Sector

  • The speakers express concern that the market is in "some form of an AI bubble," drawing parallels to the internet bubble of the late 1990s.
  • The massive investments by big tech companies are driven more by a fear of being left behind than by clear Return on Investment (ROI) calculations.
  • A major risk is that for current valuations to be justified, AI must create "shocking amounts of productivity."
    • In economic terms, "productivity" is often a euphemism for cutting costs, which usually means eliminating jobs.
    • This could lead to a paradox: if AI eliminates too many jobs, there won't be enough consumers with purchasing power to support the very companies driving the AI boom.
  • The speakers suggest a "washout" of some AI companies is likely, similar to what happened after the dot-com bubble, even though the underlying technology (like the internet) is revolutionary and will be a major part of our lives.

Takeaways

  • While AI technology is transformative for the long term, the current market sentiment may be overly euphoric, leading to inflated valuations.
  • Investors should be cautious about indiscriminate spending in the AI space and question whether companies can generate enough real-world cash flow to justify their stock prices.
  • Be aware that the path to AI integration may involve significant economic disruption, including job losses, which could create headwinds for the broader economy and the market.

Nvidia (NVDA)

  • Nvidia is compared to RCA in the 1920s, which was a hot, innovative stock that everyone believed was "the future," driving its price up dramatically.
  • The company's success is acknowledged, with the speaker noting an investor would have made an "extraordinary amount of money" by owning the stock.
  • A specific deal is highlighted as a potential red flag: Nvidia's investment in OpenAI, which then uses the funds to buy Nvidia's chips.
    • This is described as a "round trip deal" or "circular financing," a practice that can be a signal of a market bubble.
    • While the deal has some safeguards (it's released in tranches based on milestones), it's indicative of the speculative nature of current AI investments.

Takeaways

  • Nvidia is at the center of the AI boom, and its stock performance reflects that. However, its high valuation and the circular nature of some of its financing deals warrant caution.
  • Investors should look beyond the hype and analyze the sustainability of the company's revenue and the broader health of the AI ecosystem it supplies. The comparison to RCA in the 1920s serves as a historical reminder that even revolutionary companies can become dangerously overvalued.

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • The discussion highlights the availability of extreme leverage in the crypto market, with mentions of 20x to 50x leverage available on Bitcoin through options and other products. This is presented as a modern parallel to the excessive leverage that led to the 1929 crash.
  • Bitcoin's intrinsic value is questioned. It's contrasted with "productive assets" (like a farm or a software company) that generate real economic value.
    • The speaker references Warren Buffett's view of Bitcoin as "rat poison."
    • The value of Bitcoin is described as having a "religious aspect," dependent on a community of believers rather than underlying cash flows.
  • The speaker is neutral on its future price, stating he doesn't believe it will go to a million dollars, nor does he believe it will go to zero.
  • While Bitcoin itself is likely not large enough to cause a systemic crisis, its interconnectedness with other assets could pose a risk. If highly leveraged crypto investors face losses, they may be forced to sell other "real assets" to cover their debts, creating a ripple effect.

Takeaways

  • Investing in Bitcoin carries significant risk, partly due to its lack of intrinsic value generation and its price being driven heavily by sentiment.
  • The availability of high leverage in the crypto space is a major risk factor. Investors should be extremely cautious about using leverage and be aware that forced selling from leveraged players can cause extreme price volatility.
  • While Bitcoin may have a place in some portfolios, it should be viewed as a highly speculative asset.

Blockchain Technology

  • A strong distinction is made between specific cryptocurrencies (like Bitcoin) and the underlying blockchain technology.
  • The speaker is very bullish on the future of blockchain, stating it will play a "hugely" important role in the future of finance.
  • Specific promising applications mentioned include:
    • Stablecoins: For enabling seamless and rapid global money transfers.
    • Tokenization: The ability to create digital tokens representing fractional ownership of hard assets (like real estate), which could revolutionize how these assets are bought and sold.

Takeaways

  • The underlying blockchain technology has revolutionary potential far beyond speculative cryptocurrencies.
  • Investors interested in this space could look for opportunities related to the infrastructure and application of blockchain technology itself, which may be a more durable long-term investment theme than any single cryptocurrency.

Private Markets (Venture Capital & Private Equity)

  • A key risk in the current market is the trend of "democratizing finance" by giving retail investors access to private market assets, such as shares in SpaceX and OpenAI, often through crypto tokens.
  • These private investments lack the transparency and disclosure requirements of publicly traded stocks.
    • Public companies must provide audited financials and regular reports, which do not exist in the same way for private companies.
  • The recent SPAC (Special Purpose Acquisition Company) boom is cited as a cautionary tale where retail investors were given early access to private companies, and "very few people won and most people lost." The losses were attributed to a lack of transparency around fees, conflicts of interest, and unreliable financial projections.

Takeaways

  • Be extremely cautious when considering investments in private companies, especially when offered through new, less-regulated channels like crypto tokens.
  • The lack of transparency and investor protection in private markets creates significant risk. Understand that you are often investing with less information than institutional players.
  • The promise of "getting in early" can be alluring, but as the SPAC boom showed, it often comes with higher risks and unfavorable terms for the average investor.

Big Tech

  • The host makes a bull case that "this time is different" for big, established tech companies, arguing that network effects and technological convergence allow them to continue growing revenue at double-digit rates even at a multi-trillion dollar scale.
  • The speaker generally agrees that most big tech companies do not look like the "mania" of 1929.
    • He notes that companies like Google and Apple have P/E ratios in the high 20s, which is not dramatically higher than a stable consumer company like Coca-Cola.
  • The primary bubble-like behavior is seen in smaller AI-focused companies and the crypto space, not necessarily in the established tech giants.

Takeaways

  • While the broader market, especially in AI, shows signs of speculative excess, the valuations of the largest, most profitable tech companies may be more reasonable.
  • Investors should differentiate between the speculative frenzy in emerging tech and the more stable, cash-flow-positive business models of established tech leaders.
  • Even for these giants, the pressure to invest heavily in AI to avoid being left behind could impact future profitability and introduces new risks.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Andrew Ross Sorkin’s new book, 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History—and How It Shattered a Nation, is an eye-opening account of the forces that led to the worst financial crisis in history, and the lessons that disaster can teach us about today’s economy. Andrew Ross Sorkin’s new book, 1929: Inside the Greatest Crash in Wall Street History—and How It Shattered a Nation, is an eye-opening account of the forces that led to the worst financial crisis in history and the lessons that disaster can teach us about today’s economy. (7:09) What life was like before the crash (8:58) How Americans developed a taste for leverage (17:10) What happened on Black Thursday (20:05) Why so few people saw the crash coming (26:23) Could the crash have been averted? (37:13) Andrew’s fascination with money (39:22) What if financial bubbles are a feature, not a bug? (41:35) Could we be headed for another 1929? (45:00) The dangers of leverage (53:16) Will the blockchain change the future of finance? Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About The Next Big Idea
The Next Big Idea

The Next Big Idea

By Next Big Idea Club

The Next Big Idea is a weekly series of in-depth interviews with the world’s leading thinkers. Join hosts Rufus Griscom and Caleb Bissinger — along with our curators, Malcolm Gladwell, Adam Grant, Susan Cain, and Daniel Pink — for conversations that might just change the way you see the world. New episodes every Thursday.