The skyscrapers that NIMBYs and zoning couldn't stop
The skyscrapers that NIMBYs and zoning couldn't stop
42 days agoPlanet MoneyNPR
Podcast22 min 24 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Investors should prioritize Vancouver rental real estate to capitalize on the city's chronic housing shortage and "bonkers" rent increases. Focus on projects like Senak that utilize "regulatory arbitrage" by building on sovereign land, as bypassing municipal zoning can increase land valuation by up to 50%. Look for developers shifting from condos to long-term rental apartments, which act as high-yield "ATMs" that remain resilient during periods of high inflation and interest rates. Prioritize companies that have secured Service Agreements for infrastructure and government backing, such as the $1 billion CAD low-interest loan provided to the Squamish Nation. Adopt a "Seven Generations" investment philosophy by favoring high-density skyscraper developments that maximize scarce land utility for long-term generational wealth.

Detailed Analysis

This analysis explores the investment landscape of the Senak (Sən̓aʔqʷ) development project in Vancouver, a unique economic experiment led by the Squamish Nation. It highlights the intersection of indigenous sovereignty, real estate development, and the removal of regulatory barriers.


Vancouver Real Estate Market (Residential & Rental)

The transcript identifies Vancouver as one of the most expensive cities in the world, characterized by a severe housing shortage and "bonkers" rent increases. The market is historically constrained by geography (surrounded by water) and restrictive zoning laws.

Takeaways

  • Supply-Demand Imbalance: The city suffers from a chronic lack of inventory. Projects that bypass traditional zoning—like Senak—are positioned to capture high demand from a population priced out of homeownership.
  • The "YIMBY" Shift: Public sentiment is shifting from "NIMBY" (Not In My Backyard) to "YIMBY" (Yes In My Backyard). Investors should note that pro-housing movements are beginning to influence local politics, potentially easing future development hurdles.
  • Rental vs. Sale: The Squamish Nation’s strategy focuses on rental apartments rather than condos for sale. This creates a long-term "ATM" (recurring cash flow) model, which is highly resilient in high-inflation or high-interest-rate environments where buying a home is difficult.

Senak Development Project

This is a massive "mega-project" consisting of 11 skyscrapers (up to 60 stories) on 10.5 acres of sovereign land near downtown Vancouver. It aims to add 6,000 new apartments to the market.

Takeaways

  • Regulatory Arbitrage: Because the land is sovereign Squamish territory, the project is exempt from city zoning laws, parking requirements, and height limits. This allows for extreme density, which significantly increases the potential Return on Investment (ROI) per square foot.
  • Speed to Market: The project is moving "crazy fast" because it avoids the typical multi-year legal battles and permitting delays associated with municipal planning boards.
  • Valuation Premium: According to the mentioned MIT/Princeton study, land with pre-approved permits or "by-right" development capabilities is worth 50% more than restricted land. The Squamish Nation effectively holds the most valuable development rights in the region due to this lack of red tape.
  • Government Backing: The project received a $1 billion (CAD) low-interest loan from the Canadian federal government, signaling strong institutional and political support for large-scale rental housing.

Real Estate Development Risks (NIMBYism & Permitting)

The transcript highlights "concentrated costs versus diffuse benefits" as a primary risk to real estate investment.

Takeaways

  • Hidden Costs of Delay: In cities like Los Angeles or Vancouver, the slow permitting process can account for one-third of total construction costs. Investors in traditional real estate firms should factor in these "hidden costs" of bureaucracy.
  • Infrastructure Requirements: Even sovereign projects must negotiate with municipalities for "tie-ins" to sewage, power, and roads. Investors should look for developments that have secured Service Agreements with local cities to ensure the project doesn't become a "stranded asset."
  • Social License: While the Squamish can legally ignore neighbors, they chose to fund traffic upgrades and bike lanes. This suggests that even "unregulated" projects benefit from maintaining a "social license to operate" to avoid long-term friction.

Investment Theme: "Seven Generations" Planning

The Squamish Nation utilizes a "Seven Generations" framework—planning for the wealth and health of descendants 150+ years into the future.

Takeaways

  • Long-Horizon Investing: This approach prioritizes generational wealth over quarterly earnings. For the general public, this translates to the "buy and hold" philosophy.
  • Asset Selection: The transition from "mid-rise" (modest profit) to "skyscraper" (massive profit) shows that when planning for the long term, maximizing the utility of a scarce resource (land) is the most effective way to ensure survival and prosperity across decades.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
LIVE SHOW TOUR INFO HERE. New stories, live tapings, special guests, book signings and more.  What would you build on a piece of land when all the normal rules go out the window? On today’s show, how the Squamish Nation reclaimed a sliver of prime urban real estate and were liberated from zoning restrictions, to the consternation of their wealthy NIMBY neighbors. We trace the 100 year saga of what might be the most interesting real estate development in North America right now: There’s a violent eviction, a tense legal battle, and a giant, tough decision for the Squamish Nation that culminates in the daring project that they’re building today. It’s a story with lessons for every city trying to lower housing costs and build more. This episode is adapted from Planet Money: A Guide To The Economic Forces That Shape Your Life. Pre-order before April 7 and you can get a poster. Details here.  The working paper we mentioned on “ready-to-issue” permits in Los Angeles. Subscribe to Planet Money+ Listen free: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, the NPR app or anywhere you get podcasts. Facebook / Instagram / TikTok / Our weekly Newsletter. This episode was produced by Sam Yellowhorse Kesler with an assist from Emma Peaslee. It was edited by Jess Jiang, fact-checked by Sierra Juarez and engineered by Cena Loffredo. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money’s executive producer.  To manage podcast ad preferences, review the links below: See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for sponsorship and to manage your podcast sponsorship preferences. Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices NPR Privacy Policy
About Planet Money
Planet Money

Planet Money

By NPR

Wanna see a trick? Give us any topic and we can tie it back to the economy. At <em>Planet Money</em>, we explore the forces that shape our lives and bring you along for the ride. Don't just understand the economy – understand the world.<br><br><em>Wanna go deeper? <em>Subscribe to </em><em>Planet Money+ and get sponsor-free episodes of Planet Money, The Indicator, and Planet Money Summer School. Plus access to bonus content. It's a new way to support the show you love. Learn more at plus.npr.org/planetmoney</em><br></em>