Asking for a friend … which jobs are safe from AI?
Asking for a friend … which jobs are safe from AI?
241 days agoPlanet MoneyNPR
Podcast28 min 51 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider a long-term "picks and shovels" strategy for the Artificial Intelligence theme by investing in companies that provide its core infrastructure. For direct exposure to a leading AI developer, look at Microsoft (MSFT) due to its deep partnership with the private company OpenAI. As a defensive play, consider investing in companies that support AI-resistant skilled trades like plumbing and electrical work. In highly exposed sectors like law and finance, seek out innovative firms that use AI to augment employee productivity rather than simply automate jobs. Finally, Apple (AAPL) remains a compelling investment as it expands into financial services to further lock in its user base.

Detailed Analysis

Investment Theme: AI as a General-Purpose Technology

  • The podcast discusses research that frames Artificial Intelligence (AI) not as a niche product, but as a General-Purpose Technology (GPT), similar in scale and impact to electricity.
  • This implies that AI's influence will be vast, touching nearly every corner of the economy and fundamentally changing how work is done across many industries.
  • The researchers suggest that because the changes will be so large and widespread, it is very difficult to predict the specific outcomes, such as which jobs will disappear and which new ones will be created (e.g., the job "electrician" didn't exist before electricity).

Takeaways

  • Long-Term Bullish Outlook: Viewing AI as a foundational technology like electricity suggests it is a long-term, secular growth trend. Investors should consider strategic, long-term exposure to the AI sector rather than treating it as a short-term trade.
  • Broad-Based Impact: The GPT thesis means that AI is not just a "tech" investment. Investors should look for companies in all sectors (finance, healthcare, manufacturing, etc.) that are effectively integrating AI to improve their products and services.
  • "Picks and Shovels" Play: As with any major technological shift, a viable investment strategy is to invest in the companies that provide the essential tools and infrastructure. In the case of AI, this includes companies that develop the AI models, the software to use them, and the hardware that powers them. The podcast specifically mentions the importance of learning to use AI, which points to growth in AI software and training services.

Investment Theme: AI-Exposed vs. AI-Resistant Sectors

  • The discussion analyzes jobs based on their "exposure" to AI, meaning how much AI can help with the tasks involved. This creates two distinct categories for investors to consider.
  • Low Exposure / "AI-Resistant" Sectors:
    • These are primarily physical, blue-collar jobs where a human presence is essential.
    • Examples mentioned include plumbers, electricians, welders, dredge operators, athletes, and short-order cooks.
    • Risk Mentioned: One researcher noted that if everyone rushes into a "safe" field like welding, a surplus of workers could drive wages down.
  • High Exposure / "AI-Transformative" Sectors:
    • These are primarily knowledge-worker jobs that involve tasks that Large Language Models (LLMs) can perform or assist with.
    • Examples mentioned include lawyers, paralegals, translators, writers, public relations specialists, tax preparers, and insurance appraisers.
    • The key point stressed is that "exposure" does not equal "automation." High exposure can lead to massive productivity gains, which could be very positive for companies and employees who adapt.

Takeaways

  • Defensive Play in Skilled Trades: The "low exposure" sectors could represent a defensive investment strategy. Companies that manufacture tools, provide training, or offer services for skilled trades may see stable demand that is less affected by AI disruption.
  • Focus on Innovators, Not Sectors: For "high exposure" sectors like law and media, the key is to differentiate between companies. Investors should look for firms that are actively and intelligently augmenting their employees with AI to improve productivity and create higher-value services, rather than simply using AI for cost-cutting and layoffs. The podcast gives an example of paralegals who flourished when using AI to eliminate tedious tasks, allowing them to take on more advanced work.
  • Avoid the "Automation Hit List" Mindset: The research explicitly warns against viewing the high-exposure list as an "automation hit list." A highly exposed job could become more valuable and higher-paying if AI makes the worker dramatically more productive and demand for their work increases.

Investment Theme: The "Human" (EPOC) Factor

  • A second framework discussed is the EPOC score, which measures a job's reliance on uniquely human skills: Empathy, Presence, Opinion (judgment/ethics), Creativity, and Hope (vision/leadership).
  • The theory is that jobs with high EPOC scores are more likely to be complemented by AI rather than replaced, as machines cannot easily replicate these traits.
  • High-scoring jobs mentioned include emergency management directors, managers of all kinds (including IT project managers), and substance abuse counselors.
  • Even jobs like construction worker scored surprisingly high on empathy due to tasks involving mentoring and teaching others.

Takeaways

  • Invest in "Human-Centric" Businesses: This framework suggests long-term value in businesses where the core offering is built on human judgment, creativity, and relationships. This could include fields like high-end consulting, specialized healthcare, therapy, and creative agencies.
  • Look for Complementary Models: When evaluating a company, consider how it combines technology with human expertise. A business that uses AI to handle clerical work while freeing up its employees to focus on high-EPOC tasks (like client relationships or strategic thinking) may have a more durable competitive advantage.

Apple (AAPL)

  • Apple was mentioned as a sponsor for the Apple Card.
  • The ad highlighted the card's design, its integration with the iPhone, and its rewards program (3% back at Apple).
  • The card is noted as being issued by Goldman Sachs Bank USA.

Takeaways

  • Financial Services Expansion: This reinforces Apple's ongoing strategy to expand into the financial technology (FinTech) space, leveraging its enormous and loyal customer base.
  • Ecosystem Lock-In: By offering financial products like the Apple Card, Apple further integrates users into its ecosystem of hardware, software, and services, making it harder for customers to switch to competitors.
  • Strategic Partnerships: The mention of Goldman Sachs (GS) as the issuer highlights the model of Big Tech partnering with traditional financial institutions to roll out new products.

Other Company Mentions

  • OpenAI (Private Company): Researchers from OpenAI co-authored one of the key studies discussed. This places OpenAI at the forefront of not just developing AI, but also understanding its broad economic implications.
    • Takeaway: While OpenAI is not publicly traded, investors can gain exposure to its ecosystem through its key partners and backers, most notably Microsoft (MSFT).
  • Vanguard (Private Company): Mentioned as a sponsor, highlighting its actively managed institutional bond funds run by a large global team.
    • Takeaway: This positions Vanguard as a provider of professionally managed, "human-led" investment products, which is an interesting contrast to the podcast's theme of AI automation. It suggests a market for both automated and human-centric financial services.
  • LinkedIn (owned by Microsoft - MSFT): Mentioned as a sponsor for its advertising platform.
    • Takeaway: This highlights a key B2B revenue stream for Microsoft. The health of LinkedIn's ad business is tied to corporate spending and the overall strength of the professional labor market.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
There’s one question we seem to be hearing everywhere: “Is my job safe from AI?” Dozens of you, our listeners, have written to us about this. Saying things like, “Maybe my yoga teacher side gig is actually my safest bet now,” and “My parents were in real estate, and I never thought I’d say it ... but maybe that’s what I should do?”   If only there were a list that could tell you which jobs are safe from AI. We go looking for that list…and find that the AI future is going to be even weirder than we’d imagined. Today on the show: We talk to two researchers who have come up with some first drafts of the future. We learned more about the machines that might be coming for our jobs, and also, more about what it actually means to be human. Subscribe to Planet Money+ Listen free: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, the NPR app or anywhere you get podcasts. Facebook / Instagram / TikTok / Our weekly Newsletter. Today’s episode was produced by Eric Mennel and edited by Marianne McCune. It was fact-checked by Sierra Juarez and engineered by Robert Rodriguez. Alex Goldmark is Planet Money's executive producer. Learn more about sponsor message choices: podcastchoices.com/adchoices NPR Privacy Policy
About Planet Money
Planet Money

Planet Money

By NPR

Wanna see a trick? Give us any topic and we can tie it back to the economy. At <em>Planet Money</em>, we explore the forces that shape our lives and bring you along for the ride. Don't just understand the economy – understand the world.<br><br><em>Wanna go deeper? <em>Subscribe to </em><em>Planet Money+ and get sponsor-free episodes of Planet Money, The Indicator, and Planet Money Summer School. Plus access to bonus content. It's a new way to support the show you love. Learn more at plus.npr.org/planetmoney</em><br></em>