Mamdani's Win, Palantir's Stock Slide, and Tesla's Pay Package
Mamdani's Win, Palantir's Stock Slide, and Tesla's Pay Package
183 days agoPivotNew York Magazine
Podcast1 hr 1 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Famed investor Michael Burry has placed significant bets against high-flying tech stocks Palantir (PLTR) and NVIDIA (NVDA), signaling potential overvaluation concerns for these market leaders. Despite its strong performance, PLTR is considered extremely risky due to its valuation of nearly 300 times earnings, making it a "meme stock" disconnected from fundamentals. Tesla (TSLA) investors should watch the upcoming shareholder vote on Elon Musk's pay package, as its outcome is a key event that could cause significant stock volatility. For sophisticated investors, a high-risk opportunity exists in buying tariff claims from companies at a deep discount before a key Supreme Court ruling. This speculative trade is estimated to have a one-in-three chance of success, offering a potentially massive payout if the court orders the government to issue refunds.

Detailed Analysis

Palantir (PLTR)

  • The company reported "Blockbuster Earnings," beating analyst expectations on both revenue and profit.
    • Revenue was $1.2 billion versus $1.1 billion expected.
    • Commercial software sales grew an impressive 121% year-over-year.
    • Sales to the U.S. government grew 52%.
  • Despite the strong results, the stock fell 8%. This was partly due to news that famed investor Michael Burry (from "The Big Short") bought over $1 billion in put options, which is a bet that the stock price will go down.
  • The discussion highlighted a massive disconnect between the company's performance and its stock valuation.
    • It trades at almost 300 times earnings and 125 times sales, making it one of the most expensive stocks in the S&P 500.
    • It has a similar market value to Netflix but with only one-tenth of the revenue.
  • The sentiment is that Palantir is an "incredible company" but is also "dramatically overvalued." It is described as a "meme stock" that has "lost all connection to the underlying metrics" that are traditionally used to value companies.

Takeaways

  • High Risk vs. High Growth: Palantir is a classic example of a high-growth company with a sky-high valuation. While its business is performing exceptionally well, the stock price may already reflect years of future growth.
  • Beware the Meme Stock Factor: The stock's price movement is not just tied to its financial results but also to retail investor sentiment, making it highly volatile and unpredictable. Shorting the stock is described as dangerous because its price could double and "make even less sense."
  • Follow the Big Money: When a well-known investor like Michael Burry makes a large bet against a stock, it's a significant risk signal that investors should be aware of, even if they are bullish on the company's long-term prospects.

NVIDIA (NVDA)

  • NVIDIA was mentioned alongside Palantir as one of the two companies that investor Michael Burry is shorting (betting against) with a large position in put options.
  • The host described the idea of shorting NVIDIA and Palantir as "batshit crazy" because they are the companies "making all the money" in the current market.

Takeaways

  • Potential Overvaluation Signal: While the podcast doesn't go into detail on NVIDIA's fundamentals, the fact that a prominent investor known for spotting market bubbles is betting against it suggests that its valuation may be stretched after its massive run-up.
  • A Contrarian View: This serves as a reminder that even for the market's top-performing stocks, there are credible arguments that they may be overvalued. Investors should consider both the bullish case (strong AI-driven growth) and the bearish case (potential for a price correction).

Tesla (TSLA)

  • The discussion centered on the upcoming shareholder vote on CEO Elon Musk's massive pay package.
  • The host predicts that the pay package will be approved, despite opposition from major shareholder advisory firms and a large Norwegian investment fund.
  • The reasoning is that Tesla shareholders are not investing in a traditional car company—whose auto revenues are "declining faster. Incredibly fast"—but are instead betting on Elon Musk himself.
  • The fear that Musk might leave if the package is not approved is likely to persuade shareholders to vote in favor of it, as his leadership is seen as critical to the stock's value.

Takeaways

  • A Bet on Musk, Not Just the Company: Investing in Tesla is fundamentally a bet on Elon Musk's ability to "pull another rabbit the size of Jupiter out of a hat." The company's valuation is deeply tied to investor faith in him personally.
  • Key Person Risk: The heavy reliance on Musk presents a significant risk. If he were to leave or become less focused on Tesla, the stock could be severely impacted, regardless of the company's underlying performance.
  • Watch the Vote: The outcome of the shareholder vote on the pay package will be a major indicator of investor sentiment and could cause significant volatility in the stock price.

Investment Strategy: Buying Tariff Claims

  • A speculative investment strategy was discussed related to the Trump-era tariffs that are currently being challenged in the Supreme Court.
  • The core idea is that if the Supreme Court rules the tariffs were illegal, the U.S. government may have to refund the billions of dollars paid by companies that imported goods.
  • The investment play is to buy the "claims" for these tariff payments from the companies that paid them.
    • For example, a company that paid $10 million in tariffs might sell its claim to that money for 10 to 15 cents on the dollar (i.e., for $1 million to $1.5 million) because they don't expect to ever get it back.
    • If the court orders a refund, the investor who bought the claim would receive the full $10 million, resulting in a massive profit.
  • The host estimates there is a "one in three chance" of this happening, suggesting a favorable risk-reward profile for this high-risk strategy.

Takeaways

  • Event-Driven Investing: This is an example of an advanced, event-driven investment strategy that depends on a specific legal outcome. It is not a traditional stock investment and carries a high degree of risk.
  • Distressed and Special Situations: For more sophisticated investors, this highlights opportunities that can be found in "special situations" like legal challenges or bankruptcies, where assets can be purchased at a deep discount to their potential future value.

Investment Strategy: FTX Bankruptcy Claims (featuring Anthropic)

  • As a successful example of the strategy above, the host mentioned buying claims against the bankrupt crypto exchange FTX.
  • The investment thesis was based on research into FTX's bankruptcy filings, which revealed a $500 million investment in the AI company Anthropic.
  • The host believed this stake in Anthropic was now worth $2 to $3 billion.
  • This hidden value meant that the claims against FTX, which were trading for just 22 cents on the dollar, were significantly undervalued.

Takeaways

  • Do Your Homework: This example shows the value of deep research, especially in unconventional situations. Reading through financial documents like bankruptcy filings can uncover hidden assets that the broader market has overlooked.
  • Value in Unexpected Places: Valuable assets can be found within failed companies. In this case, a stake in a hot AI startup (Anthropic) was the key to unlocking value from a bankrupt crypto exchange (FTX).
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Kara and Scott discuss Democrats' Election Night victories, and what they mean for the 2026 midterms. Then, Palantir's stock takes a dive amid overvaluation and shorting concerns, and Tesla shareholders vote on Elon Musk's trillion-dollar pay package. Plus, Trump's tariffs face the Supreme Court, and the far right erupts in civil war over Tucker Carlson's interview with white nationalist Nick Fuentes. We're going on tour! Get tickets at pivottour.com Watch this episode on the ⁠⁠Pivot YouTube channel⁠⁠.Follow us on Instagram and Threads at ⁠⁠@pivotpodcastofficial⁠⁠.Follow us on Bluesky at ⁠⁠@pivotpod.bsky.social⁠⁠Follow us on TikTok at ⁠⁠@pivotpodcast⁠⁠.Send us your questions by calling us at 855-51-PIVOT, or email Pivot@voxmedia.com Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices
About Pivot
Pivot

Pivot

By New York Magazine

Every Tuesday and Friday, tech journalist Kara Swisher and NYU Professor Scott Galloway offer sharp, unfiltered insights into the biggest stories in tech, business, and politics. They make bold predictions, pick winners and losers, and bicker and banter like no one else. After all, with great power comes great scrutiny. From New York Magazine and the Vox Media Podcast Network.