What's Actually Going On With Private Credit
What's Actually Going On With Private Credit
12 days agoOdd LotsBloomberg
Podcast50 min 47 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Investors seeking higher yields should prioritize Double B rated public high-yield bonds, as the riskiest Triple C borrowers have migrated into the less transparent private credit market. If you are considering retail private credit vehicles like the Cliffwater Corporate Lending Fund (CCLFX), treat these as 5-to-10-year commitments due to quarterly redemption "gates" that limit liquidity during market stress. Avoid funds or managers heavily exposed to Payment-in-Kind (PIK) interest, as this practice of paying debt with more debt often masks underlying corporate distress. Be cautious of SaaS-focused private debt, which lacks physical collateral and faces significantly lower recovery values if subscription revenues falter. Monitor your portfolio for companies with leverage exceeding 6x enterprise value, as these firms face a high risk of default as floating-rate loans reset to current interest levels.

Detailed Analysis

Private Credit (Sector Analysis)

Private credit has evolved from a niche financing tool into a massive asset class, now estimated to be larger than the public junk bond market. Historically rooted in "shadow banking" and internal corporate lending (like GE Capital), it saw a "step function" growth after the 2008 financial crisis due to stricter bank regulations and an investor search for yield during the zero-interest-rate era.

Takeaways

Structural Shift in Quality: The rise of private credit has actually improved the quality of the public high-yield (junk bond) market. Riskier, highly leveraged companies that used to issue public junk bonds are now moving to private credit. • Double B bonds (higher quality junk) now make up ~60% of the high-yield market, up from 35%. • Triple C bonds (riskiest) have dropped to ~9% from over 20%. • The "Subscription" Risk: Unlike Private Equity, which calls for cash only when a deal is found, many retail-facing private credit funds take money upfront. This creates "drag" on performance, forcing managers to deploy cash quickly, which can lead to weaker underwriting and lower standards just to get the money working. • Valuation "Mirage": Private credit often appears less volatile because assets are not "marked to market" daily like public stocks. This can lull investors into a false sense of security during market downturns.


Software as a Service (SaaS) & Tech Debt

A major trend in private credit is the financing of software companies. Historically, tech and debt did not mix because tech companies lacked physical assets (like factories) to use as collateral.

Takeaways

Cash Flow as Collateral: Lenders now treat predictable subscription revenue (SaaS) as a financeable asset. • High Leverage Risk: Some sponsors are paying 16-17x enterprise value for software firms and using private credit to fund the gap. • Recovery Risk: If a software company fails, there are no "hard assets" (like real estate or machinery) to sell. In a default, recovery values for these loans could be significantly lower than in traditional industries.


Interval Funds & BDCs (CCLFX)

The podcast highlights the Cliffwater Corporate Lending Fund (CCLFX) as a prime example of the massive growth in the retail private credit space. These vehicles allow individual investors to access private debt but come with specific liquidity rules.

Takeaways

The Role of "Gates": Most of these funds have "gates" that limit redemptions to ~5% of the fund per quarter. • Insight: These gates are critical to prevent a "bank run" scenario, but they can create a "slow-motion" crisis if investors lose confidence and everyone lines up to exit at once. • Contagion Risk: If redemptions spike, managers may be forced to sell their "best" (most liquid) assets first to pay out exiting investors, potentially leaving remaining shareholders with a portfolio of lower-quality, stressed loans.


Investment Themes & Sector Sentiment

Bullish/Neutral Factors

Relationship Lending: Private credit offers "expediency" and "certainty of execution" for companies, making it a preferred choice over volatile public markets. • Insurance Synergy: Insurance companies are natural fits for private credit because they have long-term liabilities and can harvest the "illiquidity premium" (extra return for locking money up).

Bearish/Risk Factors

The "Six Times" Rule: Historically, companies with leverage greater than 6x struggle to survive. With current high interest rates, many private credit-backed firms are now well above this threshold, increasing default risks. • PIK (Payment-in-Kind) Interest: Some stressed borrowers are paying interest with more debt (PIK) rather than cash. This masks distress and grows the loan balance, creating a "ticking time bomb" for future defaults. • Refinancing Cliff: Many loans from the 2020-2021 era were made when rates were near zero. As these floating-rate loans reset to 10-12% interest, corporate cash flows are being "chewed up," potentially leading to a 15% default rate in some pockets of the market.


Actionable Insights for Investors

Monitor Manager Dispersion: The "easy money" era of private credit is over. Investors should expect a wide gap in performance between "old school" disciplined lenders and newer firms that grew too fast. • Check the "Covenants": In the current hyper-competitive environment, many private loans are "covenant-lite," meaning lenders have fewer legal protections if the borrower’s performance slips. • Liquidity Awareness: If investing in BDCs or Interval Funds, understand that you cannot exit quickly during a crisis. These should be viewed as 5-10 year commitments, not liquid substitutes for bond ETFs.

Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
The private credit market has grown enormously fast in recent years — so much so that by some estimates it's now bigger than the market for junk-rated corporate bonds. So what's driven all that growth? What impact has private credit had on other types of corporate debt? And why are there so many concerns around the space right now? In this episode, we speak with John Sheehan and Craig Manchuck, two veteran portfolio managers for the strategic income fund at Osterweis Capital Management. We talk about the history of private credit before and after 2008, private credit's links with private equity and insurance, the prospect of higher defaults, and what to watch for right now. Subscribe to the Odd Lots Newsletter Join the conversation: discord.gg/oddlots See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
About Odd Lots
Odd Lots

Odd Lots

By Bloomberg

<p>Bloomberg's Joe Weisenthal and Tracy Alloway explore the most interesting topics in finance, markets and economics. Join the conversation every Monday and Thursday.</p>