Rory Johnston on Why His $200 Oil Prediction Didn't Turn Out Right
Rory Johnston on Why His $200 Oil Prediction Didn't Turn Out Right
1 hour agoOdd LotsBloomberg
Podcast32 min 15 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Investors should avoid chasing geopolitical price spikes in Brent Crude as the market has shifted into Contango, signaling a surplus that makes $150 targets unrealistic in the near term. Monitor China for a high-conviction re-entry signal; a return to the spot market by the world’s largest importer will likely establish a firm price floor for oil. Do not expect the transition to Electric Vehicles to collapse demand immediately, as internal combustion engines still outnumber EVs 10-to-1 in the critical Chinese market. Look for long-term opportunities in energy infrastructure and storage, specifically companies involved with ADNOC or the U.S. Strategic Petroleum Reserve, as nations eventually move to refill depleted stockpiles. Be cautious of high volatility suppressing trade volumes, and instead focus on regional shifts caused by new facilities like the Dangote Petroleum Refinery.

Detailed Analysis

Crude Oil (Brent)

• Despite the closure of the Strait of Hormuz (a major geopolitical tail risk), Brent crude prices failed to reach the "doomsday" predictions of $150–$200 per barrel, peaking instead near $120. • The market is currently experiencing a disconnect between physical supply stress and financial pricing, with Brent recently trading below $74. • The market has transitioned into Contango (where the current price is lower than future prices), signaling a surplus of supply relative to immediate demand.

Takeaways

Monitor the "War Premium": The geopolitical risk premium is deflating rapidly. Investors should be cautious of assuming that conflict automatically leads to sustained price spikes in the current high-inventory environment. • Watch for Re-entry: A key indicator for a price floor will be when China returns to the spot market as a competitive buyer, which has not yet happened.


China (Oil Import Strategy)

• China, the world's largest crude importer, reduced imports by upwards of 5 million barrels per day during the crisis—roughly half of the total spot market supply hit to Asia. • This massive reduction acted as a "silent" stabilizer, preventing other Asian nations (Japan, South Korea, Taiwan) from facing extreme price competition. • Mystery of Demand: While mobility data in China remained stable, implied demand destruction was on par with COVID-zero levels. This suggests China was likely drawing down underground strategic reserves and refined product stocks (gasoline/diesel) that are not visible to satellite tracking.

Takeaways

Inventory as a Buffer: China’s ability to swing its import demand by 5 million barrels per day makes it the most significant "swing consumer" in the world, rivaling the impact of the IEA’s strategic releases. • EV Transition Lag: Despite high EV sales (60% of new sales), the total vehicle fleet remains 10-to-1 in favor of internal combustion engines. Do not expect EVs to structurally collapse Chinese oil demand in the immediate short term.


Strategic Petroleum Reserves (SPR)

• The cumulative volume of oil shut in during the Hormuz crisis was approximately 1.3 billion barrels. • Offsets included: • IEA SPR Releases: ~400 million barrels. • Chinese Import Reductions: 400–500 million barrels. • The U.S. SPR is nearing "operational minimums," limiting the government's future ability to intervene if another shock occurs.

Takeaways

Refill Demand: There is a looming structural demand undercurrent as countries like the U.S., Japan, and India seek to refill depleted reserves. However, this demand will likely only manifest when the market is loose to avoid self-inflicted price spikes. • New Infrastructure: Watch for investment in storage infrastructure in emerging markets; for example, ADNOC is planning a 50-million-barrel strategic stock in India.


Energy Sector Themes & Risks

Market Resilience: The oil market proved more resilient to a major supply shock than analysts expected, largely due to "inventory responding to price" rather than "production responding to price." • The "Jawbone" Effect: Aggressive rhetoric and downside volatility injected by political administrations (specifically mentioned: the Trump administration) created a "everyone is bullish but no one is buying" sentiment among traders, preventing a price melt-up. • Refinery Developments: The opening of the Dangote Petroleum Refinery in Nigeria is noted as a significant global engineering feat that could alter regional product flows.

Takeaways

Risk Management: Traders' risk limits were "throttled down by 90%" due to extreme volatility, which suppressed the normal price discovery process. • Supply Chain Shifts: The successful use of the Saudi East-West pipeline and the Emirati pipeline to Fujairah proved that rerouting options for Gulf oil are more viable than previously tested, reducing the future "chokehold" power of the Strait of Hormuz.

Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
The Strait of Hormuz has (mostly) re-opened! Crude prices are still up since the start of the war with Iran, but popular predictions earlier this year of $200-a-barrel Brent didn’t pan out. Why is that? We last talked to Rory Johnston, the founder of the Commodity Context newsletter, at the start of the conflict. And in that conversation he said that the Strait’s closure would lead to $200 oil if it persisted for any length of time. Today, he returns to tell us what he’s learned about the oil market since then. He explains the various factors that kept a lid on prices, including some re-routing, Trump jawboning, and (crucially) surprise import reductions from China. Previous: Rory Johnston on How Oil Could Surge to Over $200 a Barrel Only Bloomberg.com subscribers can get the Odd Lots newsletter in their inbox, plus unlimited access to the site and app. bloomberg.com/subscriptions/oddlots See omnystudio.com/listener for privacy information.
About Odd Lots
Odd Lots

Odd Lots

By Bloomberg

<p>Bloomberg's Joe Weisenthal and Tracy Alloway explore the most interesting topics in finance, markets and economics. Join the conversation every Monday and Thursday.</p>