How To Fix Crypto's Token Dilemma
How To Fix Crypto's Token Dilemma
134 days agoLightspeedBlockworks
Podcast1 hr 3 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

On Solana, consider that traditional automated market makers like Radium (RAY) and Orca (ORCA) face significant headwinds and may fade into irrelevance. Instead, focus on vertically integrated platforms like MetaDAO, which combines a token launchpad with its own exchange and is positioned as a more durable investment. On Ethereum, Uniswap (UNI) is adapting to this trend by building its own platform ecosystem, making it a strong hold. Keep an eye on the emerging on-chain equities theme, which is being validated by major players like Robinhood (HOOD) tokenizing stocks on Arbitrum. For a more speculative play, watch for the upcoming launch of Phoenix Perpetuals on Solana to compete in this growing market.

Detailed Analysis

Solana (SOL) DEX Ecosystem

  • The podcast presents a thesis that the decentralized exchange (DEX) market on Solana will split into two main categories based on the maturity of the traded assets.
    • Proactive Market Makers (Prop AMMs) like Humidify are expected to dominate trading for mature, high-volume assets (the "short tail") like SOL-USD. Their competitive advantage is superior execution (i.e., better prices).
    • Traditional Automated Market Makers (AMMs) will need to focus on newly launched, less liquid assets (the "long tail") to stay relevant.
  • The speakers argue that for traditional AMMs to survive, they must pursue vertical integration by controlling the token issuance layer. This means they need to become the primary platform where new tokens are launched.
    • MetaDAO is highlighted as a prime example of this winning strategy, functioning as a token issuance platform with its own integrated Futaki AMM to monetize those launches.
    • Conversely, traditional AMMs like Radium (RAY) and Orca (ORCA) are mentioned as potentially "fading into irrelevance" because they do not control a primary source of new token launches and are losing volume. Radium reportedly lost its largest source of volume after POMP (a launchpad) redirected its graduated coins to its own AMM.

Takeaways

  • Investors should watch for the trend of vertical integration in the DEX space. AMMs that are also successful launchpads (like MetaDAO) may have a more durable business model than standalone AMMs.
  • Protocols like Radium (RAY) and Orca (ORCA) may face significant headwinds unless they can innovate and capture a consistent stream of new token listings.
  • The rise of Prop AMMs is a key evolution in Solana's market structure. While it may be difficult for retail to invest in them directly, their dominance in high-volume pairs signals a maturing market that is increasingly focused on execution quality, similar to traditional finance.

Humidify (Prop AMM)

  • Humidify is a Proactive Market Maker (Prop AMM) on Solana, developed by the Temporal team. It is presented as a leader in providing the best execution for high-volume pairs like SOL-USD.
  • Data from a Chorus One report indicates Humidify consistently quotes the lowest spreads (the difference between the buy and sell price) across various trade sizes, from $1,000 to $1,000,000.
  • A key part of its strategy is its high-frequency oracle updates. For its SOL-USD pairs, it updates its price quotes approximately three times per second.
    • This high update rate is expensive. The platform has paid over $1 million in transaction fees and Jito (JTO) tips for its four main USDC pools.
    • This strategy helps them avoid being taken advantage of by "toxic" arbitrage traders.
  • The speakers note that while it's clear Humidify is capturing significant volume due to its low spreads, it's still difficult to determine exactly how profitable the platform is. However, early analysis suggests it is making money.

Takeaways

  • Humidify represents the next generation of AMM technology on Solana, focusing on capital efficiency and price competitiveness rather than just attracting passive liquidity.
  • The high operational costs (over $1 million in fees) suggest that this is a sophisticated, high-stakes business model that is difficult to replicate.
  • While there is no direct way to invest in Humidify mentioned, its success is a bullish indicator for the maturity of the underlying Solana (SOL) infrastructure that enables such advanced applications.

MetaDAO & The STAMP Model

  • MetaDAO is frequently cited as a successful example of a vertically integrated platform that combines token issuance (like an ICO platform) with its own AMM (Futaki AMM) to monetize those launches.
  • The platform is pioneering a new fundraising model called STAMP (Simple Token Agreement, Market Protected), created in partnership with Colosseum.
  • The STAMP model is designed to fix the "dual token equity structure" problem in crypto, where projects have both private equity investors and public token holders, often leading to misaligned incentives.
    • With STAMP, teams can raise private capital first. When they are ready for a public launch (ICO), they use MetaDAO.
    • At the time of the ICO, all project IP and legal structures are transferred to an entity governed by the token, effectively making the private equity worthless and ensuring all value accrues to the token.
  • This model provides guarantees for token holders, such as limiting investor allocations to 20% of the total supply and team allocations to 40%, with team tokens vesting based on performance milestones.

Takeaways

  • MetaDAO is presented as a potential solution to some of crypto's most significant incentive and governance problems. Its model aims to make tokens function more like traditional equity, with clearer rights and value accrual for holders.
  • The STAMP model could become a new standard for crypto fundraising, offering better protection for public investors compared to the traditional "SAFE + token warrant" model.
  • Projects launching through MetaDAO may be perceived as having stronger token holder alignment and governance, which could be a bullish factor for those specific tokens.

On-Chain Equities

  • The podcast discusses two forms of on-chain equities: tokenized spot stocks and equity perpetuals (perps).
  • Tokenized Spot Stocks:
    • Platforms like X-Stocks (recently acquired by Kraken) offer tokenized versions of stocks like Tesla (TSLA), Nvidia (NVDA), Coinbase (COIN), and Robinhood (HOOD) on Solana.
    • Daily trading volume on Solana for these assets is around $40 million, up from $20 million earlier in the year. Tesla is the most traded asset.
    • The speakers speculate that most of this volume is driven by arbitrage bots rather than organic retail demand.
  • Equity Perpetuals:
    • This has been a hotter narrative recently. Hyperliquid is the current market leader, with its top pair doing over $100 million in daily volume.
    • There is excitement for new competitors on Solana, such as the upcoming Phoenix Perpetuals.
  • Growth Catalyst: The key to unlocking real growth is the development of consumer-facing applications (like neobanks) that use these on-chain equities as their foundation. This would abstract away the complexity and bring in users who don't currently use crypto wallets.
  • Robinhood (HOOD) is actively tokenizing up to 2,000 stocks on Arbitrum, signaling that major traditional finance players see a future in on-chain assets.

Takeaways

  • The on-chain equities market is still very nascent and primarily used by sophisticated arbitrage traders. Organic retail adoption is low.
  • The "killer app" for on-chain equities will likely be a user-friendly neobank or brokerage app that leverages the technology on the back end, making it seamless for users in underserved jurisdictions to access global stock markets.
  • Keep an eye on competition in the equity perps space. The launch of Phoenix Perpetuals on Solana could challenge Hyperliquid's dominance by leveraging Solana's composability (the ability to combine spot and perp trading in a single transaction).
  • Robinhood's (HOOD) move to tokenize stocks is a major validation of the thesis. This suggests a convergence where traditional brokers move on-chain and crypto platforms build more traditional financial products.

Uniswap (UNI)

  • Uniswap is discussed as the dominant DEX on Ethereum, but its competitive environment is different from Solana's.
  • The Ethereum ecosystem has not seen the rise of Prop AMMs yet, largely due to technical limitations like block times and transaction costs, which make high-frequency oracle updates prohibitively expensive.
  • However, Uniswap appears to be aware of the "vertical integration" trend seen on Solana.
    • It is building a platform-style ecosystem with UniV4.
    • It has its own token launch mechanism, CCA, which was recently used for a $60 million raise for Aztec, showing it understands the value of controlling token issuance.

Takeaways

  • Uniswap (UNI) is not standing still. It is evolving into a platform and embracing the token issuance model, which could be a durable moat against competitors on Ethereum.
  • The thesis that traditional AMMs are at risk is currently more specific to the highly competitive and advanced market structure of Solana.
  • If Ethereum's technical capabilities improve (e.g., faster blocks), it could see a similar evolution with Prop AMMs emerging, which would create a new competitive threat for Uniswap.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Gm! We're back with Dan & Carlos for our final roundup of the year. We deep dive into the current DEX landscape, crypto's token vs equity dilemma, prop AMMs, onchain equities & more. Enjoy! -- Follow Dan: https://x.com/smyyguy Follow Danny: https://x.com/defi_kay_ Follow Lightspeed: ⁠https://twitter.com/Lightspeedpodhq⁠ Join the Lightspeed Telegram: ⁠https://t.me/+QUl_ZOj2nMJlZTEx⁠ -- peaq, the Machine Economy Computer, proudly sponsors the Lightspeed podcast. peaq is home to 60+ apps across 20+ industries and millions of devices, machines, and onchain robots. It powers the world’s first tokenized robo-farm, launching soon in Hong Kong, and has launched the Machine Economy Free Zone in Dubai as a Web3 x Robotics x AI innovation hub. For more about peaq, check out www.peaq.xyz -- Sablier is the leading onchain token distribution protocol — now on Solana. Trusted by top crypto teams, Sablier automates airdrops and vesting onchain, securely and transparently. Start in seconds at sablier.com. -- Get top market insights and the latest in crypto news. Subscribe to Blockworks Daily Newsletter: ⁠https://blockworks.co/newsletter/⁠ -- (00:00) Introduction (01:02) The State of Prop AMMs (11:55) Peaq Ad (12:21) Sablier Ad (12:50) How To Build A Moat In Crypto? (22:56) Crypto’s Token Dilemma (44:36) Peaq Ad (45:03) Sablier Ad (45:31) Onchain Equities -- Disclaimers: Lightspeed was kickstarted by a grant from the Solana Foundation. Nothing said on Lightspeed is a recommendation to buy or sell securities or tokens. This podcast is for informational purposes only, and any views expressed by anyone on the show are solely our opinions, not financial advice. Danny, and our guests may hold positions in the companies, funds, or projects discussed.
About Lightspeed
Lightspeed

Lightspeed

By Blockworks

Lightspeed is a podcast for those interested in how crypto can solve real problems and create products users love. It's a callback to the garage days of Silicon Valley, where builders pushed the limits of hardware and software to build world-changing products. We interview the projects and founders that will make this same impact today.