Trading the Taylor Swift Engagement
Trading the Taylor Swift Engagement
255 days agoDumb Money LiveDumb Money
Podcast1 hr 23 min
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Robinhood (HOOD) is a top pick due to the significant user growth potential of its new Prediction Markets feature. Sphere Entertainment (SPHR) is a bullish trade based on strong current business momentum and the massive potential catalyst of a rumored Taylor Swift residency. A medium-conviction trade is to be long Lululemon (LULU) into its next earnings report, driven by viral social media interest in its new "scuba waffle knit" product line. For a speculative catalyst trade, consider buying Starbucks (SBUX) the week before a potential collaboration announcement and selling quickly after the news. A high-risk, short-term idea is to buy weekly call options on Carter's (CRI) immediately following a potential Taylor Swift pregnancy announcement and sell within the hour.

Detailed Analysis

Signet Jewelers (SIG)

  • Mentioned as the "obvious" trade following the news of Taylor Swift's engagement, with media outlets widely reporting on it. The stock was up 3% on the news.
  • The hosts are skeptical of this being a good immediate trade, noting the stock was already up 20% in the month leading up to the announcement.
  • They question whether a celebrity engagement can meaningfully increase the number of engagements among the general public.
  • One host believes it would be an "excellent trade" only if you believe the news will cause a 5% to 10% pop in engagements over the next 90 days.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Neutral to Bearish on the immediate trade.
  • Actionable Insight: The hosts are not buying SIG right now based on the news. However, they plan to monitor the company's data weekly for the next 12 weeks to see if a "Taylor Swift effect" on engagements materializes. If the data shows a clear increase in sales, it could become an interesting trade.

Cracker Barrel (CBRL)

  • The stock rose after the company announced it was reversing a recent logo change and going back to its old logo.
  • One of the hosts performed a "fast trade" on this news. He saw a tweet about the reversal, noticed the stock hadn't moved yet, and immediately bought 10,000 shares after hours. The stock then popped 5%.
  • He sold the entire position the next day for a quick profit.
  • The hosts have a very negative long-term view of the company, describing the food as "horrible" and "frozen," citing an activist investor report that detailed the decline in food quality.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Very Bearish on the long-term fundamentals.
  • Actionable Insight: This was presented as a successful example of a short-term news-based trade, not a long-term investment. The host explicitly stated, "I never want to be invested in that company." The trade was based on correctly predicting a positive stock reaction to a specific news event and exiting quickly.

Sphere Entertainment (SPHR)

  • A host has taken a position in SPHR.
  • The bullish thesis is supported by recent data showing that traffic to the Sphere's Ticketmaster and checkout pages has been "pretty darn good" over the last 30 days.
  • The current Backstreet Boys residency is seen as a major success and a tailwind for the company.
  • The biggest potential catalyst is the rumor that Taylor Swift may do a residency at the Sphere. The hosts believe this news could cause the stock to jump 20%, 30%, or even 40%.
    • They acknowledge the CEO has denied this rumor but speculate it could be a tactic to protect a surprise announcement.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Bullish.
  • Actionable Insight: The host is in the trade based on strong current business momentum (data and Backstreet Boys) with the potential Taylor Swift residency acting as a massive, albeit speculative, bonus. The plan is to hold the position for at least the next few weeks, potentially through the next earnings report.

Lululemon (LULU)

  • A host is currently long LULU stock, describing it as a "medium conviction trade" (rated 6.75 out of 10).
  • A key bullish factor is the new fall collection, specifically the "scuba waffle knit" product line. Social media analysis on TikTok shows posts about this product are getting 10x the average view traffic, indicating it could be a huge seller.
  • The host is trading LULU long into its next earnings report, believing that even a "marginally better" quarter could be positive for the stock.
  • Risk Factor: The host noted that his initial high conviction was based on Google Trends data that later appeared to be anomalous and unreliable. He has since reduced the size of his position.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Bullish (medium conviction).
  • Actionable Insight: The trade is based on the belief that the company will have a better-than-expected quarter, driven by strong consumer interest in new fall products. The "scuba waffle knit" line is a specific product to watch as an indicator of brand momentum.

Robinhood (HOOD)

  • Described by one host as his "favorite stock currently."
  • The primary bullish thesis revolves around Robinhood's new Prediction Markets feature.
  • The hosts believe that if Robinhood were to add prediction markets for Taylor Swift life events (e.g., wedding date, pregnancy announcement), it would attract a huge number of new users to the platform.
  • A host who has used the new sports prediction feature described it as "beautiful," "fantastic," and incredibly easy to use, which he believes will drive significant user engagement.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Very Bullish.
  • Actionable Insight: The investment thesis is centered on the growth potential of the Prediction Markets feature to attract new demographics and increase engagement from existing users. The ease of use and integration into the main app are seen as key advantages.

Carter's (CRI)

  • The hosts believe the real Taylor Swift trade is not the engagement, but a potential pregnancy. The thesis is that if Taylor Swift announces a pregnancy, it will inspire a "baby boom" among her millions of fans.
  • Carter's (CRI) is the specific stock identified to play this theme.
  • The host notes that the stock's one-year chart looks terrible, showing a steady decline.
  • Because of the poor fundamentals, this is not a long-term investment.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Bearish on fundamentals, but Bullish on a specific, catalyst-driven trade.
  • Actionable Insight: The plan is to create a "Taylor Swift pregnancy portfolio" and be ready to trade it. Specifically, the host plans to buy weekly call options on CRI in the days leading up to a potential pregnancy announcement and sell within 60 minutes of the news breaking to capture the speculative pop. This is a high-risk, short-term "fast trade" strategy.

Starbucks (SBUX)

  • The hosts discussed a potential collaboration between Starbucks and Taylor Swift, timed around her upcoming album release.
  • They note that the two have collaborated successfully before in 2021.
  • The hosts are very bearish on the company's fundamentals, stating "Starbucks needs something."

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Bearish long-term, but Bullish on a short-term trade.
  • Actionable Insight: A host is considering a short-term trade on SBUX. The plan would be to buy the stock the week before a potential collaboration announcement to get ahead of the news, and then "sell and not look back" shortly after. This is purely a speculative trade on a catalyst, not an investment in the company's future.

NVIDIA (NVDA)

  • The hosts discussed the stock ahead of its earnings announcement.
  • A host who holds a large position is now more cautious due to recent uncertainty regarding its business in China. Comments from a CEO about getting China "addicted" to their chips have created political pressure and "cloudiness" over the outlook.
  • Because of this uncertainty, the host is not as levered (i.e., holding fewer call options) going into earnings as he had been in previous quarters.
  • He believes it is very difficult to know what investor expectations are for NVIDIA, making it hard to have high conviction on the earnings trade.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Cautious / Neutral in the short-term.
  • Actionable Insight: While NVDA remains a core long-term holding, the risk from potential disruption in China has reduced short-term conviction. The takeaway is that the risk/reward for a leveraged bet on earnings is less clear than it has been in the past.

Google (GOOGL)

  • The hosts raised a major concern that Google Trends data has become "unusable" and unreliable.
  • The thesis is that AI models (like ChatGPT) are scraping Google Search, which is artificially inflating search query data and making trends appear stronger than they are. This was discovered when analyzing abnormally high search traffic for Lululemon products.
  • This raises a significant risk for Google's core advertising business (AdWords), as advertisers could potentially be paying for clicks from AI bots, not human customers.
  • A host had a short position on GOOGL based on this thesis but closed it after news of a partnership between Google and Apple was announced, as that became the more dominant narrative for the stock.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Cautious / Concerned.
  • Actionable Insight: Investors who use Google Trends for research should be extremely careful, as the data may be unreliable. The underlying issue of AI-driven traffic and its impact on ad revenue is a major potential risk to watch for. If a story breaks confirming advertisers are being charged for bot clicks, it could be a catalyst for a fast trade to the downside.

Apple (AAPL)

  • The hosts are not excited about the upcoming "iPhone Air," believing its trade-offs (smaller battery, worse camera) for thinness will not appeal to most users.
  • They are much more interested in Apple's future product pipeline.
  • A foldable "Flip iPhone" expected next year is seen as a potential "huge upgrade cycle" because it offers a genuinely new and different form factor.
  • A 20th-anniversary iPhone with a wraparound screen is also expected in a few years.

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Neutral/Bearish on the immediate product announcement, but Bullish on the medium-term (1-2 year) pipeline.
  • Actionable Insight: The upcoming iPhone event may not be a significant positive catalyst. The real investment opportunity may come next year with the launch of the foldable iPhone, which could drive a major wave of upgrades.

Palantir (PLTR)

  • A host who made a large, successful trade on PLTR over the last year has now sold about 85% of his position.
  • The reason for selling is that the "information advantage" they had a year ago is now gone. The bullish thesis they traded on is now widely understood by the market and priced into the stock, which is up 6x from their entry point.
  • He clarifies that this doesn't mean the stock can't go higher, but that their specific "social arb" trade is "over."

Takeaways

  • Sentiment: Neutral.
  • Actionable Insight: This is an example of a disciplined trading strategy. The position was exited not because the company is no longer good, but because the specific thesis for the trade has fully played out and the information edge has disappeared. The host may re-enter in the future if he feels the market is underappreciating the company again.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Today on Dumb Money, the Taylor Swift engagement stock trades that everyone will be talking about.
About Dumb Money Live
Dumb Money Live

Dumb Money Live

By Dumb Money

Dave Hanson, Chris Camillo and Jordan Mclain are Dumb Money. These longtime friends sold their tech startup, quit their day jobs, and decided to become full-time investors.