Is My Spending Reasonable? This Data Set Will Tell You
Is My Spending Reasonable? This Data Set Will Tell You
Podcast36 min 15 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

To accelerate your path to financial independence, prioritize geographic arbitrage by moving from high-cost cities like Santa Cruz to lower-cost hubs with diverse economies, which can reduce your required retirement portfolio by thousands per month. Focus on the "Big Two" expenses—housing and transportation—by utilizing house hacking or public transit to maintain high-city salaries while achieving low-cost spending levels. Use tools like Monarch Money or AI models to audit your spending against regional benchmarks and identify "unreasonable" costs that can be redirected into investments. Optimize your insurance costs by implementing a laddered term life insurance strategy through platforms like Ethos, matching coverage amounts to your declining debt levels over 10, 20, and 30-year terms. Finally, increase your savings rate from 5% to 10% to potentially shave 15 years off your working career, ensuring you account for future "lifestyle creep" in your long-term retirement projections.

Detailed Analysis

Budget Benchmarking & Geographic Arbitrage

The discussion centers on using data to determine if spending is "reasonable" based on location, household type, and income quintile. The primary tool discussed is the BiggerPockets Money Budget Tool, which utilizes Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) data, HUD fair market rents, and regional pricing adjustments to estimate median spending.

  • High Cost of Living (HCOL) vs. Low Cost of Living (LCOL):
    • Santa Cruz, CA: Identified as the most expensive market. A median household (couple with kids, no daycare) spends approximately $12,600/month.
    • Beckley, WV: Identified as the least expensive market. A similar household spends approximately $6,500/month.
  • The "Big Two" Expenses: Housing and transportation are the primary drivers of cost differences between regions. Other categories like food, healthcare, and apparel show less drastic variance.
  • Affordability vs. Raw Cost: A location with high costs may be more "affordable" if the median income is disproportionately higher, allowing for a higher absolute savings rate.

Takeaways

  • Target the "Big Two": To accelerate Financial Independence (FI), focus on reducing housing and transportation costs. In HCOL areas, strategies like house hacking or using public transit can bring HCOL spending down to LCOL levels while maintaining HCOL salary advantages.
  • Geographic Arbitrage: Moving from an HCOL area (e.g., Charlotte, NC) to an LCOL area (e.g., Manhattan, KS) can lower the "FI Number" (the total portfolio needed to retire) by thousands of dollars per month.
  • Income Compounding: HCOL areas often provide "elite job opportunities" that allow for faster wealth accumulation in the final years of a career, even if expenses are higher.

Real Estate & Housing

Housing is identified as the "lion's share" of any budget and the most significant variable in achieving financial independence.

  • Rent vs. Buy: The budget tool uses HUD Fair Market Rents as a benchmark because mortgage costs vary wildly based on when the home was purchased and the interest rate secured.
  • Paid-off Housing: For those pursuing FI, a paid-off home drastically changes the math. In Santa Cruz, a paid-off home could drop monthly housing expenses from $5,300 (rent) to roughly $1,500 (taxes, insurance, utilities).
  • Economic Diversity: When looking at LCOL areas for investment or retirement, investors should look for diverse economies. Beckley, WV, was cited as a riskier example because it was historically dependent on a single industry (coal), whereas stable markets usually have a mix of healthcare, education, and government jobs.

Takeaways

  • Evaluate Local Demand: Before moving to a "cheap" area, research the main employers. Avoid "one-company towns" where a single closure could crash property values.
  • Benchmark Your Housing: Compare your current mortgage or rent against the median for your income quintile in your city to see if you are over-consuming housing.

Financial Planning Tools & Tech

The hosts recommend several specific tools to organize finances and extract insights from personal data.

  • Monarch Money: A recommended dashboard for tracking accounts, investments, and property.
    • Sankey Diagrams: Used to visualize the flow of money from income to specific spending categories.
    • AI Recaps: Used to flag spending spikes and net worth shifts.
  • AI Integration (Claude/ChatGPT): The hosts suggest uploading spending data to AI models to identify recurring transactions and "unreasonable" spending compared to regional benchmarks.
  • Ethos: A platform mentioned for Term Life Insurance. The hosts advocate for "laddering" policies (stacking 10, 20, and 30-year terms) to lower costs as financial obligations (like mortgages) decrease over time.

Takeaways

  • Audit Recurring Costs: Use AI or tracking tools to find "hidden" expenses like high utility bills or excessive Amazon shopping.
  • Optimize Life Insurance: Avoid overpaying for a single large 30-year policy; use a ladder strategy to match coverage with your declining debt levels.
  • Savings Rate is King: Increasing your savings rate from 5% to 10% can shave 15 years off your working career.

Investment Themes & Risks

  • The "Lifestyle Creep" Risk: High earners (top 20% quintile) often feel pressure to spend more to match their peer group. When planning for retirement, investors should account for the possibility that their spending may "regress to the mean" of their social circle.
  • Inflation Adjustments: When using government data (BLS/HUD), ensure you adjust for inflation, as many datasets are 1–2 years old.
  • Self-Employment Tax: A noted risk in tax planning is failing to account for the full FICA/Social Security burden for self-employed individuals.

Takeaways

  • Conservative Retirement Estimates: If you currently spend $4,000/month but your peers spend $6,000, consider padding your FI number to allow for future lifestyle increases.
  • Free Resources: Access the discussed tools at BiggerPocketsMoney.com/resources and BiggerPocketsMoney.com/budget.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Are you actually spending too much, or does it just feel that way because of where you live? In this episode of the BiggerPockets Money Podcast, Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench break down a new budget benchmarking tool that compares your spending to households like yours using real government data, regional cost-of-living adjustments, fair market rents, childcare costs, and local pricing. They explain the difference between cost of living and affordability, compare high-cost and low-cost cities, and show how housing, transportation, and income all impact your path to financial independence. You'll learn how to benchmark your own budget, identify areas where you may be overspending, and use data, AI, and your own transaction history to make smarter financial decisions. Whether you live in a high-cost city or a low-cost market, this episode will help you optimize your spending, increase your savings rate, and reach financial independence faster. To go beyond the podcast: Kick start your financial independence journey with our FREE financial resources - https://biggerpocketsmoney.com/ Subscribe on YouTube for even more content- www.youtube.com/biggerpocketsmoney  Connect with us on social media to join the other BiggerPockets Money listeners - https://www.facebook.com/groups/BPMoney We believe financial independence is attainable for anyone no matter when or where you’re starting. Let’s get your financial house in order! Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
About BiggerPockets Money Podcast
BiggerPockets Money Podcast

BiggerPockets Money Podcast

By BiggerPockets

Intermediate to advanced personal finance strategies for people serious about the FIRE (financial independence retire early) movement—not just dreaming about it. Tune in on Tuesdays and Fridays for new BiggerPockets Money episodes with your hosts, Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench! Or visit BiggerPocketsMoney.com with additional resources.