Are You Saving Too Much? Your Coast FI Number Might Be Wrong
Are You Saving Too Much? Your Coast FI Number Might Be Wrong
Podcast38 min 29 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights
  • Consider low-cost, broad-market index funds for long-term investing; historical return assumptions are planning guides, not guarantees, and should reflect your portfolio’s stock-bond mix.
  • Don’t change your investment strategy in response to short-term market declines; review your plan periodically and adjust if your goals or assumptions change.
  • Estimate your Coast FI target using realistic growth, inflation, spending, retirement-age, and withdrawal-rate assumptions; the example’s $357,275 target depends heavily on its assumptions and is not a universal benchmark.
  • Treat the 4% withdrawal rate as a starting point, not a promise—especially if you plan a longer retirement—and consider whether accessible savings outside retirement accounts are needed for early retirement.
Detailed Analysis

S&P 500 and Broad-Market Index Funds

  • The hosts use a 10% nominal growth rate while accumulating and a 7% real growth rate—after inflation—when projecting how investments may grow during the Coast FI period. They describe these as historical assumptions, not guaranteed future returns.
  • Evan says the 7% real-growth assumption is most applicable to a portfolio largely invested in broad-market, low-cost index funds that track the market. A portfolio with a large, long-term bond allocation may call for a lower return assumption.
  • The discussion emphasizes that markets can decline, but historically the S&P 500 has had more up years than down years. The hosts advise against changing an investment strategy in response to short-term market moves if the underlying plan and assumptions remain sound.

Takeaways

  • Use a return assumption that reflects your actual portfolio, and understand that historical averages are planning inputs—not promises.
  • Avoid reacting to short-term market declines based on alarming headlines or social media; review your plan on a regular schedule instead.
  • If your portfolio has substantial bond exposure, consider whether the stock-market-based return assumptions discussed in the episode fit your situation.

Coast FI and Retirement Portfolio Planning

  • Coast FI means having enough invested that, assuming continued growth, you may not need to make further retirement contributions to reach your goal by a chosen retirement age. The hosts stress that reaching Coast FI does not require stopping contributions or ceasing to monitor your plan.
  • The episode uses a 4% safe withdrawal rate as a starting point for a traditional retirement horizon. The hosts caution that a substantially longer early-retirement period may require different analysis; they also discuss flexible withdrawal “guardrails” as an alternative approach.
  • Evan’s example assumes he is 26, has $250,000 invested, contributes about $3,300 per month, and aims for $200,000 a year in retirement spending. With the episode’s assumptions—10% nominal growth, 3% inflation, and a 4% withdrawal rate—the calculator estimates a Coast FI target of about $357,275 today and roughly $468,000 at age 30. The projection estimates about $5 million at age 65, supporting around $200,000 per year in inflation-adjusted withdrawals under those assumptions.
  • The example illustrates how sensitive projections are to assumptions:
    • Reducing nominal growth from 10% to 9% pushes the example’s Coast FI age from 30 to 35 and raises the target at that age to about $870,000.
    • Using a 3.5% withdrawal rate raises the age-30 target to about $572,000; using 3% raises it to about $818,000.
    • Combining an 8% nominal growth assumption with a 3% withdrawal rate makes the example’s current saving pace insufficient to reach the modeled retirement goal by age 65.
  • The hosts also highlight spending assumptions: Evan spends about $40,000 a year currently but models $200,000 in retirement. In the calculator example, reducing projected retirement spending to $100,000 would put him above the modeled Coast FI target already; $150,000 would put him close to it.

Takeaways

  • Build projections from clear, defensible assumptions for investment growth, inflation, retirement spending, retirement age, and withdrawal rate. Avoid stacking several unusually conservative assumptions without a specific reason; the episode shows that small changes can greatly increase a modeled target.
  • Include a reasonable spending buffer, but revisit whether your retirement budget reflects your likely lifestyle and future expenses rather than an arbitrary multiple of current spending.
  • Recheck projections periodically rather than assuming the forecast will unfold exactly as modeled. If returns or spending differ from expectations, the hosts note that you can adjust contributions or other parts of the plan.
  • Consider the episode’s warning about putting all savings into tax-advantaged retirement accounts: if you want the option to retire before you can access those funds, account accessibility may matter.
  • Treat the 4% withdrawal rate and historical return assumptions as planning references, not guarantees. The hosts specifically note that a longer-than-traditional retirement can change the withdrawal-rate analysis.

Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Are you making your Coast FI number higher than it needs to be? Mindy Jensen and Coast FI co-host Evan Lawler break down how investment returns, inflation, retirement spending, and withdrawal rates affect your Coast FI target. Using Evan's own numbers, they show how changing one assumption can push your projected Coast FI age back by five years and why being overly conservative with your retirement calculator could mean working and saving longer than necessary. They also explain how to choose realistic assumptions, whether you should keep investing after reaching Coast FI, and why it's important to revisit your financial independence plan as life and markets change. The goal isn't to ignore risk, but to build a reasonable plan that gets you to financial freedom without unnecessarily moving the finish line. To go beyond the podcast: Interested in working with a Flat Fee Financial Planner? Go to https://biggerpocketsmoney.com/fipro/ Interested in Learning More About Buying a Franchise? Check out: biggerpocketsmoney.com/franzy Get 50% Off Your First Year of Monarch by using code ‘Pockets’: https://www.monarch.com/pockets Want to better protect your personal identity? Go to: https://incogni.com/bpmoney, code BPMONEY Connect with Evan Lawler: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/the_financialfoundation/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@The_FinancialFoundation  We believe financial independence is attainable for anyone no matter when or where you’re starting. Let’s get your financial house in order! See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
About BiggerPockets Money Podcast
BiggerPockets Money Podcast

BiggerPockets Money Podcast

By BiggerPockets

Intermediate to advanced personal finance strategies for people serious about the FIRE (financial independence retire early) movement—not just dreaming about it. Tune in on Tuesdays and Fridays for new BiggerPockets Money episodes with your hosts, Mindy Jensen and Scott Trench! Or visit BiggerPocketsMoney.com with additional resources.