Price-to-NAV Compression: Way Cheaper? MSTR, MTPLF, TSCWF, MARA, KULR, RIOT, BMNR, SBET GAME, DFDV
Price-to-NAV Compression: Way Cheaper? MSTR, MTPLF, TSCWF, MARA, KULR, RIOT, BMNR, SBET GAME, DFDV
YouTube16 min 28 sec
Watch on YouTube
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

For investors interested in companies holding cryptocurrency, Riot Platforms (RIOT) is presented as a favorite Bitcoin miner well-positioned to grow its holdings. As a more established play, MicroStrategy (MSTR) is trading at a historically low valuation premium, suggesting a potential entry point for a bounce. KULR Technology Group (KULR) offers a unique recovery opportunity, with its recent stock decline seen as a technical overreaction and a full recovery anticipated above $8 per share. For aggressive investors bullish on Ethereum, GameSquare Holdings (GAME) has the highest growth potential but also carries significant small-cap risk. Lastly, those who believe the Solana ecosystem will outperform should consider DeFi Development Corp (DFDV) as the primary way to gain exposure to that theme.

Detailed Analysis

Investment Theme: Price-to-NAV (MNAV) Strategy

The podcast focuses on companies that hold large amounts of cryptocurrency on their balance sheets, primarily Bitcoin, but also Ethereum and Solana. The key metric discussed is the Price-to-NAV (MNAV), which the speaker defines as the premium the market assigns to the company's stock price relative to the value of the crypto it holds.

  • How it works: A company with an MNAV of 2.0 is "selling a dollar for two dollars." This means its market capitalization is twice the value of its crypto assets.
  • Why it matters: A high MNAV allows these companies to issue new shares (a process called an "At-The-Market" or ATM offering) and use the cash to buy more cryptocurrency. This is "accretive," meaning it increases the amount of crypto owned per share, benefiting existing shareholders.
  • Current State: The speaker notes that MNAVs have seen "quite a bit of compression" recently, meaning the premiums have decreased. This reduces how effectively companies can execute this strategy but also suggests that a bounce in these stocks may be coming.

MicroStrategy (MSTR)

  • This company is presented as the "blue chip" of the Bitcoin treasury companies.
  • Its current MNAV is 1.62, meaning the market values it at $1.62 for every $1.00 of Bitcoin it holds.
  • This MNAV is on the "lower end of the historic range," and the speaker believes a bounce is likely. A drop to 1.59 would be a negative sign, as it would make its share issuance strategy less effective.
  • Like other companies, MSTR also uses debt (borrowing money) to buy Bitcoin, not just its share issuance strategy.

Takeaways

  • MSTR is considered the safest, most established play in this sector.
  • The current MNAV of 1.62 is seen as a relatively low valuation compared to its historical levels, suggesting a potential entry point for investors who believe in the strategy.
  • Investors should monitor the MNAV; a sustained level below 1.60 could be a cause for concern regarding its ability to grow its Bitcoin holdings accretively.

MetaPlanet (MTPLF)

  • This is another Bitcoin treasury company.
  • Its MNAV has fallen to below 3.0, which the speaker notes is "as low as I've seen it on that one."
  • Despite the drop, its share issuance strategy is still considered "very accretive," just less so than in the past.
  • The stock recently saw a "nice rebound."

Takeaways

  • The historically low MNAV for MTPLF suggests it may be undervalued relative to its recent past and could be due for a bounce, similar to MSTR.
  • It offers a higher MNAV than MSTR, meaning its potential to grow its Bitcoin per share is theoretically higher, but it is not considered a "blue chip" like MSTR.

Marathon Digital (MARA)

  • A Bitcoin mining company that also holds significant Bitcoin.
  • Its MNAV recently traded as low as 0.99, meaning its market cap was roughly equal to its Bitcoin holdings.
  • Because its MNAV is not above 1.0, it cannot effectively use its shares to buy more Bitcoin.
  • Instead, MARA is borrowing money via an $850 million convertible bond (with an option for an additional $150 million) to purchase more Bitcoin. This is a form of future dilution that allows them to acquire assets today.

Takeaways

  • MARA is currently unable to use the primary MNAV strategy of issuing shares to buy Bitcoin.
  • Its strategy has shifted to using debt to fund acquisitions, which carries different risks and rewards than issuing equity.
  • This makes it a different type of investment compared to high-MNAV companies like MSTR or MTPLF.

The Smarter Web (TSCWF)

  • A Bitcoin treasury company whose stock is traded in British pounds.
  • Its MNAV is currently 3.66, which is described as "historically very low" for this particular stock, which previously traded in the 5.0-10.0 range.
  • The effectiveness of its share issuance is now comparable to that of MetaPlanet.
  • The stock also experienced a recent rebound.

Takeaways

  • Like other companies in the space, its valuation (MNAV) is compressed, suggesting a potential for a rebound if market sentiment improves.
  • Despite the drop, an MNAV of 3.66 is still highly effective for accretive share issuance.

KULR Technology Group (KULR)

  • This is a "hybrid" company with an existing, "meaningful business" in space batteries that has also adopted a Bitcoin acquisition strategy.
  • Its MNAV dropped from a previous level of around 4.0.
  • The speaker states the drop was not related to its Bitcoin strategy but was a market overreaction to an 8-for-1 reverse stock split.
  • The split was done to raise the share price above $5 to qualify for inclusion in the Russell 3000 index, which was successful.
  • The speaker believes that once the stock price crosses $8, it will have fully recovered from the sell-off.

Takeaways

  • KULR offers exposure to the Bitcoin treasury strategy while also being supported by an underlying operational business, which may reduce risk compared to pure-play crypto holding companies.
  • The analysis suggests the recent price drop was due to a technical market event (the stock split) rather than a fundamental problem, presenting a potential recovery play.

Riot Platforms (RIOT)

  • The speaker's "favorite" among Bitcoin miners that are also pursuing High-Performance Computing (HPC) business lines.
  • Unlike some miners who sell all their Bitcoin, RIOT is a major "odler" (long-term holder) of Bitcoin.
  • Its MNAV is 2.24.

Takeaways

  • With an MNAV of 2.24, the speaker believes RIOT is well-positioned to issue more shares or use convertible debt to acquire more Bitcoin accretively.
  • This is presented as a top pick for investors wanting exposure to a Bitcoin miner that actively grows its Bitcoin treasury.

Ethereum & Solana Treasury Companies (General)

  • These companies apply the same MNAV/treasury strategy as the Bitcoin companies but use Ethereum (ETH) or Solana (SOL) instead.
  • This is considered a "way riskier" investment because it's a bet on a specific blockchain winning the "war" for Web3 dominance, which is still undecided. An investment in these companies is a prerequisite bet on the success of their chosen blockchain.
  • The speaker notes that many are waiting for ETH to reach a price target of $10,000.

SharpLink Gaming (SBET)

  • An Ethereum treasury company.
  • Its MNAV is calculated to be 2.32.
  • The company is described as "very aggressive" in its ETH acquisition and has a massive $6 billion ATM agreement to issue shares.

Takeaways

  • SBET is positioned to be one of the "faster horses" in the Ethereum treasury space due to its aggressive strategy and large ATM facility.
  • This is a direct and aggressive bet on the price of Ethereum.

BitMine Immersion Technologies (BMNR)

  • An Ethereum treasury company that has received investments from Peter Thiel and Cathie Wood.
  • Its MNAV is 1.87.
  • It has a $2 billion ATM offering, which is smaller than SBET's.

Takeaways

  • The speaker ranks BMNR as the "#2" option in the Ethereum treasury space.
  • The backing from prominent investors like Thiel and Wood may provide a degree of validation for some investors.
  • Its MNAV of 1.87 is still accretive but less powerful than SBET's.

GameSquare Holdings (GAME)

  • An Ethereum treasury company that also has an underlying gaming business with $100 million in annual revenue.
  • It has the highest MNAV of the ETH companies at 3.38, making its share issuance the "most accretive."
  • It is a very small-cap stock, making it highly volatile and risky ("no options, no margin").
  • It has a $250 million ATM, which is very large relative to its market cap and could allow it to nearly triple its size.

Takeaways

  • GAME offers the highest potential for accretive growth (highest MNAV) among the ETH companies discussed.
  • It could be the "fastest horse" but comes with significant small-cap risk and volatility.
  • The underlying gaming business provides a potential valuation floor, as the stock trades at only 1.25x sales.

DeFi Development Corp (DFDV)

  • This is a Solana treasury company, making it a bet on SOL winning against ETH.
  • Its MNAV is 2.23, which is down from a previous level above 3.0.
  • Instead of an ATM, it uses a $5 billion equity line of credit (ELOC) to issue shares and buy more SOL.
  • This strategy has been effective, increasing the amount of SOL per share by 79% over the past three months.

Takeaways

  • DFDV is the primary option for investors who believe Solana will outperform Ethereum and want to invest via the treasury/MNAV model.
  • The company has demonstrated a strong ability to grow its SOL per share, which is the main goal of this investment strategy.
  • An investment here is a direct bet on the Solana ecosystem.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Video Description
Join Patreon for Exclusive Perks: https://www.patreon.com/btdenominator Common ATM Math Walkthrough (how Price-to-NAV generates yield for any treasury company): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UD67EQYV5hA Beat The Denominator is a channel whose goal is to Beat the dollar's inflation (i.e., beat the denominator). Therefore, I don't cover just inexpensive stocks: I also cover Ethereum Treasury companies such as SBET stock (Sharplink gaming) and GAME stock (Gamesquare stock) and Bitmine (BMNR stock, Tom Lee's stock). I also cover MicroStrategy, Strategy, MSTR stock, Metaplanet stock, The Smarter web company, KULR, MARA stock, and RIOT stock. No Financial Advice!! As always, this video is NOT investment advice, and none of the contents should be construed as such. I do not make short-term or long-term price predictions for any stock investment, and all words spoken in this video are for entertainment purposes ONLY.
About Beat The Denominator
Beat The Denominator

Beat The Denominator

By @BeatTheDenominator