MSTR Stock: Stack Sats OR Stack MSTR? 5 Reasons Why I Prefer to Stack MSTR, Defying Saylor's Advice!
MSTR Stock: Stack Sats OR Stack MSTR? 5 Reasons Why I Prefer to Stack MSTR, Defying Saylor's Advice!
YouTube24 min 35 sec
Watch on YouTube
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Consider buying MicroStrategy (MSTR) stock as a primary way to gain leveraged exposure to Bitcoin within traditional brokerage accounts. The core thesis is that MSTR uses its stock's premium valuation, currently viewed as a "bargain" at 1.66x its Bitcoin holdings, to continuously acquire more Bitcoin for shareholders. For advanced investors, selling cash-secured puts on MSTR is a recommended strategy to generate income or acquire shares at a lower cost basis. Avoid strategies that cap the significant upside, such as selling covered calls or owning the YieldMax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY). Finally, it is suggested to complement this investment by holding some physical Bitcoin (BTC) in a self-custody wallet as a long-term insurance policy.

Detailed Analysis

MicroStrategy (MSTR)

  • The host strongly prefers "stacking" MSTR stock over stacking more physical Bitcoin at this point in his investment journey.
  • The core investment thesis is the "black hole" theory: MSTR raises capital from the market and uses it to buy Bitcoin in a one-way transaction, continuously increasing its Bitcoin holdings without ever selling.
  • The host outlines five key reasons for his preference for MSTR:
    1. Economic Exposure on Traditional Rails: Owning MSTR provides the economic upside and network effects of Bitcoin's price appreciation through a regular stock, accessible in standard brokerage accounts. This is ideal for investors primarily seeking financial gains rather than the "freedom" benefits of self-custody.
    2. Premium to Net Asset Value (NAV): MSTR doesn't require Bitcoin's price to rise to be profitable. By trading at a premium to the value of its Bitcoin holdings (mentioned as 1.66x NAV), it can issue new shares for $1.66 to buy $1.00 worth of Bitcoin, effectively increasing the Bitcoin per share for existing shareholders.
    3. Collateral for Loans: As a liquid NASDAQ-listed stock, MSTR shares can be used as collateral to borrow against (margin loans). The host notes that brokers are offering better terms and anticipates the preferred shares (MSTRK) could eventually have a 25% maintenance ratio. This enables the "buy, borrow, die" strategy, allowing investors to access liquidity without selling their shares.
    4. Valuation is a "Bargain": The host considers the current Price to NAV of 1.66 to be a "bargain."
      • He compares it to other Bitcoin treasury companies like Metaplanet (3x NAV) and SmarterWeb (5x-6x NAV), which trade at much higher multiples.
      • He also points to miner MARA, which he says struggles to trade below a 1.0x NAV, suggesting a floor for these types of stocks.
      • His "worst-case scenario" is the premium compressing to 1.0x NAV, which would represent a 39% drop in the stock price (if Bitcoin's price stays flat), a risk he considers a "walk in the park" for long-term holders.
    5. Options Market: MSTR has a liquid and volatile options market, which can be used to generate income.
      • He specifically suggests selling cash-secured puts at a price you would be happy to acquire the stock. If the stock drops, you buy it at your desired lower price; if it doesn't, you keep the premium.
      • He strongly warns against selling covered calls, as MSTR's volatility could lead to massive single-day gains (he cites a 25% gain in one day), causing you to lose your shares for a small premium.

Takeaways

  • MSTR can be viewed as a leveraged play on Bitcoin that operates within the traditional financial system, offering benefits like marginability and options trading.
  • Investors bullish on Bitcoin's long-term economic potential, but who are comfortable forgoing the self-custody benefits, might find MSTR an attractive vehicle.
  • The stock's premium to its Bitcoin holdings (Price to NAV) is a key metric to watch. A sustained, high premium allows the company to accretively grow its Bitcoin per share.
  • For advanced investors, selling puts on MSTR could be a viable strategy to either generate income or acquire shares at a lower cost basis. However, selling covered calls is presented as a high-risk strategy that caps the stock's significant upside potential.

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • The host makes a clear distinction between holding Bitcoin in self-custody (a "cold wallet") and holding it on an exchange or through other financial products.
  • Self-Custody ("Pure Form Bitcoin"):
    • This is described as a crucial "insurance policy" or "schmuck insurance."
    • It provides unique protection that cannot be found elsewhere, such as security against bank failures (like the Silicon Valley Bank scare), government seizures, or the need to flee a country during a war.
    • The principle of "Not your keys, not your coins" is emphasized. Holding Bitcoin on platforms like Cash App or Coinbase does not provide this same level of freedom, as the host notes being limited to a $2,000 transfer on Cash App.
  • Investment View:
    • The host believes everyone should own some Bitcoin in a cold wallet for its insurance-like properties.
    • However, after establishing this baseline position, he sees less need to continuously add to it, preferring to gain further economic exposure through stocks like MSTR.
    • A long-term price prediction of $21 million per Bitcoin by 2045 is mentioned as a possibility.
    • The host is very skeptical of lending or "staking" pure Bitcoin due to the immaturity of the ecosystem and past failures like BlockFi, Celsius, and FTX.

Takeaways

  • Investors should consider their goals for owning Bitcoin. If the goal is ultimate financial sovereignty and insurance against systemic risk, holding BTC in a personal cold wallet is paramount.
  • For investors primarily seeking economic exposure to Bitcoin's price, vehicles like MSTR or Bitcoin ETFs may be more practical after an initial "insurance" position in a cold wallet is secured.
  • Lending or staking physical Bitcoin is presented as a high-risk activity at this time, given the lack of mature and trusted platforms.

Bitcoin-Related Equities (Investment Theme)

  • The podcast highlights a broader investment theme of gaining Bitcoin exposure through public companies. These fall into two categories:
    1. Pure-Play Treasury Companies: These companies' primary strategy is to acquire and hold Bitcoin.
      • Metaplanet (MTPLF): Mentioned as trading at a 3x NAV multiple.
      • SmarterWeb (No Ticker): Mentioned as trading at a very high 5x to 6x NAV multiple.
    2. Operating Companies with Bitcoin on the Balance Sheet: These are companies with an existing business that also choose to hold Bitcoin as a treasury asset.
      • Cooler (No Ticker): A space/battery company that holds Bitcoin. The host likes this because it creates a unique asset with two distinct value drivers (the operating business and the Bitcoin holdings).
      • Tesla (TSLA): Used as an example of how a company could become more interesting if it held more Bitcoin, providing a hedge for its core business.

Takeaways

  • An emerging investment strategy is to analyze companies based on their Bitcoin holdings.
  • Pure-play treasury companies like Metaplanet and SmarterWeb offer an alternative to MSTR, but currently trade at significantly higher valuations relative to their Bitcoin holdings. This could imply higher growth expectations or higher risk.
  • Investing in operating companies that hold Bitcoin (like Cooler) can be a form of diversification, as the investment's success is not solely tied to the price of Bitcoin.

Marathon Digital Holdings (MARA)

  • MARA is used as a valuation benchmark for MSTR.
  • The host refers to it as the (quote) "worst miner out there" that "a lot of people love to hate on."
  • Despite this negative sentiment, he notes that MARA briefly traded at 0.99x its Bitcoin NAV before bouncing back to a premium (mentioned as 1.2x NAV or a 20% premium).

Takeaways

  • MARA's valuation serves as a market sentiment indicator. The fact that even a less-favored Bitcoin-related stock trades at a premium to its underlying Bitcoin assets suggests strong investor demand for equity-based exposure to crypto.
  • This supports the argument that a premier company like MSTR is unlikely to see its valuation premium disappear entirely.

YieldMax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY)

  • The host has a strong negative opinion on this ETF.
  • He states MSTY is "definitely not for me" and is "way too expensive."
  • The primary criticism is its strategy of selling covered calls on MSTR. The host believes this is far too risky because it caps the massive upside potential of MSTR stock in exchange for a relatively small income stream.

Takeaways

  • Investors should be cautious with products like MSTY. While they offer income, they do so by sacrificing the potential for large capital gains, which is a primary reason many investors own a volatile asset like MSTR in the first place.
  • The host advocates for a "do-it-yourself" approach to options if an investor wants to generate income, specifically by selling puts instead of calls.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Video Description
Join Patreon for Exclusive Perks: https://www.patreon.com/btdenominator Common ATM Math Walkthrough: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UD67EQYV5hA Beat The Denominator is a channel whose goal is to Beat the dollar's inflation (i.e., beat the denominator). Therefore, I don't cover just inexpensive stocks: I also cover Bitcoin derivative stocks such as Strategy Stock (MSTR stock) and the preferred shares of STRK, STRD, and STRF, and today I especially cover Saylor's take on "stacking sats," and I counter with the idea of stacking MSTR stock. No Financial Advice!! As always, this video is NOT investment advice, and none of the contents should be construed as such. I do not make short-term or long-term price predictions for any stock investment, and all words spoken in this video are for entertainment purposes ONLY.
About Beat The Denominator
Beat The Denominator

Beat The Denominator

By @BeatTheDenominator