I bought this MSTR Preferred..What Could Possibly Compel me to Buy Perpetual Debt?!! Full Rationale.
I bought this MSTR Preferred..What Could Possibly Compel me to Buy Perpetual Debt?!! Full Rationale.
YouTube15 min 44 sec
Watch on YouTube
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

A specific MicroStrategy perpetual preferred stock offers a compelling dual investment opportunity with a current yield of 8.2%. The primary thesis is a bet on falling interest rates, which could cause the security's price to appreciate from $97 towards a target of $150-$200. This investment also provides long-term upside, as it becomes convertible into MSTR common stock if MSTR's price surpasses $1,000 per share. Unlike traditional bonds, this security is heavily collateralized by MicroStrategy's Bitcoin holdings, providing significant downside protection. This structure allows investors to capture potential gains from both interest rate cuts and MSTR's growth while receiving a steady income.

Detailed Analysis

MSTR Preferred Stock ("Strike")

The primary focus of the podcast is on a specific MicroStrategy perpetual preferred stock, which the speaker refers to as "Strike". The speaker has personally invested in this security.

  • Security Type: A perpetual preferred stock, which means it has no maturity date and is designed to pay a dividend indefinitely.
  • Current Price & Yield: The speaker bought it at $97, which is below its par value of $100. It pays a fixed annual dividend yield of 8.2% based on that purchase price.
  • Collateral & Safety: Unlike traditional bonds backed by future company earnings, this security is backed by Bitcoin (BTC) held on MicroStrategy's balance sheet. The value of the Bitcoin collateral is 5.5 times the amount of debt issued, providing a significant safety buffer. The market may view it as "junk," but the speaker argues this backing makes it much safer.
  • Volatility: This preferred stock is significantly less volatile than MicroStrategy's common stock (MSTR). The speaker notes it trades in a relatively stable range of approximately $100, plus or minus $20.

Takeaways

The investment thesis is described as a "dual bet" with two distinct ways to profit, making it a compelling hybrid investment.

  • 1. Short-to-Medium Term Bet on Interest Rate Cuts:

    • The main driver for this trade is the expectation that the Federal Reserve will begin cutting interest rates.
    • When interest rates fall, the price of assets paying a high, fixed yield (like this 8.2% preferred stock) typically increases. This is known as a "re-rating".
    • The speaker projects that as rates approach zero (potentially by 2028), the price of "Strike" could rise from $97 to between $150 and $200. This represents a potential 2x return from the rate-cut catalyst alone.
    • This part of the trade is a macro play on interest rates and is uncorrelated with the daily price movements of Bitcoin or MSTR.
  • 2. Long-Term Bet on MSTR's Upside:

    • The preferred stock includes a powerful feature: if MSTR common stock trades above $1,000 per share, the preferred becomes convertible into one-tenth (1/10th) of an MSTR share.
    • This allows the investor to capture the long-term upside of MSTR after it surpasses the $1,000 milestone. For example, if MSTR were to reach $5,000 per share, this preferred security would be worth at least $500 (1/10th of $5,000), in addition to the value of its yield.
    • This provides exposure to MSTR's massive growth potential (which is a proxy for Bitcoin's success) while offering the stability and income of a debt-like instrument.

MicroStrategy (MSTR)

The common stock of MicroStrategy is discussed as the alternative investment and the underlying equity for the preferred stock's long-term potential.

  • Current Price (at time of podcast): Approximately $358.
  • Sentiment: The speaker is extremely bullish on the long-term future of MSTR, suggesting it could become a multi-trillion dollar company based on its Bitcoin acquisition strategy.
  • Volatility: Acknowledged as being highly volatile, with price swings of "$100" around its base price of "$350".

Takeaways

Investing in the preferred stock ("Strike") instead of the common stock (MSTR) involves a clear trade-off.

  • The Opportunity Cost: By choosing the preferred stock, an investor forfeits the potential gains on MSTR common stock from its current price of ~$358 up to the $1,000 conversion price. This represents giving up a potential 2.79x return.
  • The Justification: The speaker argues this is a worthwhile trade because, in exchange for giving up that initial upside, an investor receives:
    • A separate, uncorrelated potential 2x return from the interest rate play.
    • Significant downside protection due to lower volatility and strong Bitcoin collateral.
    • A steady 8.2% annual dividend.
    • The ability to still capture the majority of the upside if MSTR becomes a "megabull" stock and rises far beyond $1,000.

Investment Strategy: Positive Carry with Margin

A more advanced and high-risk strategy discussed is using a margin loan to purchase the "Strike" preferred stock.

  • The Core Idea: The preferred stock's dividend yield (8.2%) is currently higher than the margin loan rates from brokers like Interactive Brokers (5.8%) and Webull (5.9%).
  • Positive Carry: This creates a "positive carry" arbitrage, where the dividend income received is greater than the interest cost of the loan used to buy the security. The dividend essentially pays for the margin loan, with profit left over.

Takeaways

This strategy becomes increasingly profitable as interest rates fall. Note: Using margin is a high-risk strategy and can lead to significant losses.

  • Amplified Returns in a Rate-Cutting Cycle:
    • While the 8.2% yield on the preferred stock is fixed for the investor, margin loan rates are variable and follow the Federal Reserve's policy rate.
    • The speaker predicts that as the Fed cuts rates, margin borrowing costs could fall to ~2% in the coming years.
    • This would dramatically widen the spread between the fixed 8.2% income and the ~2% loan cost, making the positive carry trade extremely profitable.
  • Margin Requirement: A current risk is the high margin maintenance requirement for this security (75%). The speaker speculates this could fall to a more manageable 25% after the security has been trading for a year, which would make the strategy more capital-efficient.
  • Overall View: The combination of price appreciation potential, long-term equity upside, and a positive carry margin opportunity leads the speaker to believe this trade is "almost as compelling as the MSTR common [stock]".
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Video Description
Join Patreon for Exclusive Perks: https://www.patreon.com/btdenominator Beat The Denominator is a channel whose goal is to Beat the dollar's inflation (i.e., beat the denominator). Therefore, I don't cover just inexpensive stocks: I also cover Bitcoin derivative stocks such as Strategy Stock (MSTR stock) and their preferred offerings, including the one I purchased today. No Financial Advice!! As always, this video is NOT investment advice, and none of the contents should be construed as such. I do not make short-term or long-term price predictions for any stock investment, and all words spoken in this video are for entertainment purposes ONLY.
About Beat The Denominator
Beat The Denominator

Beat The Denominator

By @BeatTheDenominator