Why This Crypto Cycle is Over | Michael Nadeau's DeFi Report #7
Why This Crypto Cycle is Over | Michael Nadeau's DeFi Report #7
200 days agoBankless
Podcast
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Given signs that the crypto bull cycle is likely over, investors should consider reducing risk, similar to the analyst's move to a 70% cash position. For Bitcoin (BTC), two consecutive weekly closes below the critical $102,000 level would be a strong signal that the bull market has ended. The bull case for Ethereum (ETH) reaching $8,500 is now unlikely due to its underperformance and a recent rally driven by excessive leverage. For those seeking ETH exposure through traditional stocks, BitDigital (BTBT) offers a proxy by holding and staking a large ETH treasury. Finally, monitor the AI stock sector, as a significant downturn there could trigger a crash across all risk assets, including crypto.

Detailed Analysis

Crypto Market Cycle

  • The primary analyst on the podcast, Michael Nadeau, has shifted to a "risk-off" stance, moving from a 20-25% cash position to a 70% cash position. He believes the current crypto bull cycle is likely over.
  • This view is based on several factors:
    • Late Cycle Timing: The current cycle is over 1,065 days long (measured from the November 2022 bottom), which is similar in length to the 2017 and 2021 cycles.
    • Weakening Fundamentals: The analyst observed low trading volumes, slowing ETF inflows for both Bitcoin and Ethereum, and a decrease in "animal spirits" in speculative ecosystems like Solana.
    • Excessive Leverage: Before the recent "flash crash," the market was tilted heavily towards risk with an all-time high leverage ratio in Ethereum futures. This leverage was not supported by strong underlying buying activity, creating a "wobbly house of cards."
    • Lack of New Catalysts: The analyst is having trouble identifying the next major catalyst that could push the market significantly higher.

Takeaways

  • Consider Reducing Risk: The primary sentiment is that the market is in a high-risk, late-cycle phase. Investors might consider taking some profits or reducing exposure to more speculative assets, similar to the analyst's move to a 70% cash position.
  • The Bear Case is Building: While not a certainty, the probability of a market top having already occurred is increasing. The "wealth distribution" phase, where long-term holders sell to new buyers, has been going on for 10 months.
  • The Next Bear Market May Be Different: Due to the long wealth distribution phase and new institutional holders, the next bear market could be less severe and establish a higher price floor than previous cycles.

Bitcoin (BTC)

  • The analyst's previous base case was for a cycle top in Q4 2025 with a Bitcoin price of $150,000. However, he has now moved away from this view.
  • A key indicator of long-term holder sentiment, Realized Profits, shows that $900 billion in profits have been taken this cycle. This is nearly double the $500 billion taken in the entire last cycle, suggesting significant selling has already occurred from early investors.
  • The bull market structure is considered weakened but not fully broken. A critical level to watch is the 50-week moving average, which is currently around $102,000.
  • A counter-argument for a continued bull run is the "Gold Catch-up Trade." With gold hitting all-time highs, some believe "digital gold" (Bitcoin) could follow, though the analyst notes the historical correlation is very low.

Takeaways

  • Watch the $102k Level: The 50-week moving average is a critical support level. If Bitcoin has two consecutive weekly closes below $102,000, it would be a very strong signal that the bull market is over.
  • The "Easy Money" May Be Gone: With early investors having already sold $900 billion worth of Bitcoin, the question is who the next marginal buyer will be to push prices significantly higher.
  • Strength in Consolidation: If Bitcoin can continue to hold its ground above $100k-$102k despite the selling pressure, it could build a strong base for a potential next leg up, should a new catalyst (like a "Trump money cannon" or major liquidity event) emerge.

Ethereum (ETH)

  • The analyst's previous base case for an Ethereum peak was around $8,500 - $8,700, with a bull case of $10,000. This was based on the assumption of a $150,000 Bitcoin.
  • The recent run-up in ETH price was heavily fueled by leverage. The ETH futures estimated leverage ratio hit an all-time high, meaning there was nearly one dollar of leverage for every one dollar of actual ETH on exchanges.
  • Unlike Bitcoin, Ethereum has had a muted cycle in terms of profit-taking. Realized profits for ETH this cycle are $206 billion, which is actually less than the $220 billion from the last cycle.
  • This suggests ETH has underperformed relative to Bitcoin (ETH/BTC ratio remains low) and has not had the same kind of bull run that many expected.

Takeaways

  • The Bull Case for ETH is Weaker: With the analyst now risk-off on the broader market, the $8,500 price target is no longer the base case and seems unlikely without a major market reversal.
  • A Disappointing Cycle for Holders: Many ETH investors feel the cycle has been disappointing, as it never reached the "euphoric" stage and has underperformed Bitcoin. This sentiment itself can paralyze the market.
  • Potential for a Catch-Up?: The fact that ETH hasn't had its "run" is what gives some bulls hope. If the cycle does extend, ETH could have more room to grow than Bitcoin. However, this is dependent on the overall market cycle not being over.

Investment Themes & Other Assets

BitDigital (BTBT)

  • BitDigital is a publicly traded company mentioned as a way to gain exposure to Ethereum through the stock market.
  • The company transitioned from Bitcoin mining to becoming an "ETH treasury company," holding over 150,000 ETH.
  • They stake all of their ETH holdings on institutional-grade validators.

Takeaways

  • For investors who prefer traditional brokerage accounts, BTBT is presented as a stock that provides direct exposure to the price of ETH plus the added benefit of staking yields.

AI Stocks

  • The AI sector is seen as a massive driver of the entire traditional stock market and U.S. economy.
  • The performance of AI stocks is fueling broader risk-on sentiment.

Takeaways

  • A Major Systemic Risk: The podcast suggests a simple thesis: "If the AI bubble pops, it's over." A significant downturn in major AI stocks would likely cause a crash in other risk assets, including crypto. Investors should monitor the health of the AI sector as a key macro indicator.

Stock Picker's Market

  • This cycle was unique because some of the best returns came from crypto-related stocks, not just crypto assets.
  • Companies like Coinbase (COIN), Robinhood (HOOD), and others have, at times, outperformed Bitcoin itself.

Takeaways

  • Broaden Your Horizon: To fully capture gains in this crypto cycle, an investor needed to look beyond just on-chain assets and consider publicly traded "proxy" stocks. This may be a continuing trend for future cycles.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Is the crypto cycle already over, or is this just a reset before one last push? Michael Nadeau from The DeFi Report joins Ryan to break down why he went 70% cash ahead of the flash crash, what late-cycle data he’s watching, and the signals that would flip him back risk on. We dig into Bitcoin’s 50-week moving average, ETH’s $8–10K scenarios, slowing ETF flows, rising leverage, and whether global liquidity and AI could still drive a melt-up. Michael explains why this cycle has felt muted, what would confirm a top, and how he’s positioning into year-end. Michael Nadeau & The DeFi Report: https://x.com/JustDeauIt https://thedefireport.io/ ------ 📣BIT DIGITAL ($BTBT) | ETH-FIRST PUBLIC COMPAN https://bankless.cc/bit-digital We’re being compensated by Bit Digital (NASDAQ BTBT) for this segment promoting their company and BTBT. The compensation is paid in cash as a one time payment. You can find  ------ BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS: 🪙FRAXNET | MINT, REDEEM, EARN  https://bankless.cc/fraxnet 🦄UNISWAP | SWAP ON UNICHAIN https://bankless.cc/unichain 🛞MANTLE | MODULAR L2 NETWORK https://bankless.cc/Mantle 🌳KGEN | REQUEST A DEMO  https://bankless.cc/KGEN-podcast 💠BIT DIGITAL ($BTBT) | ETH TREASURY  https://bankless.cc/bit-digital We’re being compensated by Bit Digital (NASDAQ BTBT) for this segment promoting their company and BTBT. The compensation is paid in cash as a one time payment. You can find additional information about Bit Digital and BTBT on their Investor page at https://bit-digital.com/investors ------ TIMESTAMPS & RESOURCES 0:00 Intro 0:48 Crypto Cycle: Is It Over? Mike's Risk-Off Strategy  https://thedefireport.io/research/portfolio-update 2:15 Flash Crash Insights  3:14 Crypto Investor Profiles  https://thedefireport.io/ 5:40 Understanding Market Cycles  https://thedefireport.io/research/cycle-awareness-update#fear-greed-index 7:34 Late Cycle Analysis  https://thedefireport.io/research/cycle-awareness-update#fear-greed-index 12:41 Shifting to Risk Off  https://thedefireport.io/research/portfolio-update 18:54 On-Chain Data Insights  https://thedefireport.io/research/where-might-eth-top#scenario-analysis-for-eth 21:47 Stages of the Cycle https://thedefireport.io/research/cycle-awareness-update#fear-greed-index 26:12 Wealth Distribution Phase https://thedefireport.io/research/cycle-awareness-update#fear-greed-index 28:15 Realized Profits Comparison  https://thedefireport.io/research/cycle-awareness-update#fear-greed-index 32:00 Global Liquidity Discussion  https://x.com/RaoulGMI/status/1977140156386660654  https://x.com/RaoulGMI/status/1977498706510487748 33:52 Gold vs. Bitcoin  https://x.com/merlijntrader/status/1978793051062509966 1:01:52 The Shittiest Bull Market Ever  https://x.com/cryptorbion/status/1979614717707489461 1:08:31 What Would Change Mike's Mind? https://www.coinglass.com/bull-market-peak-signals 1:17:14 Future of the DeFi Report  https://thedefireport.io/research/portfolio-update  https://thedefireport.io/ ------ Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
About Bankless
Bankless

Bankless

The Ultimate Guide to Crypto Finance. DeFi, NFTs, and cryptocurrencies. Level up. Go bankless.