Where is ETH in the cycle? | Michael Nadeau
Where is ETH in the cycle? | Michael Nadeau
59 days agoBankless
Podcast56 min 52 sec
Listen to Episode
Note: AI-generated summary based on third-party content. Not financial advice. Read more.
Quick Insights

Maintain Bitcoin (BTC) as your core portfolio anchor, as it remains the primary benchmark that other crypto assets must outperform to justify the higher risk. For Ethereum (ETH), the current price is considered "Fair Value," but investors should wait for "Deep Value" entries at $1,500 or below to maximize potential returns. Monitor the ETH/BTC ratio closely; if ETH cannot prove it can outperform BTC, it is safer to remain in the latter until a clear breakout base forms. Watch for the passage of the Clarity Act, which could serve as a major catalyst by allowing traditional finance to launch stablecoins on the Ethereum network. For high-velocity retail speculation, Solana (SOL) is the preferred alternative, while Galaxy (GLXY) offers institutional exposure to the intersection of crypto and AI infrastructure.

Detailed Analysis

Ethereum (ETH)

The discussion centered on Ethereum’s performance during the current market cycle, its shifting roadmap, and how to determine its "fair value" amidst a period of price stagnation relative to previous cycles.

  • Diminishing Returns: Analysts noted that ETH's growth has slowed significantly across cycles:
    • Cycle 1 (2017): 175x return from trough to peak.
    • Cycle 2 (2021): 61x return.
    • Current Cycle (2024/2025): Only 5.6x return (peaking near $4,953).
  • The "L2 Side Quest": A primary reason for ETH's recent underperformance is the shift to Layer 2 (L2) scaling (e.g., Optimism, Arbitrum).
    • Ethereum "disrupted itself" by making transactions cheap on L2s, which caused fee revenue on the main Layer 1 (L1) to collapse.
    • The market perceived this as a loss of value accrual for the ETH token.
  • Roadmap Pivot: There is a renewed focus on scaling the L1 directly and bringing DeFi activity back to the main chain to drive value to the asset.
  • Staking Economics: Despite low fees, ETH remains healthy.
    • Annualized issuance is approximately 0.83%, similar to Bitcoin.
    • Even with low "organic" revenue, the network is not highly inflationary, supporting a "Store of Value" thesis.

Takeaways

  • Fair Value vs. Deep Value: ETH is currently viewed as being in a "Fair Value" zone around $2,000. "Deep Value" (a high-conviction buying opportunity) is estimated at $1,500 and below.
  • The "Nation-State" Model: Investors should view ETH as the currency of a digital nation. Its value is derived from the "GDP" on top of it (stablecoins, TVL) rather than just transaction fees.
  • Performance Benchmark: For ETH to be a "buy," it must prove it can outperform BTC. While it underperformed this cycle, its "higher low" on the charts suggests it is building a base for a potential breakout in 2027.

Bitcoin (BTC)

While the episode focused on Ethereum, Bitcoin remains the "anchor" asset for the discussed portfolio strategy.

  • The Benchmark: BTC is the primary hurdle for any other crypto investment. If an asset (like ETH) cannot outperform BTC, the analyst prefers holding BTC.
  • Market Sentiment: The analyst is currently "Risk On" but cautious, favoring BTC over "altcoins" (including ETH) until deeper value entries appear.
  • Cycle Timing: BTC is expected to show further weakness or "choppy" behavior through 2026 before the next major expansion phase.

Takeaways

  • Portfolio Anchor: Maintain BTC as the core holding while waiting for specific "buy signals" (fat pitches) to move down the risk curve into other assets.
  • Valuation Metric: Use the 200-week moving average and MVRV (Market Value to Realized Value) to identify cycle bottoms.

Investment Themes & Sectors

Stablecoins

  • Ethereum's Dominance: ETH hosts over $180 billion in stablecoins (roughly 60% of the total market).
  • Bullish Indicator: The fact that stablecoin supply on Ethereum remained steady while prices dropped suggests a strong, sticky "economy" that the market hasn't fully priced in yet.
  • Regulatory Catalyst: The "Clarity Act" (pending legislation) could allow traditional finance (TradFi) to launch more stablecoins, likely on Ethereum.

Solana (SOL)

  • The Competitor: Solana captured the "speculative" and "high-velocity" retail interest this cycle due to lower fees.
  • Differentiation: ETH is evolving into a "Slow DeFi" chain for high-value settlement, while SOL is the "High-Velocity" chain.

Traditional Finance (TradFi) Integration

  • Galaxy (GLXY): Mentioned as a key institutional player bridging crypto and AI infrastructure.
  • BitGet: Highlighted as a platform merging crypto trading with traditional assets like gold and stocks, signaling the "Universal Exchange" trend.

Risk Factors

  • L2 Fragmentation: The user experience of moving between different Layer 2 networks is still "broken" and needs to be fused together for ETH to regain its momentum.
  • Macro Headwinds: Rising oil rates, sticky inflation, and geopolitical risks create a "stagflationary" environment that is generally bearish for high-risk assets like crypto.
  • Lack of "Breakout Apps": While existing apps (like Uniswap) moved to L2s, no major new consumer application has launched to drive massive new demand.
Ask about this postAnswers are grounded in this post's content.
Episode Description
Ethereum underperformed this cycle, and investors are asking the big question: did ETH just skip a cycle, or is something deeper going on? Michael Nadeau joins Ryan to break down where Ethereum sits in the market cycle today, why several of his key indicators suggest ETH is entering a fair value zone, and whether the true macro bottom could still lie ahead. They also unpack why ETH struggled despite improving fundamentals. Mike explains how Ethereum’s L2 roadmap may have improved the network while weakening short-term value capture for the asset itself, and what signals he’s watching (MVRV, supply in profit, the 200-week moving average) as he looks for the next expansion phase. Michael Nadeau & The DeFi Report: https://x.com/JustDeauIt https://thedefireport.io/ --- 📣GALAXY | INSTITUTIONAL DIGITAL FINANCE https://bankless.cc/Galaxy --- BANKLESS SPONSOR TOOLS: 🔮POLYMARKET | #1 PREDICTION MARKET https://bankless.cc/polymarket-podcast  🪐GALAXY | INSTITUTIONAL DIGITAL FINANCE https://bankless.cc/galaxy-podcast  🏅BITGET TRADFI | TRADE GOLD WITH USDT https://bankless.cc/bitget 🎯THE DEFI REPORT | ONCHAIN INSIGHTS https://thedefireport.io/bankless 🌍 WORLD | FULLY ONCHAIN EXCHANGE https://bankless.cc/world --- TIMESTAMPS 0:00 Intro 3:50 The History of ETH Cycles 5:41 Analyzing Performance Trends 8:32 The Impact of L2 Roadmap 10:24 Roadmap Decisions & Market Perception 15:50 Valuation Metrics Explained 20:08 Disparities in Valuation Methods 23:22 Navigating Market Conditions 26:14 Nation-State Metaphor & Valuation 27:45 Revenue and Economic Impact 33:42 DEX Volumes & Their Implications 37:25 Stablecoin Supply on Ethereum 38:09 Cycle Metrics & Analysis 44:22 Fair Market Value Insights 50:40 Evaluating ETH for the Portfolio --- Not financial or tax advice. See our investment disclosures here: https://www.bankless.com/disclosures
About Bankless
Bankless

Bankless

The Ultimate Guide to Crypto Finance. DeFi, NFTs, and cryptocurrencies. Level up. Go bankless.